Stage 3 step 2 (Q#S3-1). DEFAULT-PRESERVING WITH ONE INTENTIONAL
NORMALIZATION — not "behaviour-preserving", which would be too broad a
claim. Every adopter keeps its current default, and the full serialized
suite is 3447 passed / 0 failed with ZERO suites differing from the
pre-change baseline. But invalid-input behaviour DID move, deliberately,
and that is pinned rather than asserted in prose.
Before this, FOUR adopters validated the same three-value vocabulary in
four places: Rust for the terminal, and hand-written Lua copies in
listview.lua, compile.lua and dired.lua, each carrying its own copy of
the error string. `parse_adopter_placement` read like the shared parser
its doc comment implied but had exactly one caller. Four copies of one
rule is how the next adopter gets it subtly wrong, and the next adopter
is DAP.
`resolve_adopter_display(operation, raw, default)` now owns exactly
three things: the vocabulary, the error text, and the default policy.
Reachable from Lua as the internal seam `pmacs.window._resolve_display`.
THE DEFAULT IS A PARAMETER, NOT A CONSTANT, and that is load-bearing
rather than stylistic. listview/compile/terminal will resolve omission
to the panel in step 3; DIRED MUST NOT, because
`pmacs.path.set_directory_handler` calls it with `{ dest = dest }` and
no `display` key at all — a flipped default would open `pmacs .` in a
bottom panel. Passing the default in makes dired's exemption visible at
its call site instead of hidden in a divergent copy.
TERMINAL'S `window` MUTUAL-EXCLUSION STAYS IN ITS OWN WRAPPER. Only the
terminal accepts a `window` id and only it must reject `window` combined
with `display = "panel"`. A helper pretending the four parsers were
identical would be its own defect.
THE NORMALIZATION, DECIDED AND PINNED. Terminal read
`get::<Option<String>>("display")?`, so a non-string value raised mlua's
TYPE error before reaching any custom message, while the Lua copies
stringified it into their own. Nothing pinned either behaviour — every
existing assertion passes an unknown STRING, which takes the same path
under both designs and therefore could not have caught a regression
here. The custom error wins because it names the legal vocabulary; the
value is rendered by TYPE ALONE (`unknown display (integer)`) so the
message cannot imply a string was passed.
Pinned at the terminal entry point in acc19 — the one adopter whose
behaviour changed — asserting the shared error AND that nothing is
created. The type SPELLING is deliberately not pinned: Lua 5.4 says
`integer` where LuaJIT has no integer subtype, so asserting either
literal would pass on one CI flavor and fail on the other. Verified
46/46 under both.
COMPILE NEEDED AN EXPLICIT OMISSION CAPTURE, and finding that out is
what this step is for. The resolver collapses omission into its default,
but compile's recompile gate distinguishes them: it fires on OMISSION
only, never on an explicit `display = "current"`, which is the
documented opt-out and must reach the raw switch even when the previous
run was panel-placed. Resolving first and testing `== "current"`
afterwards would have silently merged the two and broken the opt-out
with every test still green. `display_omitted` is captured before the
resolver call and the gate keys on it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Implements `docs/journey-stage1b1-compile-defaults-framing.md`
(approved at revision 2). Lua, tests and docs; no Rust change and no
protocol change.
`C-c c` now runs `compile.run`, and the first prompt is prefilled from
the detected project kind through `pmacs.compile.defaults` — seeded
`rust = "cargo build"` and extensible from `init.lua`. `_last` still
wins, so a session that has compiled keeps its own command.
The prompt CAPTURES its directory rather than re-resolving it. Sharing
one resolver between the prompt and the run is necessary and not
sufficient: `pmacs.minibuffer.read` is asynchronous and nothing freezes
the active window while a prompt is open, so two calls to the same
resolver at two different moments are still two different answers — the
user could be offered `cargo build` for A and handed a run in B by
clicking away mid-prompt. This is Journey Stage 1a's `commit_to`
discipline on a smaller seam.
`pmacs.compile.defaults` is public and assignable, so the lookup is
guarded: a throwing `__index`, a non-string entry and a non-table
replacement all degrade to the pre-stage empty prompt and never
prevent compiling.
Only `rust` ships seeded. Rust has one answer; npm/yarn/pnpm,
make/cmake, and `go build` versus `go test` do not, and a wrong prefill
costs more than an empty one.
Adds eight step-9 rows to the journey ratchet and five module pins to
the compile suite. Corrects `COHERENCE.md`, which named a
`ProjectKind::Cargo` that does not exist — the variant is `Rust`, line
77 is its doc comment, and Lua only ever sees the tag string "rust".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
PR #155 review round 2.
