Review follow-up on fc411ea. Finding 1 was correct and was mine to own: I wrote
"every primitive -- glyph, stroke, and curve alike -- MUST declare a
VerticalBandId" and placed it in the ResolvedLayoutIR section, where the adjacent
ResolvedGlyph listing has no such field. Under a literal read the implementation
was non-conforming against a requirement I had just added.
The rule belongs to the stage that has the obligation. req:layoutir:primitive-
band-ownership moves to Ch7 §ConstrainedLayoutIR §Vertical Bands and is scoped to
"every primitive the projection presents to the solver". A new companion,
req:layoutir:resolved-band-ownership, says what survives: a resolved Stroke/Curve
MUST retain its band (casting-off and the inter-staff solve both relocate them
and must attribute them), while a ResolvedGlyph carries none -- its ownership is
consumed during the solve and already baked into its resolved position, so the
field would be dead weight in a rendering fingerprint. That requirement also
carries the non-canonical clause: canonical_bytes omits vertical_band even from
the primitives that do retain it.
Finding 2: the ConstrainedLayoutIR listing gains strokes/curves. They have been
in the code since staff lines and were never listed -- so an implementation
following Chapter 7 could not have supplied non-glyph ownership to the solver at
all, which makes this the listing gap that actually blocked the new MUST.
Finding 3: the ratification trail now records the tranche -- a revision-history
row and a PASS12 log section naming both requirements, the three listing
corrections, the two commits, and the fact that adopting it churned no golden
(the declared owner agrees with the inferred one across the corpus, which is what
licensed the swap).
The log also records a pre-existing listing gap I found while checking my own
citations: ConstrainedLayoutIR still elides break_origins and catalog. I had
first written that neither is named anywhere in core_spec, then verified and
found both types ARE specified (req:layoutir:break-origin-attribution; Ch7 §Glyph
Catalog Identity) -- only the struct listing is incomplete, and unlike
strokes/curves neither gap blocks an implementation. Left as a Pass-13 candidate
rather than widened into this tranche.
Spec rebuilds clean: no LaTeX errors, no undefined references, both new labels
registered. Workspace 30/30, conformance 8/8; no Rust changed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Levi Neuwirth
ced4b7255e