* docs: frame QoL Stage 5, GPU horizontal scroll
Stage 4 merged as #222, so the lane advances to its last stage. Rule 4
still does not apply — the arc closes when Stage 5 merges, not before.
THE FRAMING'S FIRST FINDING CORRECTS STAGE 4'S. §1.3 there said the GPU
"needs a mechanism that does not exist", named it the fact most likely
to invert the cost estimate, and I endorsed the Stage 4/5 split partly
on that basis.
Half of it holds: `Scroll::horizontal` really is discarded throughout,
because glyphon 0.11 never applies it when placing glyphs — three
doc sites and three asserting tests. But that is not the only
mechanism. The document `TextArea` already carries an explicit `left`
origin and a `TextBounds` clip whose `left` is `gutter_clip_left`, and
horizontal scroll is `left: text_left - offset_px` with the clip
unchanged. glyphon then drops what falls left of the gutter — the same
"paint from column 0, clip at the edge" shape the grid renderer uses,
expressed in pixels. It is machinery the file already depends on, not
new machinery.
The split stays right for the reason that survives: the three consumers
Stage 4 named — caret (`code_byte_px`), decoration geometry
(`push_glyph_extent_rects`), hit testing (`gutter_aware_rel_x`) — each
produce x relative to `text_left()` and each need the same offset,
applied ONCE or they disagree. Shipping that inside Stage 4 would have
made one reviewable change into two unreviewable ones. But it was
justified partly by an overstatement, and saying so is cheaper than
letting a future reader inherit it.
No wire, no version bump: the GPU owns its viewport locally, exactly as
it owns `scroll_top` and `code_scroll_residual`. The parallel with
`ui.line-wrap` is misleading and the doc says why — the MODE is buffer
state and needed v22, the OFFSET is viewport state and needs nothing.
Five questions, each with my vote. Q#G3 is the one I am least sure of:
the GPU can resolve a proportional family, where "column" has no fixed
pixel width, so column-for-column parity with the TUI is unachievable.
I lean to defining the behavior in pixels and accepting imprecise
correspondence rather than gating a navigation feature on a font
choice — but that is a product call.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* docs: Stage 5 revision 2 — a clip, not just an offset
Two functional findings and two record repairs.
Q#G3 WAS BUILT ON A FALSE PREMISE, and the correction makes the lane
stricter rather than looser. Revision 1 said the GPU can resolve a
proportional family and proposed accepting a new TUI/GPU divergence to
accommodate it. It cannot: `family_is_monospace_everywhere` gates the
family across all four weight/style combinations,
`apply_font_facts` falls back when that fails, and
`unresolvable_and_proportional_families_fall_back` REQUIRES the
fallback. Answered as monospace-only by the font contract that already
exists — and the consequence is that the TUI-parity witness becomes
UNCONDITIONAL for every font the GPU supports. Revision 1 would have
introduced a font-dependent behavior difference to solve a problem the
codebase had already solved, in the lane whose purpose is removing
unchosen divergence.
"THREE CONSUMERS" WAS INCOMPLETE IN A WAY THAT WOULD HAVE SHIPPED A
DEFECT. Shifting the `TextArea` clips glyphon's text because glyphon
honors `TextBounds`. The manual quad and squiggle renderers have no
code-area scissor at all — nothing stops them painting into the gutter,
and today nothing needs to, because no code-relative x can be negative.
Scrolling makes that false.
So the framing now requires TWO shared things: one screen↔code
transform, and one code clip rectangle every code-relative painter
intersects with. The paths are tabulated with sites — caret rect
(`:9698`), caret-painted predicate (`:9734`), glyph extent rects
(`:9766`), inline math origins (`:9434`), completion anchor (`:7606`).
The two caret sites are the sharpest, and one of them falsifies a claim
revision 1 made: `:9734` has no left-edge test, so "the scroll
indicator inherits the fix" was false — `code_byte_painted` reuses it
and would call an off-left byte painted. And `:9698` does not merely
lack a check, it DOCUMENTS the absence as safe ("the caret x can't
precede `text_left`"). A comment asserting an invariant this lane
deletes is worse than silence.
Q#G2: "inert under wrap" was too weak. The offset must be RESET to zero
on the wrap transition, as the TUI already does — `horizontal_follow`
assigns `view_left = 0` on the wrap branch. Inertness hides a stale
value that reappears the moment the buffer toggles back to `truncate`,
before any cursor motion. G5 gains a witness that an inertness-only
implementation fails.
RECORDS. Rule 4's Stage-5 removal precondition was not actually met:
the handoff still described Stage 4 as upcoming work. Stage 4's durable
facts are now transferred — the unsnapped per-window column with a
per-line effective edge, the line-absolute walk, the three-way cell
designation, `Viewport::visible_cols` and its five adopters, the
wrap-branch reset, the `#[serde(default)]` persistence, and the absence
of any wire. The ledger's "Stage 4 ahead" / "Stage 4 plan" text is
corrected to Stage 5, and its Rule 4 note now says the removal is
legitimate BECAUSE those bullets exist.
And the journey-step claim is withdrawn. Revision 1 said this lane
completes journey step 4; step 4 is scored on welcome/help/tutorial
discoverability and COHERENCE.md:395 holds it Partial for reasons this
lane does not touch (`C-h` deletes a word, no tutorial). Restated as
preserving interface comprehension with no scorecard movement. §16 is
the direct target. Writing an unearned mark into a scorecard is how a
coherence document stops being ground truth.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* docs: Stage 5 revision 3 — four corrections, one of them impossible
Q#G1 CONTRADICTED THE Q#G3 ANSWER IN THE SAME DOCUMENT. It still said
the GPU's font "need not be monospace" and that Q#G3 makes "column"
ill-defined — both falsified by the answer two sections below, in the
same revision that wrote it. The pixel-storage vote is unchanged, but
its reasons narrow to the ones that survive, and the conversion is now
stated as EXACT: columns × the supported monospace advance. That is
what makes the unconditional parity witness checkable at all.
Also removed `follow_cursor`, which I invented. The GPU's pass is
`ensure_caret_painted`, and it is now named rather than cited by line —
robust against the transposition that put these two sites at each
other's line numbers in review.
Q#G2 WAS MISSING THE BUFFER-SNAPSHOT RESET. The GPU zeroes `scroll_top`
and `code_scroll_residual` when a snapshot installs a new buffer; the
horizontal offset must reset there for the same reason. Without it a
buffer switch INHERITS the previous document's leftward viewport,
showing the new buffer scrolled sideways until a cursor motion repairs
it — a worse symptom than the wrap case, because nothing about the new
buffer explains it.
THE GUTTER ASSERTION WAS IMPOSSIBLE, not merely imprecise. Revision 2
proposed asserting that nothing paints left of `gutter_clip_left`. With
line numbers on, the gutter DELIBERATELY holds digit glyphs and
diagnostic-sign quads, so that assertion fails on a correct
implementation — a test that can only be satisfied by removing the
gutter. Replaced with the checkable form of the same intent: the gutter
rectangle is byte-identical before and after a horizontal scroll, and
the left-edge rule is checked against code-relative geometry only. It
still catches a code painter bleeding into the gutter, because that
changes those pixels.
THE COMPLETION ANCHOR HIDES, IT DOES NOT CLOSE. `completion_anchor_px`
already returns `None` when the anchor scrolls out, so nothing draws
while the daemon-owned completion state and its key handling are
retained; actual closure is `CompletionPopup { anchor: None }`, which
is the daemon's to send. Revision 2 said "closes", which would have had
a viewport-geometry lane quietly redefining when a completion ends.
Specified as: no completion paint while the anchor is off-left, popup
reappears when it scrolls back, session semantics unchanged.
Ledger drift fixed: it still called the framing revision 1 with five
questions open.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* docs: Stage 5 revision 4 — witnesses for the two rules that had none
Both additions cover requirements the framing had already stated and
then left untested, which is how a rule becomes a comment.
THE SNAPSHOT RESET (Q#G2). Revision 3 added the buffer-snapshot reset
and tested only the wrap one. The witness now scrolls buffer A to a
non-zero offset, installs a buffer B snapshot, and asserts the offset
is zero and B renders at its code origin BEFORE any `CursorByte`
arrives.
The pre-cursor scoping is the entire test. A later cursor motion
repairs the offset regardless, so a witness that waits for one cannot
distinguish "reset on snapshot" from "repaired on first motion" — and
the second is the defect. Same shape as the wrap witness, which is also
scoped to before any motion, and for the same reason.
THE MINIMAP (Q#G4). The vote is "no movement", and the implementation
already supports it: the minimap derives from the summary, the surface
dimensions and `scroll_top`, with no horizontal input. So the witness
pins an existing property rather than requesting work — which is
exactly why it is worth writing. An offset threaded one seam too far
would break it silently, and nothing else in G5 would notice.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* docs: Stage 5 approved, five questions resolved
G1 pixels with exact conversion via the supported monospace advance; G2
automatic cursor-follow only, zeroing on both the wrap transition and
BufferSnapshot; G3 monospace-only by the existing font contract; G4
minimap unchanged; G5 accepted whole, including the snapshot-reset and
minimap-stability witnesses.
The scope boundary is restated in both documents because it is what
keeps this lane small: local GPU viewport state, no wire message, no
protocol bump, no command surface, no minimap movement.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* feat(gpu): horizontal scroll — the transform, the clip, and both resets
Stage 5, partial. The mechanism and lifecycle are in; two consumers and
the whole verification set are NOT yet done — see the tail of this
message, which is a status, not a summary.
WHAT IS IN.
The offset, `code_scroll_left`, in pixels (Q#G1). Column parity stays
exact because the code font is monospace by contract, so
`columns × advance` is a definition rather than an approximation.
Local viewport state: no wire, no version bump.
One screen↔code transform (`code_x_to_screen` / `screen_x_to_code`) and
one code clip (`code_clip_left` / `survives_code_clip_left`), which is
the pair framing §1.1 requires. Written before any consumer moved,
because five sites deriving the same offset independently is how the
caret and the glyphs it sits among come to disagree.
The glyph-side mechanism is one line: the document `TextArea`'s `left`
shifts while its `bounds.left` stays at the gutter, so glyphon clips
and the gutter keeps its own pixels.
BOTH LIFECYCLE RESETS (Q#G2), which were the two rules most likely to
be left as comments. The wrap transition zeroes the offset in
`apply_line_wrap` — inertness would park a stale value that reappears
the instant the buffer toggles back to `truncate`. The buffer snapshot
zeroes it beside `scroll_top` and `code_scroll_residual`, or a buffer
switch inherits the previous document's leftward viewport and shows the
new buffer scrolled sideways until a cursor motion repairs it.
`code_caret_rect_in_clip` gains its left-edge test, and its comment is
REWRITTEN rather than extended: it used to assert "the caret x can't
precede `text_left`", an invariant this stage deletes. A comment
asserting something a later stage falsifies is worse than silence. That
also repairs `code_byte_painted`, which reuses it — revision 1's claim
that the scroll indicator "inherits the fix" was false precisely here.
`gutter_aware_rel_x` is now the exact inverse of the transform, with
the gutter clamp applied in screen space first: a click in the gutter
band means "the first visible column", which after scrolling is the
offset, not column 0.
The completion anchor HIDES when scrolled off-left and does not close —
the daemon owns completion state and its key handling, and closure is
`CompletionPopup { anchor: None }`, which is the daemon's to send.
`horizontal_follow` mirrors the TUI's: automatic only, scroll just far
enough, so a caret already visible never moves the view. It runs after
`normalize_code_scroll` because it reads the caret's laid-out x, which
vertical normalization can change.
WHAT IS NOT IN, and must land before this is reviewable:
- `push_glyph_extent_rects` — washes, squiggles and selection extents
still paint at unshifted x and are not cropped at the gutter.
- Inline math origins (`:9434`) — same.
- Every Q#G5 witness. The 228 existing GPU tests pass, which says
only that nothing regressed at offset 0; not one of them exercises
a non-zero offset.