Finding 1 (must fix): Q#BP7 item 1 — "growth reaching the live tail
re-arms follow (top -> None), only when no selection is active" — was
never implemented. `at_bottom` is the instantaneous geometric readout
`scroll_offset == 0`, which a still-anchored view satisfies whenever it
happens to be tall enough to reach the tail, so the round-1 assertion
could not see the gap: the next rows the child printed pushed the
anchored view back into history.
`rearm_follow_on_growth` now clears `top` when a viewport-size
declaration makes the view cover the tail and no selection is frozen,
and every size-declaring path (`snapshot_for_view`, `record_view_size`,
`view_status_for_size`) routes through one `declare_view_size` helper so
grid and semantic declarations cannot disagree. `scroll_view` and
`begin_selection` deliberately stay out: they write `top` themselves,
and `scroll_view` already owns the scroll-driven arm.
New acc32b is the pin the review asked for: scroll into history, grow
past the tail, then release a SECOND burst of child output through a
filesystem gate and assert the view moved with it.
Finding 2: the PTY fixtures emitted LF-only output, which staircases
rightward until every row clips to blanks past the viewport width — so
the round-1 anchor assertions compared "" with "" and could not fail.
Both fixtures now emit CRLF, and each anchor comparison is guarded by
`assert!(!top_before.is_empty())`.
Finding 3: acc33's contrast case asserted nothing, and the behavior it
claimed was false as coded. With the re-arm in place it is true and now
asserted: clearing the selection at the same geometry re-arms follow and
leaves the frozen anchor.
Finding 4: `start_run` gated the panel branch on `display == "panel" or
already_in_panel(..)`, so an explicit `display = "current"` lost to the
inference — and that value is the documented user-facing opt-out from
the Stage 3 default flip. Now gated on OMISSION. acc19b gains the
explicit-"current" case.
Finding 5: `window_drag` is a `HashMap<FrontendId, WindowDragState>`, so
a peer's mode-line press can no longer steal or clear another
frontend's in-flight gesture, and concurrent drags are legal. Cleared on
detach. acc30c gains the mode-line-press case.
Minor: `pmacs.window.buffer()` resolves both arms through the acting
frontend using the shared `lookup_window` / `selected_window` validators
rather than re-implementing them beside an ambient `active_buffer_id()`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
PR #155 review round 1.
Finding 1 (must fix): `try_split_active` had no production caller —
`pmacs.window.split_horizontal` / `split_vertical`, and therefore
`C-x 2` / `C-x 3`, still went through plain `split_active`. Splitting a
focused panel made the root wrapper's final child a split rather than
`Leaf(side)`, which both `Layout::compute`'s fixed pass and
`document_subtree` key on: the panel band reverted to 1:1 weight
division and an ordinary window ended up living inside it. Both bindings
now route through the guard, and acc26 asserts through the real Lua
path — a direct core call passes with the guard unwired, which is how it
survived the first round.
Finding 2: the armed-drag early return now checks the arming frontend,
so one frontend's in-flight gesture cannot cancel or swallow another's
mouse events. New acc30c.
Finding 3: `paint_mode_line_graphemes`'s doc block was left heading
`paint_divider_segment`; moved back.
Finding 4: a recompile carries no `display`, so it took the raw switch
and duplicated a panel-placed `*compilation*` into the document window.
`start_run` now detects that the buffer already owns the panel slot.
`pmacs.window.buffer` gained an optional window argument so an adopter
can ask without selecting the panel first. New acc19b.
Stage-2 hazard pins the review asked for, both in `src/daemon.rs`:
a fresh attach while LOCAL is focused in a panel inherits LOCAL's
document buffer, and an initial-target bootstrap whose `after-load`
hook creates and selects a panel still reasserts into a document window.
Minor: dropped listview's dead `p.side`; documented `focus_window`'s
caller-validates contract; `jump_back` restores through `focus_window`
so the "every focus change" contract holds; `params` / `resize` default
to the acting frontend's selected window rather than the ambient one;
widened the flexible-division math to u64 intermediates.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- `listview.open`, `compile.run`, and `pmacs.terminal.open` all take the
same strict `display = "current" | "panel"`, validated before any
buffer, session, process, or wrapper exists. Omission keeps today's
behavior; Stage 3 flips the default.
- `listview.quit` / `compile.quit` delegate to `window.quit` only when
the buffer really is in a side window, so the presentation is deleted
or restored instead of leaving a source buffer stranded in the slot.
