The final whole-artifact check returned zero findings. Ratified on the
authority of the repository owner. Contract status: RATIFIED, PINS FROZEN --
executed, not edited; a defect found during execution is reported as its own
amendment with its own review round. NOT YET DISPATCHED: ratification and
dispatch are separate acts and no execution has begun. The status line states
no count of the review passes, per the rule this contract adopted after its own
tallies went stale twice.
Two of the ledger row's own claims did not survive scoping, and the row is
appended -- never rewritten -- with both corrections. The doc comment's G3a
aside is ambiguous, not false: G3a's pin 6 is titled "doc-only" and 6c5e69f
wrote the aside, so "this prose" is self-referential. The row's "claims a
specification repair that never landed" reading is withdrawn, and with it the
"only artifact pointing at the gap" rationale. The two-sided repair stands on a
different footing: the normative enumeration and the doc comment are incomplete
mirrors of each other, incomplete in different places, so neither may be
repaired from the other. The surface is derived from the check bodies instead --
41 tokens, each carrying its resolution target and a symbolic code anchor.
Review scaffolding, applied earlier under a narrow authorization and committed
here because ratification is what changes its staging state: two
DISCUSSED_NOT_CITED rows in requirement_labels.rs. The citation scan reads the
filesystem rather than git, so this contract naming two not-yet-existing labels
broke the mandated green baseline for three review passes before it was
measured. The req:graph: row is permanent -- it never becomes a requirement and
survives only in M6's evidence. The req:time: row is temporary, deleted by pin 4
when the requirement lands, because at that moment its own claim ("discussed,
never cited") turns false; gate 12 checks that deletion, since a stale row is
inert and nothing else would catch it.
The rung also files two candidates it does not repair: P13-S29, the invariant-10
tag multiplexing Chapter 3/4 failures through a public API and its Display; and
P13-S30, the repository-wide assumption that TeX is spelled exactly, which
misses \label {x}, \begin {requirement}, \end {requirement} and \chapter {X}.
S30 carries four consequences with the conditions under which each is silent or
loud -- three of them silent only conditionally, two distinct panic paths, and a
full inventory of the ten known consumer sites across three files, all
test-scope.
Baseline unchanged at 1583 passing across 42 suites; clippy and the pinned
four-crate fmt gate clean on 1.95.0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Ps1szk2mSfgp4Cz21eVH9x
Levi Neuwirth
01c621d64e