Gates so far: fmt; clippy --workspace --all-targets -D warnings;
PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU=1 -p pmacs-gpu 228/0; git diff --check. The full
two-configuration sweep is deliberately not claimed — the lane is not
finished.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* feat(gpu): the last two painters move, and twelve witnesses say so
Completes Stage 5. `62fb93e` landed the transform, the clip and both
resets but left two code-relative painters at unshifted x and the whole
Q#G5 witness set unwritten; its 228 green tests said only that nothing
regressed at offset 0.
The two painters:
- `push_glyph_extent_rects` — selection/search washes, peer presence
and diagnostic squiggles. Shifted through `code_x_to_screen`, then
CROPPED at the gutter rather than dropped: a selection running in
from off the left edge must paint the part that is visible. That is
the same boundary Stage 4's review caught the TUI painter getting
wrong, and it would have been easy to reproduce here.
- Inline math. The glyph mini-buffers only needed their origin moved —
their layer already carries the code area's `TextBounds`. The
fraction rules are quads in the background batch with no scissor of
their own, so those are cropped by hand.
`crop_to_code_clip_left` is the crop, and `survives_code_clip_left` now
delegates to it, so a caret the crop would discard is never painted.
One boundary rule, not two that agree today.
TWELVE WITNESSES, EACH MUTATION-TESTED. Eleven production mutations —
unshifted wash x, uncropped wash, unshifted math origin, uncropped math
rule, untested caret left edge, missing snapshot reset, missing wrap
reset, unhidden completion anchor, unscrolled glyphs, inverted hit-test
sign, pixel-instead-of-column snap — each fail the intended witness as
an ASSERTION failure, not a compile error. The minimap-stability
witness was mutation-tested separately by threading the offset into
`minimap_vertex_bytes`.
That battery earned its keep immediately. The gutter byte-identity
test's "the code area must actually have moved" assertion is satisfied
by a decoration wash and the caret alone, so it PASSED with
`TextArea.left` pinned to `text_left` — the entire glyph-side mechanism
was unwitnessed and nothing in review would have shown it. Its
replacement isolates the glyph layer: no decorations, and a source line
carrying no caret, whose band is blank at offset 0 and inked after.
ONE DELIBERATE STEP OUTSIDE THE APPROVED SCOPE, and it needs a ruling.
Q#G5 asks for frontend agreement that is "checkable rather than
asserted". Two tests in two crates asserting the same literal is not
that; it is the structural duplication `pmacs-protocol::scroll`'s own
module docs condemn, and that module exists because THIS ARC already
shipped that defect — the scroll indicator, fixed in one copy and left
wrong in the other. So the follow rule moved to
`pmacs_protocol:📜:follow_left`, beside `classify`, and both
frontends call it: `src/editor.rs::horizontal_follow` delegates, and the
GPU converts px <-> columns around it, exact by Q#G3.
The cost is that Stage 5 now touches `src/editor.rs`, which "local GPU
viewport state" does not cover. No wire message and no version bump —
the same argument `classify` already makes. If rejected, reverting is
small: restore the four-line conditional, drop `follow_left` and its
four protocol tests, rewrite the parity witness as a two-sided pin.
GATES, both configurations, five ambient roots isolated: fmt; clippy
`--workspace --all-targets -D warnings`; `--lib` 1920 and `--lib
--features crdt` 2105; horizontal_scroll 11, long_line_readable 3,
line_wrap 6, full_grid_resync 1; `PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU=1 -p pmacs-gpu`
239; `-p pmacs-protocol --lib` 29; both full workspace sweeps;
`git diff --check`.
TWO SWEEP FAILURES, NEITHER THIS LANE'S, both logged:
- R8, new row: `flat_listview_consumers_render_byte_identically...`
fails DETERMINISTICALLY, and the merge-base control is done — it
fails identically on `main`. The row renders with a leading
directory stripped; it is a prefix strip, not width truncation, and
the mechanism is NOT diagnosed. Deliberately not fixed here.
- U3: the R7 selector failed once and passed on rerun. Recorded as a
new incident, NOT an R7 match — different flavor, and its fragments
are unverified because I filtered the sweep output before reading
it. U2 records me making that exact mistake already. Sweeps go to a
file from now on.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* fix(gpu): the completion anchor is a point, and the witness now says where
Review round 1. One defect, and a lesson about the witnesses that
missed it.
THE DEFECT. `completion_anchor_px` reused `survives_code_clip_left` and
passed `line_height` as the horizontal extent — a VERTICAL dimension
standing in for a horizontal one. The predicate is
`screen_x + w > code_clip_left()`, so an anchor up to a whole line
height left of the gutter "survived". `completion_dropdown_rect` bounds
`ax` against the right margin only, so that x reached the popup's left
edge and painted over the line numbers.
An anchor is a position between glyphs. It has no width, and the popup
it places is drawn to its right. So the predicate is a point:
`screen_x < code_clip_left()`.
The absent left clamp downstream stays absent, deliberately. This
predicate is what guarantees `ax >= code_clip_left()`; a second clamp
would be a duplicate of the same rule, which is the failure mode this
stage's shared-transform design exists to avoid. It is witnessed
instead.
THE LESSON, which is the more useful half. The existing test placed the
anchor 200px off-left — and 200px off-left fails a width-based
predicate too, so it stayed green straight through the defect. The
mutation battery agreed with it, because every mutation asked only
whether REMOVING a check was caught, never whether the check had the
right shape.
A boundary must be tested AT the boundary. The new witness straddles it
by ±0.05px — the same anchor either side of the edge, which no
width-based predicate can separate — and additionally asserts the
popup's own left edge stays out of the gutter, making "no left clamp
needed downstream" a checked claim rather than a comment. Verified both
ways: the new witness fails against the original predicate, the old one
passes against it.
THE AUDIT that finding prompted. Stage 5 has one other left-edge
predicate, the caret's. Its use of `survives_code_clip_left(rect.x,
rect.w)` is correct — a caret quad genuinely is `CARET_WIDTH` wide —
and it was also only tested far from the edge. It is now walked ACROSS
the boundary a column at a time, asserting painted carets are wholly
inside the code area and hidden ones wholly outside.
That pins an argument that was load-bearing and invisible: because
`horizontal_follow` snaps to whole columns, a caret is never partly
behind the gutter, since `CARET_WIDTH` (2px) is far below any code
advance. Substituting `rect.h` for `rect.w` — the exact error above —
fails it. An over-width smaller than one advance does not, and that is
the invariant rather than a gap.
SCOPE. `follow_left` recorded as the one approved exception to "local
GPU viewport state" in the framing doc, new §1.2a: what it is, why the
Q#G5 parity witness cannot be real without it, and what it does not do
— no viewport state moved, no wire message, no version bump.
GATES, both configurations, five ambient roots isolated, sweeps
redirected to files per U3's lesson: fmt; clippy `--workspace
--all-targets -D warnings`; `--lib` 1920 and crdt 2105;
`-p pmacs-protocol --lib` 29; `PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU=1 -p pmacs-gpu` 241;
horizontal_scroll 11, long_line_readable 3, line_wrap 6,
full_grid_resync 1; both full workspace sweeps; `git diff --check`.
The only sweep failure is R8, confirmed by its recorded fragments —
pre-existing, deterministic, merge-base controlled against `main`, and
not this lane's.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* docs: Stage 5 is PR #223, head 55faa45
The ledger said "no PR opened yet", which stopped being true the moment
it was. Records the PR, its head SHA, and the standing do-not-merge.
Rule 4 still applies at merge, not now: the long-lines lane stays until
#223 lands.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
* docs: the tip is the ref, not a SHA the commit itself invalidates
The previous commit wrote "head 55faa45" into the ledger and, by
existing, made it false — recording the PR moved the head to 4902048.
A SHA pinned in a document that the act of writing it stales is a trap,
not a record.
The ledger already states the correct convention two paragraphs down
("the authoritative tip — the ref, not a SHA"); this follows it, and
says to verify CI against the PR's live headRefOid.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Stage 4 is open as #222; Stage 5 (GPU) still closes the arc, so the
Rule 4 exemption above stands unchanged.
Records the two things review added after the framing was approved: the
`Viewport::visible_cols` single clip rule with its five adopters, and
the corrected `ui.line-wrap` description. Both are lane facts rather
than framing ones — the framing decided the coordinate contract, and
these are what implementing it against a real frame turned up.
Also notes R7, so a reader of this lane finds the unrelated red without
having to reconstruct why a sweep in this window went 112/113 once.
No SHA — `githubsucks/horizontal-scroll` stays the authoritative tip,
per this ledger's own rule.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Stage 4 of the QoL arc, framing revision 4 (approved). Under
`truncate`, text past the right edge was UNREACHABLE; moving the cursor
now brings it into view. Automatic only — no commands, no bindings, no
new interaction island (Q#HS2).
THE CONTRACT. `view_left` is an unsnapped per-window display column
(Q#HS7(a)), and each line derives its own effective edge during the
walk it already performs from column 0. Starting at 0 is not laziness:
tab expansion depends on the absolute column from the line start, so a
walk beginning at the edge would put tab stops in the wrong place. The
walk stays line-absolute and only the emit translates.
Where the edge bisects a wide glyph on a given line (Q#HS7(c′)), its
trailing cell paints a styled BLANK rather than a `Continuation` — that
glyph means "the cell before me is a wide glyph's head", and here that
cell is off-screen, so emitting it would name a cell nobody painted.
The mapping designates that cell to the glyph's START byte, which keeps
`byte_at_place` total over visible cells and makes the character the
user scrolled toward clickable. Tabs keep FORWARD rounding (Q#HS7(c″))
— preserved, not chosen.
DECORATIONS TRAVEL WITH THE TEXT. The first version of this commit
translated the base glyph walk and nothing else, which split the frame
in half: at `view_left = 10` a glyph from source column 10 painted at
screen column 0 while its syntax style, diagnostic underline, search
wash and `BufferStyleOverlay` span painted at screen column 10 — or
vanished. Decorations drifting off the characters they describe,
silently, and only once a window had been scrolled.
Every such site carried the same two lines (`start_col.min(max_cols)`,
`end_col.min(max_cols)`), correct only while the left edge was pinned
at zero. `Viewport::visible_cols` is now the one rule all FIVE adopters
share — syntax/LSP styling, diagnostic underlines, search washes,
`BufferStyleOverlay`, and the selection painter — so a future decorator
inherits the translation instead of re-deriving it. It also subsumes
the old `end_col <= start_col` guard rather than sitting beside it.
`StyleSpanOverlay` and `VirtualCellOverlay` are deliberately untouched:
they are documented as viewport-relative, so translating them would be
the mirror defect.
The selection painter was nearly a sixth site with its own copy of the
rule, which I justified by a width it supposedly needed and the
viewport lacked. That was FALSE — the render viewport's
`cell_size.cols` is already `rect.size.cols - gutter_w` and its origin
already sits past the gutter. It now takes that same viewport and drops
its `rect`/`gutter_w` parameters entirely. A canonical rule with one
honest exception is not canonical.
The selection painter had the same defect with a worse failure mode: it
asked `pos_to_display` through the LIVE context, which returns `None`
for a position left of the edge, so a selection beginning off-screen
and reaching into view took `continue` and painted NOTHING. That is the
common shape, not an edge case — select rightward from column 0 past
the window width and the view scrolls with the cursor.
TWO THINGS THE TESTS FOUND, both in `pos_to_display`. My framing note
said a caret sits between characters so never lands inside a glyph;
true for the caret, false for the DESIGNATION direction — the glyph's
start byte must map to its visible trailing cell, so `screen_col` needs
the straddle rule and not a bare subtraction. And the `take == 0` early
return short-circuited the translation entirely, so byte 0 looked
visible at every offset.
`view_left` is inert under `wrap` BY CONSTRUCTION —
`LayoutCtx::effective_left` and `Viewport::left_edge` return 0 while
wrapping — rather than by every caller remembering.
