Pin 13 requires an oracle committed and reviewed before any candidate is
scored against it. Both halves land here, before C1 or C2 exists, so
neither candidate can shape what it will be measured by.
round2-candidatekit is the only code the two candidates share. It loads
and validates Packet 2A's fixtures, probe table, reference rasters and
regions; it renders nothing, resolves no hit test, and builds no
accessibility node -- a dependency deny-list test reads its own manifest
at test time to keep it that way, including the dotted-subtable and
target-cfg forms a line scanner would otherwise miss. Check 3 is pinned
NOT RUN by the recipe's 1.2 ruling: a report claiming Pass or Fail for it
is refused, and the supplementary F-D field is one the scoring function
never reads, so it cannot reach the criterion cell by construction rather
than by convention. A check-5 NOT RUN now requires typed evidence that the
platform bus was unreachable, because Round 0 already proved it reachable
for both candidates -- "we did not build it" is scope, and scope is not
environmental.
round2-a11y-oracle derives every byte string a live AT-SPI readback must
compare against, from the digest-validated fixtures alone: the expected
name three ways, the at-spi2 role sets, a precommitted alternative form
per prohibited outcome, the visual-order form, and the per-segment source
atoms. The fixtures digest is unchanged at acc13c0d, so Packet 2A stays
frozen.
verify.py gains a check-5 mode whose classifier is a pure function, unit
tested without a bus, and which fails closed on platform, digest, fixture
completeness, the name/hex/length triple, atom concatenation, and any
string that would classify as two different outcomes.
The scoring policy, settled over eight review rounds and worth stating
because most of it was won by finding the opposite in the code first:
- An accepted-role exact match wins from anywhere in the forest. It used
to be first-match, so tree order decided a disqualifying check.
- Composition is scoped to one run subtree and outranks any per-node
diagnosis. Application-wide concatenation both passed a run half-drawn
as a canvas and failed a correct split run because the window carried
a label.
- Contributor order stays significant, since 8.1 requires logical order;
only non-contributor order is required not to matter.
- name-empty means an attempted static-text exposure without a name.
absent-from-tree means a drawing-only or unrelated tree, and nothing
else -- it is the outcome 8.3 says this check will most likely catch,
and it was nearly unreachable while gated on role presence.
- A byte-exact PASS outranks an alternative-form match. F-C's
"drops unresolved codepoints" form is its own first segment, so a
legitimate per-run split was being failed on a check that eliminates.
That collision is structural for any two-segment fixture with one
unresolved segment, not an F-C accident.
Recorded as a finding, not fixed: the recipe's claim that visual-order
assembly diverges for F-D "and only there" is false -- F-B diverges too,
and any non-palindromic RTL run of two or more graphemes will. F-D's real
distinguishing property is an interior RTL run. The same stale wording is
compiled into fixtures.json and covered by its frozen digest, so
correcting it would move acc13c0d out from under Packet 2A.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01RSX4zSLgKvtiXaPjnMqLGz
Levi Neuwirth
694d135bfc