docs(lane): retract the "mechanism located" claim --- it was unsupported
a92ef7f said the mechanism was located: the launcher blocked in `do_wait` on a GPU probe child stuck in `futex_do_wait`. Checking the instrument against the claim shows it does not support it. The sampler caught 394 distinct launchers across a reproducing sweep and the longest-lived was 5s TOTAL. For this test to fail, a launcher must outlive its SIGINT by 5s, so its lifetime would be 8s or more. The failing instance was never captured. What I described is a healthy launcher from one of the suite's other tests --- the normal teardown shape, reported as the defect. This is the same error as the `available`-memory reading earlier in this lane: a measurement that looked conclusive, reported before checking that it discriminated. Retracted here rather than left to be found. Two facts do survive and constrain the next attempt: `pmacs-gpu` installs no signal handling at all, so the probe should die on SIGINT's default action; and its main loop is a 50ms `recv_timeout`, so it never blocks indefinitely. The next instrument must key on the failing instance --- launchers outliving ~6s, or a PID recorded by the test itself --- rather than sampling every launcher and hoping. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
This commit is contained in:
parent
a4117adef8
commit
c1cc98ad5a
|
|
@ -478,21 +478,33 @@ from #171 and #215.
|
|||
`ctrl_c_on_launcher_group_does_not_reach_spawned_daemon`. **This
|
||||
branch is not implicated**, and no branch can pass this gate stage
|
||||
on this machine until the underlying defect is fixed.
|
||||
- **MECHANISM LOCATED, by sampling the process table twice a second
|
||||
through a reproducing sweep.** After the test SIGINTs the
|
||||
launcher's process group:
|
||||
- **MECHANISM STILL NOT ESTABLISHED. The "located" claim below was
|
||||
RETRACTED on its own evidence** — read this before trusting it.
|
||||
A process-table sampler ran through a reproducing sweep and caught
|
||||
394 distinct launchers, but the **longest-lived was 5s total**. For
|
||||
this test to fail, a launcher must outlive its SIGINT by 5s, so its
|
||||
total lifetime would be 8s or more. **The failing instance was
|
||||
therefore never captured**, and the `do_wait`/`futex_do_wait` pair
|
||||
below is a healthy launcher from one of the suite's other tests,
|
||||
not the one that blew the deadline. The observation is kept only
|
||||
as a description of the NORMAL teardown shape.
|
||||
- Provisional and unconfirmed, from that sampler:
|
||||
- `pmacs --gpu --socket …` (the launcher) sits in **`do_wait`** for
|
||||
the full 5s — it is waiting on a child, not ignoring the signal;
|
||||
- `pmacs-gpu --headless-managed-probe …` (its child, same process
|
||||
group, so it received the SIGINT too) sits in
|
||||
**`futex_do_wait`** and never exits.
|
||||
|
||||
So the deadline is missed because the GPU probe child does not tear
|
||||
down under SIGINT, and the launcher blocks on it. **The next step
|
||||
is the probe's shutdown path**, not the test's timeout — raising
|
||||
the 5s would only hide it. Why the child hangs *only* in a complete
|
||||
sweep is still open; every prior GPU suite in the run has already
|
||||
exercised the adapter by then, which is where to look first.
|
||||
That is what a HEALTHY teardown looks like; it is not evidence
|
||||
about the failing one. Two facts do survive and constrain the next
|
||||
attempt: `pmacs-gpu` installs **no signal handling whatsoever**
|
||||
(grep for SIGINT/signal_hook/sigaction across `pmacs-gpu/src`
|
||||
returns nothing), so the probe should die on SIGINT's default
|
||||
action; and the probe's main loop is a 50ms `recv_timeout`, so it
|
||||
is never blocked indefinitely. **The next instrument must key on
|
||||
the failing instance specifically** — sample only launchers whose
|
||||
lifetime exceeds ~6s, or have the test itself record the PID and
|
||||
timing — rather than sampling every launcher and hoping.
|
||||
- **Five further explanations were tested and REFUTED.** Recorded so
|
||||
nobody re-runs them:
|
||||
- *Machine load*: refuted. Red on a quiet machine (load 2.77 at
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Reference in New Issue