Persisted per leaf at DESKTOP_VERSION 1 (Q#HS5) with both approval
conditions: `#[serde(default)]` and a literal v1 JSON fixture omitting
the field, hand-written because a generated one would gain the field
and prove nothing.
Also: `view_left: window.view_left` in the render viewport, not a
literal 0. My mechanical fill put 0 there and it is EXACTLY the
`aa3cd4d` defect — coordinates and the indicator following the scroll
while the painter stays pinned at column 0.
BITE, per clause. Forcing `bisected = false` fails the multi-line
straddle witness; dropping the backward designation fails the
round-trip witness; removing `#[serde(default)]` fails the v1 fixture;
pinning `visible_cols` to an absolute clamp fails all three decorator
witnesses; restoring the selection painter's live-context lookup fails
the off-screen-start selection witness. Each alone. And with selection
now reading the shared helper, pinning `visible_cols` to an absolute
clamp fails the selection witnesses TOO — which is the check that the
duplication is really gone rather than merely reworded.
One unrelated red, logged as R7 in ci-red-signatures.md — the first
this session with a COMPLETE signature, so a matchable row rather than
a U note. `pmacs-gpu`'s managed-retry attach hit a BrokenPipe once
under full-sweep load and did not reproduce (6 isolated runs plus a
clean 113-target sweep). Per the rerun rule that is intermittence only,
and the row explicitly does not claim harmlessness. Not attributed to
this lane: Stage 4 touches no `pmacs-gpu` file and adds no wire
surface.
Gates: fmt; clippy --workspace --all-targets -D warnings, both
configurations; `cargo test --workspace --no-fail-fast -- --skip
basedpyright` 113 targets exit 0, and the same with --features crdt,
113 targets exit 0; git diff --check. No protocol change, so no version
bump and no protocol-bump matrix.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Two small revisions, and every Stage 4 question is now answered.
Approval is NOT recorded; no implementation may begin.
Q#HS7(c″) — the tab-straddle mapping. Recorded as PRESERVED rather
than chosen, because it already exists: `byte_at_place`'s doc comment
says it rounds forward to the next character boundary, and the walk
accumulates past the tab byte and returns on the NEXT character's
start column, so every column inside a tab's expansion already yields
the post-tab offset (src/text_view.rs:224, :243-254). The requirement
on Stage 4 is therefore that horizontal scroll not PERTURB it — which
makes its witness a regression test, and one that should fail if the
walk is ever "optimized" to start at the effective edge instead of
column 0.
The obvious objection is that (c′) rounds backward and (c″) forward,
so the framing answers it. A wide glyph's two cells belong to ONE
character: forward-rounding its trailing cell would designate it to
the next character and leave the straddling glyph with no visible cell
mapping to it at all — unreachable by click exactly when it is what
the user scrolled toward. A tab's expansion cells are whitespace
BETWEEN the tab byte and the next character, and forward-rounding them
is already how clicking in indentation lands at the start of the text.
Different directions, one principle: every visible cell is designated
to the byte a user would mean by clicking it.
With (c′) and (c″) the (d) contract is total over visible cells:
ordinary character → its own start; bisected wide glyph → the glyph's
start; tab expansion → the byte after the tab.
Q#HS5 approved as stated, with both conditions written into the
approval rather than attached as advice: `#[serde(default)]` and a
literal v1 JSON fixture omitting the field, asserting restore at zero.
The handoff said "Stage 4 is the remainder". It now says Stages 4 AND
5 remain and the arc closes at Stage 5, carries the Q#HS1 time box,
and states explicitly that Rule 4 must not retire the long-lines lane
at Stage 4's merge. It also records that the unreachable caveat is
missing from the setting's description — the #221 gap — so that fact
lives in the durable doc and not only in a lane block that will
eventually be removed.
Ledger: the question list is consolidated (the accepted answers had
begun duplicating the blocking entries they resolved), keeping the
withdrawn (c)'s reasoning because the trap generalizes to any future
window-wide value derived from per-line content.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
P1 — Q#HS7(c) WITHDRAWN, and my vote was wrong rather than vague.
Revision 2 voted to snap `view_left` to a valid boundary at the moment
it is set. That cannot exist. `view_left` is ONE per-window display
column, but "does column N bisect a wide glyph?" is a PER-LINE
question: column 11 can be a wide glyph's trailing cell on line 3 and
ordinary ASCII on line 4. No setter-time value is canonical for every
visible line. Snapping per line instead is worse — the same source
column would appear at different screen columns on different rows,
destroying the alignment a column-oriented view exists to provide.
Replaced by (c′), a per-line effective edge. `view_left` is stored
unsnapped; each line derives its own edge during the walk it already
performs from column 0. Where the requested edge bisects a wide glyph
on THAT line, the finding's actual question — what occupies the
leftmost cell — is answered: it paints as a space carrying the glyph's
style, and the mapping DESIGNATES that cell to the wide glyph's start
byte. That keeps `byte_at_place` total over visible cells, preserves
the round trip (`place_of_byte(start)` reports the straddle and
designates cell 0), and gives a click there the character a user would
expect. Bytes lying entirely left of the edge are reported not-visible
rather than clamped to column 0, because clamping would make
arbitrarily many bytes share cell 0 and destroy (d).
Recorded as deliberately NOT the mirror of Stage 3's right-edge rule:
under wrap a too-wide glyph is pushed to the next row entirely, and at
the left edge under truncate there is no next row, so the same intent
requires a different rule. Stated so nobody "fixes" one to match the
other.
(d) is amended accordingly: the invariant is a property of
`(view_left, line)`, not of `view_left` alone — which is what makes a
multi-line fixture with differing glyph widths at the same column the
DISCRIMINATING test rather than an extra one. A single-line sweep
passes against the withdrawn design.
P1 — Stage 4 no longer closes the arc, and the stale claim was
load-bearing in the wrong direction. Rule 4 removes a lane when its ARC
is done, so a framing asserting Stage 4 closes it would license
retiring the lane at the TUI merge — orphaning the very Stage 5 that
Q#HS1's time box exists to guarantee, while `truncate` is still a dead
end in the GUI. Both the framing opening and the lane header now say
the arc closes at Stage 5, and the lane carries an explicit "Rule 4
does not apply at Stage 4's merge".
P2 — the stale Stage 3 residue in the ledger claimed the unreachable
caveat is in the setting description, contradicting revision 2 forty
lines above it. Corrected in place: the caveat lives only in the
toggle's status message and a source comment, and a user who sets the
mode in init.lua is told nothing.
Q#HS5 now states the concrete condition rather than an instruction to
check one. Verified: SavedLeaf carries no #[serde(default)] anywhere in
src/desktop.rs, so serde would REJECT a version-1 desktop JSON omitting
a new `view_left`. "Yes, no version bump" is sound only with the
annotation AND a regression fixture holding literal v1 JSON without the
field. The reverse direction already works — an old binary meets an
unknown field, which serde ignores absent deny_unknown_fields, and
there is none in that file.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
P1 — THE PROTOCOL-BUMP GATE WEAKENED THE SWEEP IT MEANT TO STRENGTHEN.
Revision 1 said `--tests --no-fail-fast` REPLACES the `--workspace`
line. Measured: `--tests` selects 108 targets, `--workspace` selects
110, and the two it drops are `pmacs_protocol` and `pmacs_gpu`. On a
PROTOCOL bump, dropping the protocol crate's tests is the wrong loss —
and it also silently dropped `--skip basedpyright`.
Worse, this lane's own remediation sweep used `--tests`, so it never
ran pmacs-protocol's 25 tests, including the `scroll::classify` tests
this lane had just written. They pass (verified 25/0), but by luck. A
correction that reproduces the shape of the mistake it corrects is
worth naming, so §3 and §5 both say `--workspace`, additive, with
`-- --skip basedpyright` retained in both feature configurations.
P1 — NO COORDINATE CONTRACT FOR view_left. Revision 1 decided what
moves the viewport and never said what its offset IS — the same
omission as shipping WrapMode with no DisplayCoord. Its verification
sketch named tabs and wide characters with no oracle for either,
because nothing defined what a left edge is.
Q#HS7 is new and BLOCKING, in four coupled parts: the unit; which
columns may be a left edge; the snap rule for an invalid one; and the
invariant rendering and coordinate mapping share. Votes recorded —
display column (tab stops come free, since the walk must start at
column 0 either way and a byte offset buys nothing); a left edge may
not fall inside a wide glyph; snap toward the line start (snapping left
can only reveal a character, snapping right can hide the one the user
scrolled to reach); and snap when the value is SET, not in the painter,
so one canonical value serves both readers.
Part (d) is why it blocks: if the painter clips where the mapper does
not, clicks land on the wrong character — silently, and only on lines
wide enough to scroll.
P2 — THE CAVEAT IS NOT IN THE SETTING DESCRIPTION. Revision 1 said it
was. builtin/runtime/linewrap.lua:23 says only "truncate at the edge";
"unreachable" lives in the toggle's status message and a source
comment, neither of which a user sees who sets the mode in init.lua.
That is a real, small user-facing gap shipped in #221. Claim corrected,
and amending the description is now a Stage 4 deliverable (§6) with the
text depending on which stage has landed.
THE THREE ANSWERS, recorded with the reasoning that decided them:
HS1 — GPU is Stage 5. The distinction that matters is that Stage 3's
defect was never "the frontends differ" but "the frontends differ and
nobody chose that". Time box made concrete per the request: Stage 5
is the immediately-next QoL lane, `wrap` stays default until it
lands, release notes state the asymmetry, and the truncate
affordances name the GUI gap meanwhile.
HS2 — automatic only. No command surface; the cursor-visibility pass
gains a horizontal component.
HS6 — `wrap` stays default, and the reason given is stronger than the
one revision 1 reasoned from. I had framed it as "if scroll makes
truncate good, reconsider the default". With the GPU deferred, a
truncate default would ship a mode navigable in the TUI and a dead
end in the GUI for every user who never opened the setting. HS1 and
HS6 are coupled: the split is only safe because the default does not
move.
Q#HS4 is deferred rather than closed — not live under automatic-only,
but the snap-back hazard is real and rediscovering it costs more than
carrying the paragraph. Q#HS5 stands, with the caveat that §1.4 cites
the struct shape and not serde's behavior on a missing field.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
#221 merged, so the long-lines lane is REWRITTEN rather than removed —
rule 4 removes a lane when its arc is done, and Stage 4 is ahead. Stage
3's durable facts move to the handoff §1, which is rule 4's actual
precondition.
THE FRAMING LEADS WITH THE FACT MOST LIKELY TO INVERT ITS OWN COST
ESTIMATE, because that is what Stage 3 revision 1 got wrong. The GPU
cannot honor horizontal scroll through cosmic-text: `Scroll::horizontal`
is discarded throughout, and not by oversight — glyphon 0.11 never
applies it when placing glyphs. Documented in three places and asserted
by three tests. So the GPU's half needs a mechanism that does not exist,
touching caret placement, decoration geometry, and hit testing, each of
which assumes x starts at `text_left()`. That is Q#HS1: whether the GPU
is in Stage 4 at all.
Also verified rather than recalled: there is NO horizontal scroll
anywhere in the tree (greenfield, not an extension); `paint_line` starts
every walk at column 0, so `view_left` enters the functions Stage 3 just
rewrote and the wrap rule must stay written once; `view_top` is
persisted per leaf at DESKTOP_VERSION 1; `scroll_window`'s comment
already records the cursor-follow hazard; and `goal_col` is unexamined
horizontal state on the same window.
Six questions, each with my vote and the argument against it. The one I
am least comfortable with is Q#HS6: Stage 4 adds capability that exists
only under a NON-DEFAULT mode, which is a conditional surface rather
than a uniform improvement — and Stage 3 chose `wrap` as the default
partly BECAUSE scroll did not exist. If scroll makes `truncate` good,
that default deserves re-examination rather than inheritance.