- LSP `visit_location`, LSP go-to-definition, and compile `visit_error`
route through `display_file`, so a visit from a panel lands in the
document target and fires its hook with that window active.
- `window.quit`'s Delete arm focuses the revalidated remembered origin.
- Capability fallback discards an accompanying `height` rather than
rejecting the call.
- `window.min-height` clamps a below-floor value on read instead of
refusing the write.
- `tests/bottom_panel_stage1_acceptance.rs`: 42 tests over the framing's
Stage 1 criteria, including the two production `Layout::compute`
callers, the recursive minima, hide/reappear, the final-focus matrix,
quit chains at the depth cap, per-frontend jump origins, the divider,
and a real-PTY pin of Bet B1.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Finding-by-finding (framing revision 11; bites via scripts/bite
against 6793edc):
1. Style-span coordinate translation belongs to the BUFFER. A new
BufferStyleSpanTranslator is attached by
pmacs.buffer.add_style_overlay and sees every edit exactly once —
bypass writes, undo/redo, remote CRDT ops — independent of window
count or visibility; the window-attached BufferStyleOverlay
copies are render-only (on_edit removed). Pre-fix each attached
view translated the shared store: start_run's explicit attach
duplicated the after-switch hook's (switch_buffer fires it
synchronously), so the normal path shifted later spans TWICE per
byte-delta rewrite, splits multiplied further, and a hidden
buffer shifted ZERO times. The redundant attach is removed;
correctness no longer depends on attachment discipline. Bites:
per-cell rendered assertions active (red a, blue bc, CR, red é →
é red, b/c blue) and hidden (run finishes with the buffer in no
window; switch back renders true colors); three direct units pin
exactly-once with extra render views attached.
2. Translation preserves the untouched fragments of a partially
overlapped span: left of the replaced range keeps its styling,
right of it shifts by the length delta, only the rewritten bytes
lose theirs (the writer styles what it writes; inserted bytes
inherit nothing). Pre-fix any overlap dropped the WHOLE span —
red abc, SGR reset, CR, X left bc unstyled; zero translation
painted the default X red instead. Bite: exact (glyph, fg) cells
X=default, b/c=red — any_styled_cell cannot see either failure.
3. The per-CR/BS/erase-line whole-prefix scan is gone:
slot.line_start is tracked — advanced at every \n (append helper
+ the mid-line newline branch), read O(1) by the rewind paths,
reset on run start/resync/raw marker appends. Measured on 2 MB of
output + 3000 CR updates (release): 2.52s pre-fix → 0.67s
post-fix (remainder is fixture-bound; pre-fix cost grows with
buffer size). No correctness bite is possible for a pure perf fix
— the committed test pins the tracked value's behavior across
multi-line appends, batch-boundary CR, repeated CR, erase-line,
and recovery paths, and passes on both implementations by design.
Gates: fmt; clippy workspace all-targets; lib 1531; crdt lib 1705;
compile acceptance 60; crdt acceptance 3; m4 101; m6.4 15; m6.5 11;
m6.8 8; GPU 59; workspace sweep 2517/0; git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
Finding-by-finding (framing revision 10; bites via scripts/bite
against b5bbce8):
1. CR rewrites are COLUMN-counted and newline-segmented, not
byte-counted. Each newline-free segment of a text event consumes
one existing codepoint per incoming codepoint (codepoints
approximate columns; double-width and combining characters count
as one — the documented stance), and LF is not an overwrite
column: a newline arriving mid-line drops the cursor to a fresh
line and the stale remainder survives in place (terminal
semantics). Pre-fix, abcdef\rX\n wrote "X\n" over "ab" — splitting
the line and leaving "cdef" as a ghost line the parser saw again
at EOF — and abc\ré ate two ASCII columns because é is two bytes.
Round-3's UTF-8 invariant holds per-segment: every edit's range
ends sit on codepoint boundaries, so the rope is valid after each
step and byte-native CRDT edits never reject. Bites: single-batch
(shorter rewrite, multibyte-over-ASCII, CRLF), split-feed with the
é split across batches, and a CRDT twin covering the segmented
multi-edit replication.
2. Alternate-screen exits resynchronize the effective style. The
parser now tracks the style the consumer LAST RECEIVED
(emitted_style; outside alt-screen it always equals
current_style). An ordinary ?1049l exit emits the resync SetStyle
whenever suppressed SGR changes drifted the two apart, and
finish() balances against emitted_style rather than
current_style — a suppressed SGR reset inside the alt screen left
the internal style default, so the old comparison saw nothing to
balance while the consumer stayed red. Consumer-mirror units for
both drift directions plus the no-drift no-event case; Lua twin
(r4f2) bites via the ansi.rs swap.