ALSO A GATE CORRECTION, and it changes what I said in 4d70ff6. I wrote
that "the touched acceptance suites" is the standing gate. That is
CLAUDE.md's list. `docs/agent-handoff.md` §3 — which CLAUDE.md tells me
to read FIRST — already required `cargo test --workspace -- --skip
basedpyright`, a full sweep. I ran the short list. So the eight broken
version assertions were not a gap in the documented gates; they were me
following a summary instead of the gate suite.
§3 now says so, and adds the protocol-bump form (`--tests
--no-fail-fast` in both feature configurations), because even the full
sweep stops at the first failing target and builds one configuration —
it would have shown one or two of the eight, not all of them.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
CI red on #221: all five Test jobs, one identical test, every platform
— deterministic, not a flake. The production code was never wrong.
WHY MY GATES MISSED IT. The standing gate is "the touched acceptance
suites", selected from the diff. A PROTOCOL_VERSION bump breaks
version-assertion tests that appear nowhere in it. Worse, CI showed
only ONE of the eight, because cargo stops at the first failing
target; the rest surfaced only under `--tests --no-fail-fast`, and one
at a time would have cost four more red rounds.
Three of the eight were invisible even to that, because they are
crdt-gated real-daemon tests asserting on a live socket. Found by
`--tests --features crdt --no-fail-fast`. That is the handoff's
existing "a local sweep is blind to whichever configuration it does
not build" lesson, hit again by a different lane.
THREE TRIPWIRES, WORKING AS DESIGNED. `assert_eq!(PROTOCOL_VERSION,
21)` in statusline_segments, bottom_panel_stage2b_gpu, and
vterm_stage3 are meant to fire and take a deliberate edit; each says
so in its own comment. Updated to 22 with the reason recorded. Worth
noting the pin that must NEVER be edited —
ADVERTISED_PROTOCOL_VERSION == 20 — did not fire, which is the
mechanism behaving exactly as designed.
FIVE DEFECTS, ONE SHAPE: an absolute contract expressed as arithmetic
on, or equality with, a MOVING constant. Each was true when written
and silently false afterwards.
- `PROTOCOL_VERSION - 1` meaning "below the panel version". Held
only while PROTOCOL_VERSION == PANEL_MIN_VERSION; at v22 it
equalled PANEL_MIN_VERSION exactly, so the fixture's "old" peer
became panel-capable and the daemon correctly sent it a frame.
Now `PANEL_MIN_VERSION - 1`.
- `assert_eq!(PANEL_MIN_VERSION, PROTOCOL_VERSION)` — a coincidence
true only while panels were the newest feature. Replaced by the
two durable bounds: above the advertised floor, at or below this
binary's wire.
- `assert_eq!(PROTOCOL_VERSION, 21)` in a test named
`the_panel_stage_takes_protocol_v21` — the current wire as a proxy
for the panel stage's own version, in a test whose name says which
one it means. Now PANEL_MIN_VERSION.
- `session_protocol_version == "21"` in two real-daemon probes. What
the counter-offer activates is THIS BINARY's wire, so the literal
was only ever right by accident. Now PROTOCOL_VERSION, plus an
explicit `>= PANEL_MIN_VERSION` for the panel capability the
literal had been carrying implicitly.
The codebase already had the right idiom: src/daemon.rs and
pmacs-gpu/src/main.rs spell it `PANEL_MIN_VERSION - 1` in five places.
Every outlier was in tests/.
ALSO LOGGED, NOT FIXED: U2 in ci-red-signatures.md.
`process::tests::m6_1_pty_raw_mode_disables_kernel_echo` failed once
during a full corpus run and did not reproduce (108 targets exit 0,
plus 3 isolated --lib runs at 1917/0). It is in no registry row, so it
is a new incident, and leaked `pmacs --daemon` processes remain an
unexcluded rival explanation. Recorded with a selector this time —
unlike U1, whose name I destroyed by piping through `tail`.
Gates: fmt; clippy --workspace --all-targets -D warnings, both
configurations; --lib 1917/0; --lib --features crdt 2102/0; --tests
--no-fail-fast 108 targets exit 0; --tests --features crdt
--no-fail-fast 108 targets exit 0; PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU=1 -p pmacs-gpu
228/0; git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
The standing correction from #171, #215 and #220: the lane block is
written with the first commit, so it says "no PR yet" until something
updates it. Recording the number here rather than leaving it to be
reconstructed from the branch.
No SHA — `githubsucks/long-lines` stays the authoritative tip, since
any edit to this block advances past whatever SHA it records. That
rule is the lane's own, from #220's review.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Closes Stage 3's remaining obligations.
THE PTY TEST. Every other test in this lane checks a mechanism.
tests/long_line_readable_acceptance.rs checks the complaint: the
shipped binary, a real 80x24 PTY, one source line 200 columns wide,
and an assertion that its tail marker reaches the host. It bites —
`scripts/bite HEAD~2 src/editor.rs --test long_line_readable_acceptance`
against the pre-aa3cd4d editor never paints TAILZQX in 20s.
Its truncate control (an isolated init.lua pinning the mode) is what
makes that marker discriminating, and it is also the honest statement
of what truncate costs today: those bytes are not off-screen, they are
unreachable until Stage 4.
What it does not prove: the workspace has no screen model and no
vt100/termwiz/vte, so this shows the tail was WRITTEN to the terminal,
not which row a human would point at. That is nonetheless the whole of
the report — under truncation the bytes are never emitted at all.
§1.1 WAS WRONG, FOR NINETEEN REVISIONS. `editing.fill-column` is not
an orphaned registry setting "of the exact shape Stage 1 just fixed".
Both cited occurrences are inside `#[cfg(test)] mod tests` — fixture
names in round-trip tests covering one setting per ConfigKind. Two of
those five names are real; three, including this one, are defined
nowhere else in the tree. There is no shipped setting, so the Q#LL4
deliverable "sharpen its description" had no object.
The mechanism is worth more than the correction. A grep hit at a src/
path, a genuine `r.define(...)` call that is real API usage rather
than a mock, and `#[cfg(test)]` about fifty lines above the citation.
Every later revision inherited the conclusion instead of the evidence,
and three review rounds reasoned about the consequences of an orphaned
setting rather than re-checking that it existed. A file:line citation
is not a substitute for reading the scope it sits in.
Had it gone unchecked into implementation, Stage 3 would have shipped
an edit to a unit-test fixture believing it was rewording a
user-visible setting — a no-op with a misleading commit message.
§1.1 is withdrawn in place, keeping the original text and the
reasoning that produced it; §6's answer is unchanged (a setting that
does not exist is a stronger reason not to adopt it) and its premise
corrected. Both fixture sites now say they are fixtures. The approval
is not reopened: nothing else in the document rested on §1.1, which
argued for a display setting separate from fill-column — which is what
shipped.
AND ONE UNCLASSIFIABLE RED, logged as U1 in ci-red-signatures.md. A
`-p pmacs-gpu` run went 227/1 once; every run since is 228/0. The
failing test name was NOT captured, because I piped that command
through `tail -3` and discarded the failure block above the summary.
36 later runs are clean, 6 under deliberate concurrent load — which
per the rerun rule establishes intermittence only, and without a
selector not even that. Deliberately NOT matched against A1 despite
A1 also being GPU-headless-under-load: matching requires an exact
selector and every required fragment, and calling a shapeless red
"probably the known one" is the reputation-by-adjacency that file
exists to deny.
Gates: fmt; clippy --workspace --all-targets -D warnings; --lib
1917/0; --lib --features crdt 2102/0; line_wrap 6/0;
long_line_readable 2/0; folding 21/0; folding_stage2 48/0;
full_grid_resync 1/0; config_registry 16/0; m4 150/0;
PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU=1 -p pmacs-gpu 228/0 (see U1); git diff --check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Stage 2 (GUI zoom, #220) landed. Stage 3 shares no code with it, so this
is a currency merge rather than a dependency --- taken now so the
Stage 3 PR opens against a base it has already been tested on.
# Conflicts:
# docs/active-work.md
Section 5d.6 answered as (b): ScrollPosition and the pure classify go
in pmacs-protocol, string rendering stays in each frontend.
The reading that settles it is sharper than "shared vocabulary". Each
frontend computes its own local layout facts --- which rows are on
screen is a question only it can answer --- while the shared crate owns
the common semantic decision those facts feed. That is not presentation
leaking into the protocol crate; it is the DECISION placed where both
frontends are structurally unable to disagree, with rendering left
where it belongs.
Two properties bound the change: no wire message and no protocol
version bump, since classify is a pure function over values each side
already holds; and the one-copy-fixed defect from 5d.3 becomes
unrepresentable rather than reviewer-guarded, because there is only one
classifier to fix.
Q#LL8 approved. All eight questions answered. Implementation begins.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Revision 16 said the scroll formatter could keep its signature and
change only what callers pass. It cannot, and the byte fallback in
revision 17 made that unavoidable rather than merely untidy.
Every branch of format_scroll_indicator derives from total_lines:
total_lines <= 1 -> All
visible >= total_lines -> All
view_top == 0 -> Top
view_top + visible >= total_lines -> Bot
pct = (cursor_row + 1) * 100 / total_lines
Revision 17 removed the total. Passing byte counts makes the Bot branch
compare rows against bytes --- it would return plausible strings that
mean nothing. Passing any stand-in small enough to satisfy the guards
restores the false All this section exists to remove. And "local
predicates" is not something that signature can evaluate, because it
has no parameter for them.
Resolved by not asking it to. truncate calls the existing formatter
UNTOUCHED, with the same arguments in the same units, so its output is
byte-identical by construction rather than by assertion, and every
existing formatter test stays valid --- including the GPU's
format_scroll_indicator(0, 10, 1, 0) == "All", which correctly pins
line-space behavior. wrap calls a new classifier:
classify(first_visible: bool, last_visible: bool,
byte_pos: u64, byte_len: u64) -> ScrollPosition
All = first && last; Top = first && !last; Bot = last && !first;
otherwise Percent from bytes. No count of rows enters it, so the unit
mixing is not avoided but unrepresentable.
The actual mistake was trying to serve two genuinely different
contracts from one four-count signature. It could only do that by
making units implicit, which is how the contradiction arose. This is
5b.5's identity-case strategy applied to the indicator itself: the old
mode keeps the old code, and the new mode gets code shaped to it.
Leaves one question open. pmacs-gpu depends on pmacs-protocol only,
never on the pmacs lib, so format_scroll_indicator is duplicated
STRUCTURALLY and the classifier faces the same fork. Duplicating it
preserves exactly the condition that produced the earlier defect, where
one copy was fixed and the other was not. Sharing it through
pmacs-protocol makes the agreement structural rather than maintained,
which is the principle that chose byte-anchoring, additive sub_row, and
a content-derived cache key --- but it widens that crate from wire
vocabulary toward presentation, which is a COHERENCE section 16
layering question and not this lane's to settle alone.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Revision 16 gave the GPU its scroll-indicator total on the premise that
"cosmic-text already knows each line's visual height". It does not.
rebuild_code_slice feeds cosmic-text current_text[vstart..vend] and
nothing else, because Session S1 found that feeding the whole rope made
large-file editing O(file) per keystroke. The GPU's layout holds the
viewport slice plus overscan; it cannot yield total visual rows, nor
the cursor's or top's row ordinal.
Re-shaping the whole document to recover them would reintroduce exactly
the cost that design exists to prevent --- for a status-line readout.
So the aggregate is abandoned rather than relocated. NN% is computed
from BYTE POSITION in both frontends; truncate keeps today's
visible-line percentage. No total, no cache, no invalidation.
Three reasons it is abandoned rather than approximated. Rows-per-line
could be computed as ceil(width / cols) without shaping, but
cosmic-text decides the real break points, so the number could disagree
with what is on screen --- the same approximate-parity trap Q#LL5
rejected for whitespace wrapping. Letting the TUI use row ordinals and
the GPU use bytes would show two percentages for one buffer, which is
this lane's own defect a third time. And All/Top/Bot are unaffected
either way: they are local predicates, they stay exact, and they are
the states a user actually reads.
This retires the cache from revision 15 and the fold-key correction
from revision 16. That correction was right for the design as it stood;
the design moved under it. Section 5d.2 is marked SUPERSEDED rather
than deleted, because "the key was fixed" and "there is no key" are
different states and a later reader should be able to tell which one
happened here.
Adds the large-file guard as a witness rather than an intention: an
indicator paint must leave the GPU's view_range and shaped_top
untouched, must not lay out beyond the viewport in the TUI, and
open_100mb_under_200ms must still pass with wrap as the default mode.
Without those, the decision is an unenforced comment and a later
"improvement" to a real row count would silently restore O(file) work.
Known imprecision, stated rather than left to be discovered: under
folds a byte percentage counts hidden bytes. Folding is TUI-only today,
and it matches Emacs. It belongs to the GPU folding lane, not this one.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Two corrections to Q#LL8, both found by review of 1c9ff6a, and both the
same shape: a fix that read as complete because it was correct in one
of two places.
The GPU has its own scroll indicator. format_scroll_indicator is
DUPLICATED, not shared --- src/editor.rs:5509 and
pmacs-gpu/src/main.rs:10114, each with its own tests --- and the GPU
passes current_line_starts.len(), a source-line count. So revision 15
would have fixed the indicator in the TUI and left the GPU reporting
"All" for a one-line wrapped buffer.
That is worth naming plainly: it is this lane's own defect, reproduced
inside the section written to close it. The lane exists because two
frontends disagree for reasons nobody chose, and the fix disagreed for
exactly that reason one more time.
Both copies keep their signature. The formatter is a pure function over
counts and is correct as written; what changes is what the callers
pass --- visual rows rather than source lines, visible rows rather than
visible lines. Every existing formatter test stays valid, including the
GPU's own format_scroll_indicator(0, 10, 1, 0) == "All", which pins
line-space behavior and must not silently change meaning.
The lazy total's cache key omitted fold state. Folds are built per
rendered window and can be collapsed or expanded with no edit, no
resize and no mode change --- so all three of revision 15's key
components sit still while the projection underneath them moves. Cache
NN%, toggle a fold, and the stale total is served for the new
projection.
Now keyed on (buffer generation, content width, mode, fold projection),
and specifically on the projection's own components rather than a
revision counter on the fold registry. Components is one entry per
collapsed region, so comparing it is O(folds), and the key IS the thing
it guards --- it cannot be forgotten. A maintained counter can, on
every present and future mutation path, which is the same
did-you-remember hazard as LL7's buffer-switch trigger. Same principle
as byte-anchoring over a row index and additive sub_row over redefining
row: self-validating beats maintained.
Content width, not window width. Wrapping happens in the text area, and
the gutter's width changes at the line-count digit boundary (9 -> 10,
99 -> 100) --- something the GPU's sync_buffer_dimensions comment
already records for its own shaping. Keying on window width would serve
a stale total across that boundary.
Three witnesses added: the reported case in BOTH frontends, a "cache,
then toggle a fold" case that fails against revision 15's key, and a
digit-boundary case.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Two holes in revision 14, both found by review of this lane's own first
commit, and both would have been discovered during implementation at
much greater cost.
Q#LL7 --- the mode never reached the GPU. Section 4 resolves
ui.line-wrap into Viewport, which reaches the GRID renderer. The GPU is
not a grid consumer: it lays out locally, ignores CellDelta,
BufferSnapshot carries only CRDT bytes, and no InstanceMessage variant
expresses a wrap mode. So truncate would have changed the TUI and left
the GPU wrapping --- the two frontends still disagreeing, which is the
one thing this lane exists to fix. Q#LL5's "character wrap in both" was
equally unreachable: setting Wrap::Glyph at startup is not honoring a
mode that can change.
Specified as an additive variant at v22, appended after the current
final variant with the advertised baseline left at 20 --- the path
FontFacts took at v17 and the panel shapes at v21, and the baseline
constant's own doc reserves moving it for changes that cannot be
expressed additively. This one can.
It carries buffer_id, and is resent on attach, on config change, AND on
buffer switch. The third trigger is the one a FontFacts-shaped design
misses: font size is global, wrap mode is per buffer, so switching from
a truncate buffer to a wrap buffer changes the effective mode with no
config event at all. A design listening only to on_change is silently
wrong and passes every single-buffer test.
Q#LL8 --- the scroll indicator falsifies the locality claim. Revision
14 asserted every vertical consumer is local. format_scroll_indicator
is not: a one-line buffer wrapping to fifty screen rows has
total_lines == 1, so the first branch returns "All" while forty-nine
rows sit below the viewport. The indicator claims the whole buffer is
visible when almost none of it is.
The claim is narrowed rather than abandoned, because the distinction
that bounds the cost survives: a TOTAL is one number, lazily computed
and cached; a PREFIX-SUM INDEX is O(N) resident storage. Stage 3 needs
the first and still does not need the second. All, Top and Bot need no
aggregate at all --- each is a local predicate falling out of the
render walk --- so only NN% pays, which matters because the M1 gate
measures open time on a 100MB file.
Also fixes a notation hazard. Section 7 said pos_to_display returns
"the visual row", which reads as redefining row --- the exact thing
5b.5 forbids, stated two sections apart. Every wrap-point example is
now the explicit triple {row, sub_row, col}. Writing them out makes the
point visible: both coordinates at a soft break share the same row,
because a wrap does not cross a source line. That is the information a
redefinition would have destroyed, and the pair notation hid it.
Status returns to not-approved. Both questions change what gets built,
not how, so implementation waits on them.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
A line wider than the window cannot be read past the edge in the TUI.
The GPU is not in that state --- it already wraps --- so the
cross-frontend defect is not unreadability. It is that NEITHER behavior
was chosen: the TUI truncates because a cell walk breaks at max_cols,
the GPU wraps because cosmic-text's Wrap::WordOrGlyph default was never
overridden. Two accidents that disagree, and no way to state a
preference in either.
Eleven revisions of review, and the corrections were the substance.
Revision 1 claimed both frontends render from the same CellGrid, which
inverted the entire cost model --- pmacs-gpu ignores the grid variants
and lays out locally, and its own comment says so. Later rounds caught
an impossible round-trip invariant, a "collision" between two
coordinates that were one position, an off-grid argument against a
function that has no grid, a false binary for view_top, and a
renumbered visible-line space that does not exist. Each is recorded
with its reasoning rather than quietly fixed, because the pattern ---
an assertion that reads as precise while resting on something
unverified --- is more useful to the next reader than any single fix.
All six questions are answered and the framing is approved:
LL1 wrap + truncate, default wrap; horizontal scroll is Stage 4
LL2 buffer-local mode, resolved into Viewport like folds
LL4 do not adopt editing.fill-column; ours is ui.line-wrap
LL5 character wrap in BOTH frontends
LL6 no global map; byte-anchored view_top; additive DisplayCoord
Two of those deserve to be found later rather than discovered:
GUI users lose word wrap. Character-wrap parity is cheap, true, and
matches Emacs, whose default wrap is also a character wrap. But the GPU
has word-wrapped since it existed and nobody opted into losing it. The
alternative was a UAX #14 dependency, because a whitespace-based grid
wrap would give only APPROXIMATE parity against cosmic-text's Unicode
line breaking --- which is worse than honest divergence, since it looks
unified until it is not.
The audit strategy is asymmetric deliberately. The coordinate functions
gain a required context parameter so the compiler enumerates every call
site; DisplayCoord gains an additive sub_row so untouched consumers
stay CORRECT rather than merely findable. Compiler-enforced where
enforcement is possible, correct-by-default where it is not.
Also corrects two ledger headers that still said OPEN for PRs merged
earlier today (#218 at 09:59Z, #217's absorption; #219 at 13:41Z).
Neither lane is removed --- rule 4 removes a lane when its ARC is done,
not when a PR merges, and the QoL arc has this stage left. Read each
block before cutting it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
The zoom lane recorded `1e054f7` as the authoritative tip. Committing
that line advanced the tip to b645fe7, so the claim was false before it
was pushed --- self-invalidating, not merely out of date.
The ledger already says this, twice: the docs-absorption and
signal-integrity lanes both note that any edit to their block advances
past whatever SHA it records, so the REF is the thing to trust. I wrote
a new lane without following the convention the file states about
itself.
Removes the SHA and says why, so the next lane inherits the reason
rather than the rule alone.
The base SHA stays. 218d2e7 is a merge commit that already exists and
nothing here can move it --- it is a fact about where the branch
started, not a claim about where it is.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
The lane went stale across two review rounds. It said framing revision
4, 13 acceptance tests, and "the three findings review caught" --- all
true when written, none true now.
Brings it current: revision 5, the pushed tip, 15 tests, and the two
later findings. The quantization one gets a real entry rather than a
mention, because its content is a REUSABLE fact about this codebase ---
ConfigKind::Number validates finiteness and bounds and nothing else,
and on_change cannot veto --- so any future setting needing a stronger
predicate than a range meets the same wall.
Also records the verification asymmetry that mattered: the raw-step
bite fails the new witness while the pre-existing 0.37 test still
passes. That is why it had to be a separate test, and it is the kind of
detail a lane summary usually drops.
New section for pre-checkout CI reds, which #220 hit three times. The
job dies in "Set up job" before actions/checkout; grepping the full log
for checkout/cargo/test-result returns 0. No code is fetched, so the
red says nothing about the commit in either direction --- re-running it
is a first execution, not a retry-to-green.
It gets a section here and not a registry row on purpose: matching
requires an exact test selector plus fragments, and no test ran. Making
it a row would mean deforming the row shape. Whether the registry wants
a non-row section for the class is left to its owner.
Written down rather than acted on silently because the registry's
opening instruction is to read it BEFORE attributing a red run to the
environment, and that is exactly the attribution being made here.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Ctrl +/- had no effect whatsoever in the GPU frontend. Stage 1 (#219)
fixed what zoom did to the TUI; this is the other half.
NO RENDERING WORK. FontMetrics::scale already derived every GUI
dimension — code size, line height, status band, divider, menu rows,
minibuffer dropdown, gutter advance — and apply_font_facts already
re-metriced all seven buffers in one transaction. This drives the
preference that existed: two settings, three commands, and a restore.
Q#Z1 = (c). Relative zoom needs an origin and the daemon is built never
to know one — font_pref.rs is explicit that it "never learns metrics,
advances, or what resolves". Hardcoding 16.0 would put a pixel constant
on the daemon side; always sending a size would destroy the `None`
state for everyone who never zooms. A configured base is the only
option where the daemon still infers nothing, and the untouched path
stays byte-identical.
THREE THINGS REVIEW CAUGHT THAT REVISION 1 HAD WRONG.
Q#Z3 was not implementable as framed. `keymap_stack::Scope` is
Buffer | Mode | Global and carries no frontend identity, so "bind on
GPU frontends only" does not exist; and FrontendEvent has no
command-invocation variant, so the GPU cannot ask for a command by name
either. A global binding would capture the chord in the TUI and take
away the terminal's own zoom — the very thing the user is pressing it
for. Commands ship; the binding waits on capability-aware keymap
resolution, which is now a named follow-on rather than something
smuggled in here.
The restore seam did not exist. Builtins and init.lua both run BEFORE
install_state_dirs, so a pmacs.state.read at module load returns
nothing, always. saveplace and recentf never meet this because both
read lazily inside functions; zoom must apply with no user action,
which makes it this project's first eager state consumer. Restore lives
at the end of install_state_dirs — by definition the moment state
becomes readable, so it cannot be ordered wrongly and a future third
startup path gets it without knowing it had to ask.
Every size write clobbered the family. set_font replaces both fields
unconditionally, so { size = n } alone silently cleared a configured
family until restart.
BITTEN, THREE WAYS. Dropping family preservation fails 3 tests.
Reverting to the framing's own first parser `^(%d+)$` fails 4 including
the seam restore — it anchors to end-of-subject and rejects the
newline-terminated file the writer emits, which is the contradiction
review caught in the framing before it reached code. Hardcoding the
16.0 origin fails the base test.