Gates: fmt; clippy workspace all-targets; lib 1528; crdt lib 1702;
compile acceptance 56; crdt acceptance 3; m4 101; m6.4 15; m6.8 8;
GPU 59; workspace sweep 2510/0; git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
Finding-by-finding (framing revision 9; bites via scripts/bite):
1. The CR/backspace renderer is UTF-8-safe: overwrite ranges consume
WHOLE existing codepoints (range end aligned forward past
continuation bytes) in ONE atomic replace of the complete text
event — never a split of either side — and backspace steps to the
previous codepoint boundary; out_pos stays on boundaries by
induction. Pre-fix, byte-counted splits left malformed bytes on
the plain rope, and under CRDT the byte-native edit rejected the
mid-codepoint range, aborting the pump after events_take had
consumed the batch (terminal event lost, record leaked). Bites:
default acceptance (é\rX, X\ré, é\bX with exact-content, marker,
clean-*errors*, baseline asserts) and a CRDT twin that pre-fix
times out never reaching its exit marker.
2. parser:finish()'s reset is observable: balancing events —
AlternateScreenExit for an unclosed enter, a default SetStyle for
a non-default running style (now also cleared; reset() preserved
it) — let consumers unwind mirrored state from the event stream
alone. New Rust unit applies events to consumer state; Lua twin
(r3f2) bites via the ansi.rs swap.
3. stdin/group spec fields are RAW reads: spec tables are plain
data, metatable-provided fields are deliberately not honored (the
compile.lua rawget posture), and a raising __index can no longer
be silently absorbed as group=false, quietly disabling
process-group isolation. Regression test pins both shapes:
metatable-provided group=true is ignored (pgid != pid), and a
hostile raising metatable spawns cleanly.
Gates: fmt, clippy workspace all-targets, lib 1526, crdt lib 1700,
compile acceptance 53, crdt acceptance 2, m4 101, GPU 59, workspace
sweep 2505/0, git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
Finding-by-finding (framing revision 8; bites via scripts/bite):
1. Rule validation is a stable, total snapshot: validated scalar
fields are copied into per-run plain tables via raw reads
(rawget; metatable-provided fields deliberately not honored), so
post-run mutation of the user's rule objects cannot alter an
in-flight run and a hostile __index is a counted skip, not an
error thrown through the pump mid-batch. The container traversal
is itself pcall-protected; traversal-raise semantics are
Lua-flavor-dependent (5.2+ ipairs consults __index, LuaJIT reads
raw) and the test pins both flavors.
2. Capture indexes must be FINITE (floor(math.huge) == math.huge, so
integrality alone passed it); math.huge is now a counted
malformed entry.
3. Shell-command never touches the rule table: no spurious
compile-rule warnings on M-!, and no rule-container state can
block a run that performs no parsing.
4. AnsiParser::finish() (and parser:finish()) now fully resets the
parser — in-flight CSI/OSC/escape state and alt-screen
suppression included — so a post-finish feed parses a fresh
stream. Three direct unit tests in ansi.rs plus a Lua-driven twin
in the acceptance suite (the twin exists because a scripts/bite
file swap replaces the in-file units along with the fix).
5. Comment corrections: fractional capture indexes read a distinct
absent key (not a neighboring capture); the group-coercion
comment describes truthiness, not false; the AnsiParserLua
rustdoc lists finish().
Bites: r2f1 (both shapes), r2f2, r2f3 fail against pre-fix
compile.lua; r2f4 fails against pre-fix ansi.rs. Gates: fmt, clippy
workspace all-targets, lib 1525, crdt lib 1699, compile acceptance
50, crdt acceptance 1, m4 101, GPU 59, workspace sweep 2501/0 (one
flaky-suite rerun per the standing m8 rule), git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
Finding-by-finding (framing revision 7; every fix bite-verified via
scripts/bite against the pre-fix tree):
1. Stored coordinates must be finite integers, and both cursor walks
are movement-bounded — they clamp at EOF, and the column walk
clamps at the target row's EOL instead of marching onto later
rows. An astronomical %d+ capture can no longer hang the editor.
2. The grep panel gains the same immediate buffer.after-edit
recovery trigger as the compile slots: M-x buffer.undo after a
COMPLETED search is marked synchronously.
3. The rustc arrow rule uses the framing's ([^:]+) spelling — paths
with spaces capture whole.