Also recorded: a loaded crdt run failed two m6_1 PTY tests with
`stty -a output was: ""`. That is R4/R6's empty-content readiness
family, and it means the readiness-helper audit's scope is wider than
three wait_for_file copies under tests/ — src/process.rs's own tests
carry the shape. Undiagnosed, load-sensitive, green isolated and on a
quiet full run; a scope note for that lane, not a registry row, since
the registry judges red CI runs and these were local.
Verified: fmt, clippy, diff-check, --lib 1900/0, crdt 2085/0,
gui_zoom 13/13, journey 47/0, m4 150/0, gpu 221/0, full_grid 1/1.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Zooming a terminal with Ctrl +/- left the TUI showing the previous
frame through the new one. Q#FG1 = A, as approved.
THE RULE WAS ALREADY WRITTEN DOWN, ON A PRIVATE FIELD.
src/instance_render.rs:36 says remote frontends "must blank their local
buffer before applying the deltas" — the binding contract, in the one
place a consumer author will never look. The protocol type said only
that full_grid marks "the initial sync ... versus an incremental
frame": a label, from which no obligation follows. So FG-INV now lives
on InstanceMessage::CellDelta, where whoever writes the next frontend
reads it. A resync is a picture of the screen's INK, not of the screen.
The producer diffs against a blank grid, so a cell that should be blank
produces no span. src/frontend.rs then took `CellDelta { spans, .. }`
and discarded the flag. That was correct for exactly one frame — the
fresh-attach frame, which follows Frontend::new's Clear — and wrong for
every resize after, which follows nothing. A font-size change is the
worst case because the terminal reflows in place rather than dropping
content, so the maximum number of stale glyphs survive.
emit_cell_delta joins emit_span and emit_status_overlay as a pure
helper over a writer; apply_message routes through it. No struct
change, no generic parameter, no new pattern.
WHY SEVEN TESTS MISSED IT. Every one asserts the producer SETS the
flag; none asserted a consumer ACTS on it, and no runtime reader
existed workspace-wide. "Add a test for the flag" had already been
done and did not help. Handoff §5's enforcement-vs-documentation drift,
in a second register.
Three unit witnesses, each bitten independently. The empty-spans case
earns its own test rather than folding into the others: under the
plausible `spans.is_empty()` early return the ordering test still
PASSES and only that one fails — and an empty resync is exactly the
frame whose entire content is the blanking.
The PTY acceptance drives a real SIGWINCH, and its mark is anchored to
CONTENT rather than time. A time-based settle was written first and is
unusable: a settled pmacs screen emits per-frame bytes forever, so
"output stopped growing" never becomes true. Anchoring just past the
first painted byte excludes both startup clears by construction —
Frontend::new clears before any frame exists, and the first frame is
itself a resync whose clear precedes its own spans. Bitten against the
original defect: 34,831 bytes after the first painted frame, no CSI 2 J
anywhere in them.
What it does not prove, stated here rather than found in review: the
suites assert on raw bytes, with no screen model and no vt100/termwiz/
vte dependency. This shows pmacs emitted a blank at the right moment,
not that the screen ended correct.
Verified: fmt, clippy, diff-check, --lib 1900/0, crdt 2085/0, m4 150/0,
gpu 221/0, and the grid-driving suites — full_grid_resync 1/1, vterm
1/2/3 9+9+5, m5_5 15, m5_8 5, bottom_panel_stage1 47.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1. THE CENTRAL RULE LACKED ITS TIME QUALIFIER. It said any red matching
a retired row is a recurrence — under which this PR's own R2 finding
reopens R2. Now: a match POSTDATING the retirement challenges the
disposition; a match predating it corroborates. That is not a
technicality. An occurrence scan reaches backwards by construction, so
most matches it finds are the earlier kind, and the old wording would
reopen every retired row the first time anyone scanned.
2. R5 AND R6 SAT UNDER "RETIRED ROWS" while declaring themselves live
and undiagnosed. I inserted them before R2's heading, which put them in
the wrong section — presentation contradicting classification in a file
whose whole job is classification. Moved under Live rows.
3. RECOVERY ANCHORS STILL DECLARED 12f2970, so the check accepted a
checkout lacking #216 and #217 while the same file described both as
complete. Advanced to db1bbe9, with the ancestry verified rather than
assumed.
4. THE HANDOFF'S DURABLE TREE FACTS STILL SAID IDS ARE OPAQUE AND
COMPARED BY EQUALITY — the contract ef99b64 deliberately narrowed. A §5
lesson explaining a correction does not fix a summary that still states
the uncorrected fact; the summary is what a new agent reads first.
Corrected there and in the header, which also still called Stage 2 in
flight and anchored main at f186253.
AND ONE FINDING FROM RE-EXERCISING THE RECOVERY PATH RATHER THAN
SWAPPING ITS SHA. This file claimed `git worktree add <path>
githubsucks/<branch>` fails with "fatal: invalid reference". It does
not fail. On git 2.55.0 it SUCCEEDS and leaves a detached HEAD — no
branch, no upstream.
Still use -b, but the reason is the opposite of the one recorded: the
hazard is not an error that stops you, it is that nothing stops you.
Work committed there sits on no branch and is not pushed by a bare
`git push` — the "uncommitted work does not travel" hazard wearing the
shape of committed work. A documented error message that never appears
is worse than no documentation, because the reader waits for a signal
that is not coming.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, --lib, listview 26/26. Recovery path re-run
from an empty directory at the new base; all four steps clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The ledger requires a lane for every open PR. #171 drifted 153 commits
while invisible here and #215 had no lane until review caught it, so
the block goes in with the lane's own commits rather than after someone
asks for it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
RULE 4 REMOVES A LANE AFTER MERGE, and two were overdue: the tree
primitive (#217) and macOS CI signal integrity (#215, #216).
The macOS arc could not simply be deleted. It owned R1 and R3, and a
lane removed while it still owns undone work does not close that work,
it hides it. R1 goes to a new async-runtime block; R3 goes to the
reap-ledger lane, which already parks every disposition change pending
exactly its question. Re-homing first is why this did not happen at
merge.
AN OCCURRENCE SCAN (last 25 main runs: 23 green, 2 red) found both reds
unrecorded, and I misattributed both on the first pass — by theme
rather than by required fragment, which is the exact error the registry
exists to prevent.
- Run 30710662474 is NOT R3. Same test, same EPERM, same
measured_group=unobservable(ESRCH...) — but R3 requires `leader=live`
and this reads `leader=exited(signal SIGUSR1)`, R2's exact fragment.
It is a second R2 occurrence, four days BEFORE R2's retirement, so it
corroborates the row rather than falsifying its disposition. It also
adds something: macOS luajit where R2's evidence was lua54, so the
mechanism was never flavor-specific. Filing it as R3 would have
attached a live possible product defect to an occurrence of a fixed
test race.
- Run 30555667095 is NOT R1. Different test, different module,
different assertion; they share only "supersede under a deadline on
macOS". Sharing a subject is not sharing a signature. Filed as R5,
undiagnosed.
R6 is the acc28 readiness timeout from #217's CI. Its scope is the
AUDIT, not the call site: three independently written readiness helpers
now exist and they disagree, with bottom_panel_stage1's carrying only
the zero-byte half of #216's hardening. R4's disposition predicted this
recurrence under a new selector. Patching acc28 alone repeats the
mistake this arc already made once, when the empty-file predicate was
fixed in one helper and left in its neighbour.
The registry carries a rate for the first time — a floor, not a
measurement: main only, 25 runs, readable reds only.
Four durable lessons to the handoff, two from the tree review: an
optional field the shape depends on is not optional, and a contract two
mechanisms must honour is only as strong as the weaker one.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, --lib, listview 26/26. Docs-only.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
#216 landed while this branch was open. Both conflicts are in the
ledger and the handoff, and both sides had independently written up the
same shared-CARGO_TARGET_DIR hazard.
THE TWO WRITE-UPS ARE NOT ABOUT THE SAME OCCURRENCE, and merging them
carelessly would have been a real error. Stage 2's is established: seven
failures against a clean baseline, failure text naming its own cause,
pgrep confirmation, and a dedicated-target-dir re-run at 41/41. This
lane's is the one whose signatures were destroyed before being read —
it has no captured text to match against Stage 2's, and it keeps two
non-causal hypotheses. A mechanism established in one occurrence is not
evidence about a different occurrence that was never characterized, so
the merged bullet says so explicitly rather than letting proximity
imply it.
The ledger records #216 merged and stops saying Stage 2 is in flight.
It does NOT retire the arc, though rule 4 now would: R1 belongs to the
async-runtime lane and R3 is an unresolved possible product defect for
the process-signal lane, and neither has a block yet. Re-homing them is
an absorption pass — not something to fold into a feature PR.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
It said "Unpushed while held" while githubsucks/tree-primitive-framing
sat at the same tip as HEAD. Held means no PR is open; it does not mean
the work is stranded locally, and the handoff's portability rule cares
about the latter.
The commit list also claimed to be exhaustive and then excluded the
commit that updated it — a list of that shape is wrong the moment it is
written. It is now the substantive arc, with `git log` named as the
place to get the complete one, and the remote ref rather than a pinned
SHA named as the authoritative tip: any edit to this lane advances past
whatever SHA the lane records, including this one.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
FOUR REVIEW FINDINGS, and the first two were right about the tests.
1. THE SELECTION ACCEPTANCE WAS VACUOUS. `tr_1` toggles the selected
root, which sits on line 1 before and after collapsing — so it passes
unchanged under the line-based re-seating that id-keyed re-seating was
built to replace. It proves collapse hides descendants; it proves
nothing about selection. `tr_4` adds the case that discriminates: an
`on_refresh` inserts a row ABOVE the selected node, so the node moves,
and the assertion is that selection follows the NODE. Bitten by
restoring `seat_cursor(p, saved)`: `tr_4` fails with left " kid2",
right "sibling", while old `tr_1` passes — which is the finding,
reproduced.
The substantive assertion is deliberately ordered first. It was second
at one point, behind the fixture check that the node moved, and a
regression then reported as "the insert must move the selected node" —
reading like a broken fixture rather than a broken re-seat.
2. FLAT PANELS WERE NOT BEHAVIOUR-IDENTICAL. `bind_local_keymap` binds
TAB on every listview, so a depthless panel that previously fell
through to the global binding — and to Q#P3's read-only intercept —
began answering "listview: no node here". `listview.toggle` now
delegates to `buffer.tab` when no row carries an id, restoring the
prior path exactly; leaf feedback is kept for panels that really are
trees. `tr_3` asserts the absence of both tree messages rather than
merely that the panel still renders.
3 and 4 are documentation. The lane now lists 38e94dc, and no longer
says the PR is held "pending review of the documentation" that the same
commit supplied — it is held pending the decision to open it. §20 said
to BUILD the tree primitive while §14 already carried ◐; it now says
what actually remains, which is adoption: dired's `i` is the next
constraint source, DAP's variables view is why this was worth building
before them.
ONE RED, CLASSIFIED RATHER THAN RERUN AWAY. The crdt lib gate failed
`composition_overhead_under_ten_percent` at 30.7%. It is an incumbent
handoff hazard, and the branch cannot reach it — the diff versus main
touches no src/, no crate, no manifest. Alone it ran 5/5 green at
-0.6% to +0.2%; the next full run was green. Recorded in the handoff as
a MEASUREMENT, not a cause: five isolated greens establish that the
ratio is nowhere near the threshold when alone, not that contention is
what pushed it over. Not a registry row either — that file judges red
CI runs, and this was local.
Verified: fmt, clippy, diff-check, --lib 1896/0, --lib --features crdt
2081/0, listview 22/22, m4 150/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three updates, one of which was a broken cross-reference of my own
making.
THE DAEMON-LEAK ENTRY POINTED AT A LANE THAT DID NOT EXIST. It said the
unclassified failure was "recorded in the tree lane below"; this branch
had no tree lane. A pointer to nothing is worse than no pointer — it
reads as though the record exists and sends the next reader looking. The
tree lane is added, and since it now sits ABOVE that entry the direction
is corrected too, with a second pointer to the framing §6a where the
occurrence is recorded in full.
The lane carries branch, base, framing revision, every commit, the gate
table with both sweeps and their exact reconciliations, the bite
verification for both behavioural claims, the held-PR state and the
recovery command. It also names what is NOT in scope, because the four
unadopted §14 consumers and dired's `i` will otherwise read as omissions
from this stage rather than as later ones.
COHERENCE.md §14: Tree moves ✗ -> ◐, implemented with ONE consumer. Not
✓, and the row says why: the LSP outline is the only adopter, dired's
`i` remains the deferral in its §13, and the other four named consumers
have not adopted. The organising fact goes in the section rather than
only in the framing — folding is LOCAL PROJECTION STATE, NOT A REFRESH
PROTOCOL, which is why a consumer with no `on_refresh` can fold at all.
The §0 scorecard row moves with the body; a grade table disagreeing with
its own section is the defect this document keeps correcting in others.
The framing's status moves from "approved" to implemented-and-gated,
held for PR review, and four durable facts go to the handoff §1: folding
as projection state; identity being consumer-supplied and compared by
equality, with `line:col` chosen because the `::` parent chain collides
on overloads; `has_children` having to read the full row array rather
than the rendered subset, since a collapsed node's children are absent
from it by construction and the bug would look like fold working and
unfold silently not; and that a bite which passes validates the pair
rather than the test.
The daemon leak stays a separate reap-ledger candidate. It is not tree
scope, it predates this work, and folding it in would make a lane
responsible for a leak it did not cause.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, listview 21/21, --lib 1896/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
ACCEPTANCE 5, and it needed a real test rather than a weakened claim.
`listview_acceptance` says in its own header that the references panel
"needs a live LSP and is validated manually / via the m4 harness", so it
does not exercise `*references*` at all; the m4 hover test asserts
content PRESENCE, not exact output. Neither would notice a flat consumer
silently gaining an indent column — the regression a tree extension can
introduce. So the coverage is written against the real entry points
through the fake language server.
`*references*` is pinned EXACTLY: the row is the location string and
nothing else. `*lsp*` formats its own two-space indentation, so
"starts with a space" is not a violation there; what must hold is that
the primitive reproduces the consumer's text verbatim, matched as a
WHOLE LINE — a substring would still be found inside a further-indented
copy of itself. Volatile parts (pid, elapsed) are deliberately excluded,
the same normalization reasoning the CI registry uses.
THE FIRST BITE PASSED, AND THAT WAS THE FINDING. Injecting
`string.rep(" ", row.depth or 0)` did not fail the test — flat rows
carry no depth, so it added nothing. I had simulated a regression the
flat path is immune to and would have recorded the test as verified.
The regression this criterion actually guards is an UNCONDITIONAL
column, a fold gutter on every row; with that injected the test fails on
"the flat references row renders verbatim". A bite that passes validates
the pair, not the test — and injecting the wrong defect teaches nothing
while feeling like assurance.
A VERIFICATION RECORD, including one unclassified occurrence. The first
local crdt sweep of this branch reported 7 failures and its SIGNATURES
WERE DESTROYED before being read, piped through an aggregation that
emitted only totals. That is the failure the CI registry exists to
prevent, committed one lane after writing it, and it is why the cause
cannot now be established rather than merely being unknown.
It is recorded in this lane's own framing and deliberately NOT as a
registry row: that registry keys on a normalized signature, and an
occurrence with none would be granted a recognisability it cannot
support — the same reasoning that made the unevidenced incumbents audit
notes rather than rows.
Four re-runs are tabulated with what each supports. Two were not
isolated, including one where my own guard printed "aborting" and did
not abort. TWO GENUINELY ISOLATED RUNS ARE BOTH CLEAN, which supports
repeatability under isolation and establishes nothing about the cause.
Two mechanisms are recorded as NON-CAUSAL hypotheses, because both were
present and neither can now be tested: a shared CARGO_TARGET_DIR (whose
reciprocal case another lane observed independently, with `pgrep`
evidence and failing text that named its own cause), and ~40 resident
leaked daemons. Having two plausible mechanisms and no way to
discriminate IS the result; naming either would repeat the reasoning
this project has rejected — concluding something about an occurrence
from something that was not about that occurrence.
Both mechanisms are recorded as standing hazards in the handoff, and the
daemon leak gets its own candidate lane: 42 orphans, oldest four days,
reparented to systemd with deleted sockets, from
`gpu_invocation_acceptance`'s one-command tests, leaking 3-4 per sweep
as measured rather than estimated. It predates this work and belongs to
the reap-ledger family — a process outliving its supervisor with nothing
watching it — but the existing ledger arms only for `spec.group` and so
does not cover it.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, luajit sweep 3453/0 and crdt 3722/0, each
exactly +4 on its baseline.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Both heads that carry code are 14/14 green — `2d9c678` (the fixes and
the framing) and `668fc72` (this block). The tip row is explicit rather
than missing: a checkpoint table can never record the head that adds
the checkpoint, and #215's lane used the same convention. The branch
tip stays authoritative over any row.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fills in what could only be filled in after the fact: PR #216, the
opening head's CI run, and the four-way sweep table. Both branch totals
are exactly +4 on their baseline — the four witnesses, and nothing else
moved.
**A shared `CARGO_TARGET_DIR` makes a local sweep unattributable, and it
bit this lane.** The branch `crdt` sweep first reported seven failures
in three suites while the baseline `crdt` sweep was clean. All three
spawn the REAL `pmacs` binary out of the target directory, and the
failure text named its own cause — "daemon does not advertise required
capabilities … start the daemon built with the `crdt` feature". A
concurrent `cargo test --workspace` in a DIFFERENT WORKTREE, at default
(non-`crdt`) features and the same `CARGO_TARGET_DIR`, had overwritten
`target/debug/pmacs` mid-sweep. Confirmed with `pgrep` while it was
happening, and discriminated by re-running the same three suites from
the same tree with a dedicated target directory: 41/41 green, then the
whole configuration swept again there. Recorded in the handoff's
standing hazards, beside the feature-blindness rule it rhymes with: a
feature-flavored binary is a shared mutable file, not an artifact
private to your invocation.
The clean re-sweep left ONE failure, and it is recorded rather than
rerun away: `lsp_dispatch_seams_acceptance acc33_...`. It is a new
incident by the registry's rules, and it is not attributable to this
branch on a STRUCTURAL argument rather than on its green rerun — the
only Rust change lives in `#[cfg(test)] mod tests`, which compiles into
the lib test target alone, so an integration-test binary linking the
non-`cfg(test)` lib is exactly what `main` builds. CI's `Test (crdt)`
job passed at the same head and runs that suite. The 15/15 repetition
set is the weakest of the five points, not the argument. No registry
row is opened: the registry judges red CI runs and keys on linked CI
occurrences.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Stage 2 of `docs/macos-ci-signal-integrity-framing.md` revision 3
(acceptance 6–9). Two test races, both the same shape: the thing waited
for was weaker than the thing asserted, so the wait could return inside
the window the assertion needs closed.
R4 — `wait_for_file` returned as soon as `fs::read` succeeded, which
succeeds on a ZERO-BYTE FILE. The probe publishes with
`open(path,'wb').write(b'1')` and `open()` creates the file before
`write()` fills it, so the helper handed `[]` to a caller asserting
`== b"1"`. It now takes the expected bytes and waits while the file
holds a STRICT PREFIX of them — the states a write in flight can be
observed in — returning anything else immediately so the caller's
`assert_eq!` stays the discriminating assertion rather than becoming a
timeout inside a helper that does not know what was expected.
All four callers pass their expectation. `wait_for_published_file`, one
function away in the same suite, gated the real-TUI smoke's
`assert_eq!(…, b"1")` on the identical predicate and is fixed with it:
leaving it would have let R4 recur under a different selector, which the
registry would then have had to judge a new incident.
R2 — the USR1 fixture waited on `ProcessEventKind::Started`, emitted at
SPAWN, not when `/bin/sh` has parsed `trap '' USR1`. SIGUSR1's default
disposition is terminate, so a signal inside that window kills the
child. The child now publishes a marker AFTER the trap and the test
waits for that marker's CONTENT (the same zero-byte trap applies to a
shell's `>` redirection). `exec` replaces the forked `sleep`, so the
group holds exactly one process and the ignored disposition survives by
POSIX rather than by the shell's fork-suppression optimization — an
unstated dependency the old fixture had, since these signals are
group-directed and a forked `sleep` is an untrapped group member.
Four witnesses, each verified by REVERTING the fix and observing the
failure rather than by reasoning about it:
- `wait_for_file_does_not_return_a_zero_byte_readiness_file` fails
`left: []`, `right: [49]` — R4's two required fragments, verbatim;
- `wait_for_file_does_not_return_a_partial_write` fails on the torn read
a length check alone would admit;
- `wait_for_file_returns_divergent_content_rather_than_timing_out` fails
against an over-strict helper that waits for an exact match;
- `usr1_readiness_waits_for_the_trap_not_for_the_spawn` fails
`left: Some("SIGUSR1")`, `right: Some("SIGTERM")` with the readiness
wait removed. Its fixture sleeps before `trap` so the pre-trap window
is deliberate rather than load-dependent, and it proves survival by
the child's EXIT DISPOSITION rather than by an absence observed within
a window.
R1 is NOT touched — referred to the async-runtime lane (Q#MCI3), because
widening its budget would make it pass and measure nothing more. R3 is
NOT touched and remains UNRESOLVED, owned by the process-signal /
reap-ledger lanes.
`docs/ci-red-signatures.md` moves R2 and R4 to a "Retired rows" section
with their dispositions and adds the rule the file needed and lacked: a
red matching a retired row is a RECURRENCE that puts the retirement in
question, never a known flake. `docs/active-work.md` carries this lane
from its first commit rather than after review asks for it.
Repetition sets, not single runs: the two `--lib` process tests 15/15,
the whole `vterm_stage2_acceptance` suite 15/15 at default parallelism.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three corrections.
"NO OCCURRENCE WAS EVER OBSERVED" OVERSTATED WHAT THE AUDIT CAN SAY.
Someone may well have seen one of these fail and simply not recorded it;
what is established is the absence of a RECORD. The framing now says
"linked or captured" and states the distinction explicitly, because an
audit that claims to know what nobody saw is making the same kind of
unfounded assertion this lane exists to remove — one level up.
A missing closing quotation mark in acceptance 3.
THE LANE CHECKPOINTED THE REVIEWED HEAD, WHICH GOES STALE ON THE NEXT
PUSH — the exact mechanism by which #171 became invisible while it
drifted 153 commits. Recording one head is a snapshot; what a resume
ledger needs is the sequence. It is now a table of head -> CI run ->
result, newest last, with the rule stated: the branch tip is
authoritative over any row, verified by `git rev-parse`, because the
table is written by hand and the tip is not.
Verified: fmt, diff-check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Five corrections, one blocking.
BLOCKING — the contract, not the implementation, was what needed
changing. Revision 2's acceptance 3 offered a binary: carry an incumbent
in with a signature and evidence, or remove it as never substantiated.
Stage 1 shipped a THIRD state because both incumbents are neither. The
framing is now revision 3 and names all three states, because a
governing criterion that says "two" while the branch does five is the
framing describing something that does not exist.
"MECHANISM NAMED" OVERSTATED THE EVIDENCE, and the phrase is retired.
The a33 audit proves an assertion string exists; the m6_8 audit proves a
test is timing-based. NEITHER ESTABLISHES A FAILURE MECHANISM — no
occurrence was ever observed, so nothing is known about how, or whether,
either fails. They are now AUDIT NOTES A1/A2 rather than registry rows,
with `R`-numbers reserved for signatures carrying linked evidence. The
distinction is not row-versus-weaker-row: a row says "this was seen,
here is the evidence", a note says "someone recorded a belief and no
occurrence backs it". Both remain unmatchable, so a red in either test
is a new incident.