4. All pattern captures are collected (index 4+ reads the real
capture, not nil-as-column-0); capture indexes must be positive
integers; a rule naming a column its match didn't produce rejects
the match.
5. emit_text_raw is module-local — a user global could shadow the
helper the terminal-event path depends on, and its error consumed
the terminal event before pump cleanup/forget ran.
6. stdin/group spec fields reject wrong Lua types as hard errors;
group is matched as a raw Value because mlua's bool conversion
applies Lua truthiness ("true" would silently coerce).
7. resync also nils the public line_start_byte — total pre-marker
anchor invalidation includes the byte anchor.
8. The inherited cwd resolves through
pmacs.instance.identity().working_directory; the header always
names a real path and relative error files get an explicit base.
9. New AnsiParser::finish() + parser:finish() (additions #5): a
truncated multibyte sequence at process EOF surfaces as U+FFFD
before the exit marker instead of vanishing.
10. The built-in default rules are a private deep copy — in-place
mutations of the public table no longer survive the "using
built-in defaults" degradation.
Eleven new tests (r1f1a/b–r1f10); bites: 9 fail against pre-fix
compile.lua, r1f2 against pre-fix default.lua, r1f6 against pre-fix
lua_bindings/mod.rs — all clean assertion failures. Gates: fmt,
clippy workspace all-targets, lib 1522, crdt lib 1696, compile
acceptance 45, crdt acceptance 1, m4 101, GPU 59, workspace sweep
2493/0, git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
tests/compile_mode_acceptance.rs (34 tests): spawn shape + header +
exit markers; read-only under dispatch; child-boundary stderr merge
in emission order; stdin EOF; group kill/leader-exit/escalation/
ledger bites incl. the redirected TERM-ignoring survivor and the
pipe-holding-descendant tick-latency bound; starter-rule parsing
with 0-based normalization and severity posture; sub-1 fail-closed;
severity override + malformed-rule containers; unterminated final
line; RET/n-p/M-g n/M-g p/C-x ` navigation pins with the diag
fallback; recompile + q-target discipline; supersede baseline; all
seven undo/redo chords table-driven; M-x undo after a completed run
recovering via buffer.after-edit; no-hook shrink and same-length
newline-moving replace with anchor epochs; ANSI SGR/CR with
rendered-cell attachment proof surviving RET-then-M-,; killed-buffer
teardown; grep locations panel, kill-mid-search + masking
prevention, root retention; shell-command M-!; round-trip pins.
tests/compile_mode_crdt_acceptance.rs: a chord-triggered full run
converges byte-identically on two replicas (mid-session generated-
buffer snapshot adoption), and a synthetic accepted replica edit
triggers the immediate recovery marker, converging across the
causal-reorder seam.
Fixes found by the suite: compile.lua's CR handling now scans the
current line start from the buffer (the REPL discipline) instead of
using the per-batch parse position — a same-batch CR previously let
a progress line overwrite earlier output; malformed Lua patterns
are rejected (and counted) at validation time via a probe match.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
builtin/runtime/compile.lua (Q#CM1-CM6, CM8-CM11): streaming
intercept-read-only *compilation* / *shell-command* slots fed by a
Lua-side ANSI parser (SGR to overlay spans, CR/BS/erase progress
collapse); once-per-newline error parsing over a validated,
fail-closed rule table (rustc arrows, gcc/clang, Python, generic;
severity override + keyword sniff; sub-1 captures discarded);
buffer-revision external-edit guard with desync marker and anchor
epochs, checked before every producer write, before byte-anchor
use, and immediately via buffer.after-edit; unified error.next /
error.previous dispatcher with last-claim-wins sources and a
diagnostics fallback (M-g n/p unbind-then-rebind — hence the
loader's ordering contract after lsp.lua; C-x ` bound; M-! bound);
buffer-local RET/n/p/g/q/C-c C-k plus all seven undo/redo chords as
status no-ops; tombstoned pump teardown honoring forget's
terminated-only contract; q-target never captures a generated
buffer; overlay retained per incarnation, cleared per run,
re-attached from buffer.after-switch.
builtin/commands/default.lua (Q#CM7): project.search's
*search-results* becomes a first-class locations buffer — read-only
with bypass writes, RET/n/p/q + undo no-ops + round-trip input,
structured-match locations (line-1, match_start as col, paths
resolved against the search root), per-write revision checks so a
batch cannot mask an external edit, on_removed stream cancel +
guards for kill-mid-search, root retention across interactive
supersedes from inside the pathless panel, and an error-source
claim per search.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VoiEyuPjoBhvwACf8HAnLB
Levi Neuwirth