R2's SIGNATURE WAS WEAKENED AND IS RESTORED. Splitting
`leader=exited(signal SIGUSR1)` into `leader=exited(` plus `SIGUSR1`
would match a child that exited by some OTHER disposition while SIGUSR1
appeared elsewhere in the output — precisely the name-style
over-matching this registry exists to refuse, reintroduced one level
down as fragment-style over-matching. It is one exact fragment again,
and the row says why.
THE HANDOFF STILL ISSUED LIVE IMPERATIVES. Its historical block opened
with "rerun isolated before treating a sweep failure as a regression"
and closed with "rerun the test alone before investigating", so the
supersession note I added sat between two instructions it contradicted.
Both are rewritten as record: the block now reports what that lane
OBSERVED, and the retired instruction is marked retired with its reason
— an isolated green reproduces nothing about a load-sensitive failure.
#215 HAD NO LANE, in the file that requires one for every open PR and
records why: #171 drifted 153 commits while invisible there. That is the
same defect, caught in review rather than 153 commits later. The lane
now carries branch, base, PR, reviewed head, what Stage 1 ships, the
verification, what Stage 2 owes, and the recovery worktree command. Both
snapshot headers are bumped.
Also narrowed a claim the PR body overstated: the registry is NOT
macOS-only. All four EVIDENCED rows are macOS, which is a property of
these occurrences; A1's job is `GPU Render (headless)`, which runs on
Ubuntu, and A2's job was never recorded. A future row from any job
belongs in the same table.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, clippy, --lib 1896, --lib --features crdt
2081.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Stage 1 of the macOS CI signal-integrity lane. `docs/ci-red-signatures.md`
is now the single authority for judging a red CI run.
NOT NAMED "FLAKES", DELIBERATELY. One of its rows is a possible product
defect, and a filename calling it a flake would confer immunity the
evidence does not support.
A ROW MATCHES ON SIGNATURE, NEVER ON TEST NAME. All three of selector,
job/flavor and every required fragment must hold. Fragments are
normalized rather than pasted: PIDs, elapsed times and rendered
OS-error suffixes vary between runs, so a verbatim key would match
nothing, and where a fragment lists alternatives (ESRCH / "No such
process") those are one condition rendered differently by platform. A
failure in a listed test WITHOUT that row's fragments is a new incident.
The process test is why that rule exists: it produced TWO signatures
with different mechanisms and different causal status, and only one is a
test bug. Four incidents, three tests, four signatures — the registry
counts signatures.
THE RERUN RULE IS REPLACED, NOT SOFTENED. A green rerun establishes
INTERMITTENCE ONLY — never environmental cause, harmlessness, or
retirement. The same signature again is a second occurrence and stays
blocking pending investigation or a merge-base control. A different
signature is a new incident.
RETIREMENT IS CAUSAL. A test race retires by hardening that removes the
mechanism plus a discriminating witness; a measurement-design row by its
owning lane replacing or justifying the measurement; an unresolved row
by diagnosis and disposition. Main-branch greens accumulate as
occurrence evidence and retire nothing.
THE AUDIT FOUND A THIRD CATEGORY the framing's acceptance 3 did not
anticipate. It said each incumbent is either carried in with a signature
and evidence, or removed as never substantiated. Both incumbents are in
between: the tests are real and the mechanisms plausible — a33's "blue
pixels" is a genuine assertion string at pmacs-gpu/src/main.rs:17973,
and m6_8 exists and is timing-based — but NEITHER HAS A LINKED
OCCURRENCE. Deleting them would discard a real observation; carrying
them as peers of the evidenced rows would grant exactly the reputation
this lane exists to deny.
They are recorded as "mechanism named, no occurrence recorded", with it
stated that nothing there confers known-flaky status and that a red
matching one is a FIRST recorded occurrence to be investigated. R6 goes
further: with no signature ever captured it CANNOT BE MATCHED AT ALL, so
a red in that test is a new incident by default. That is the correct
outcome for an entry that never carried evidence.
LIVE POLICY IS CENTRALIZED; HISTORICAL EVIDENCE IS NOT MOVED. The
handoff's hazards rule becomes a pointer. Its landed-lesson block at
§5 keeps its own evidence and gains a note that the registry's rerun
rule supersedes "rerun isolated". active-work.md's two mentions are
verification records for the reap-ledger and bottom-panel lanes and are
left alone; only the CI-weakness block's triage half points at the
registry, because the job-cost question there is genuinely separate.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, clippy with and without crdt, --lib 1896,
--lib --features crdt 2081, pmacs-protocol 19, m4 149, required GPU 221.
All three tests the registry names pass locally on Linux, which is
consistent with every row being macOS-only and is not evidence about
any of them.
Docs only. Stage 2 (hardening) is a separate PR.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Rule 4 removes a lane when its ARC is done AND its durable facts are in
docs/agent-handoff.md. Both hold: #213 merged, and §1 carries the five
facts Stage 3 produced. The lane goes; the distribution and CI-CRDT
lanes stay, rewritten, because each keeps named follow-ons.
The canonical base and the RECOVERY FLOOR both advance to f186253. The
floor moving with the base is this file's own rule, and the reason is
worth restating: a check that accepts an older commit than the declared
base passes on a tree the rest of the file does not describe. The three
places that named cfc1710 — the base line, the prose, and the `git log`
verification step — now name f186253 together, because a floor that
advances in one place and not the others is worse than one that does not
advance at all.
TWO CI WEAKNESSES STAGE 3 EXPOSED, recorded in the crdt lane that owns
that job rather than lost with the lane being retired:
* CI does not pass --no-fail-fast, so a multi-suite break reports as a
single-suite one. #213's first crdt failure showed ONE suite where a
local --no-fail-fast sweep of the same tree showed THIRTEEN. The
Stage 3 census hit the identical trap and recorded it; CI has it
too.
* The crdt job pairs the heaviest build — lavapipe, full workspace
with crdt, the largest test count — with real-PTY smokes on
5-second deadlines. #213 saw two different such suites fail on two
runs of the same commit; one was a real regression, the other was
load. That ambiguity is the actual problem: a job where noise and
signal look alike trains people to rerun rather than read.
Neither is a defect and neither is fixed here. They are decisions about
what the crdt job should cost, and they belong to whoever picks that
lane up.
Two ops lessons move to the handoff §5, both learned the expensive way
on #213:
* A LOCAL SWEEP IS BLIND TO WHICHEVER FEATURE CONFIGURATION IT DOES
NOT BUILD. Stage 3's census and every verification sweep ran
`--features luajit` without `crdt`, so compile_mode_crdt_acceptance
reached CI broken. Sweep both configurations before calling a corpus
green.
* "MY CHANGE MADE THIS FRAGILE" IS A DIFFERENT FINDING FROM "THIS WAS
ALWAYS FLAKY", and only one of them is yours to fix. Two CI runs on
one commit failed different PTY/GPU suites — the load-sensitivity
signature, on suites the flake list already names. The tell that it
was neither: the failures kept landing on GPU TERMINAL tests, and
terminal placement was what the PR changed. Ask which tests and why
those, before reaching for a rerun.
Docs only.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Branch-plan step 6. The lane, the handoff, COHERENCE, and the framing all
still described Stage 3 as ahead.
COHERENCE §14's scorecard row and §20's Priority 5 both said the adopter
default flip was what remained on the panel. It is done, so the panel
half of P5 is closed and the TREE PRIMITIVE becomes the arc's successor —
§14 grades Tree ✗, and DAP's variables view is its next would-be
inventor. That sequencing is now stated where the next framing doc will
read it rather than living in a conversation.
The lane is RETAINED, not removed, because the PR has not landed; rule 4
removes it once Stage 3 merges and its facts are in the handoff. Both
conditions are half-met, and recording that honestly is cheaper than
discovering later which half.
Five durable facts move to the handoff §1, each of which cost a review
round or a defect to learn:
* A VISIT FROM A PANEL MUST NEVER USE THE RAW SWITCH.
`pmacs.window.switch_buffer` replaces the buffer in the ACTIVE
window, so from a panel it clobbers the panel itself. Q#BP11c is the
contract: after RET, `M-,` must FOCUS the still-present panel rather
than clone its buffer into the document — and an assertion on the
active buffer NAME alone cannot distinguish those two outcomes.
* AN OPT-OUT THAT DOES NOT SURVIVE REPLAY IS NOT AN OPT-OUT. Anything
that replays a stored invocation must store the escape hatch with
it, or the escape hatch is a one-shot that silently reverts.
* Compile's chords are PANEL-LOCAL, deliberately, and `M-x
compile.kill` still reaches the slot from anywhere. A global chord is
a command-surface decision framed separately.
* Two `q` mechanisms coexist by design — presentation history chains in
the side slot; `p.prev` prevents raw-switch and capability-fallback
loops. Neither supersedes the other.
* A CAPABILITY FALLBACK MUST STRIP THE QUIT ACTION TOO, not just the
side parameters. A quit action stranded on a document window makes a
later `q` try to restore a presentation that never happened.
The framing reaches revision 4 with the three defects the flip exposed
(§1.7a–c) and the census lesson (§1.6d): it counted FAILURES, not
CAUSES, and the two differed by an order of magnitude — thirteen listview
failures were one missing frame-geometry declaration. Read a census as
"how many assertions move", never "how many decisions are required".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Review finding P1: Stage 3 was neither portable nor accurately
recoverable. `bottom-panel-stage3` had no upstream and no
`githubsucks/` ref, while docs/active-work.md still described Stage 3 as
"not started" — so a reader on another machine would have found a lane
claiming nothing existed, and no way to fetch the two commits that did.
That is precisely the failure this ledger records as its own rule:
"When a PR is opened, give it a lane", learned when #171 drifted 153
commits while invisible here. A branch without a PR is the same hazard
with less warning.
The lane now carries branch, base, the two completed steps with their
hashes, what remains, the verification at this head, and a recovery
command.
Review finding P2: the framing retained state the census superseded. It
still said "Nothing has been implemented or measured" and that the
blast-radius measurement "has not been taken", directly contradicting
§1.6b two screens below. Both bullets are rewritten to point at the
measurement rather than deny it, and the dired question is marked
DECIDED rather than left open.
Also records, in both documents, the thing step 2's original commit
message overstated: it is DEFAULT-PRESERVING WITH ONE INTENTIONAL
NORMALIZATION, not "behaviour-preserving". Every adopter kept its
default and the suite is byte-identical to baseline, but terminal's
invalid-input behaviour moved on purpose — and the sweep could not have
caught it, because every existing assertion passes an unknown STRING,
which takes the same path under both designs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two parts, one intent: record the release, and fix the user-facing
surfaces it falsified.
ABSORPTION. v1.1.0 shipped and nothing recorded it. docs/active-work.md
had no distribution lane, the handoff anchor still named c5f7501, and
COHERENCE.md — a REQUIRED framing input — still asserted "zero release
machinery exists" and graded journey step 1 as source-build-only. Both
are now false, and a framing doc written against them would have been
written against a lie.
* §0 scorecard: step 1 Partial -> Works; §17 Missing -> Partial; the
journey row moves off "steps 1, 11 and 12 remain the thin end" to
name 11 and 12 only.
* §17 ground truth rewritten: what Stage 1 shipped, and the nine
things it explicitly did not.
* §20 Priority 8: "State: zero" -> Stage 1 shipped, with the blocker
it named ("every other priority's value is invisible until this one
exists") recorded as LIFTED. Its next increment is a DECISION about
channels/update/signing, not a queued plan — worth stating so nobody
treats Stage 2 as pre-approved.
* A distribution lane in active-work.md, rewritten-not-removed because
the arc is not done.
Five durable facts move to the handoff §1, each of which cost something
to learn:
* a release build can produce FIVE binaries and three must never ship;
layer-2 exclusion is load-bearing, demonstrated when target/release
still held all three after building only two;
* `env!("CARGO_PKG_VERSION")` expands in the crate being COMPILED, and
three correct tests could not fail while two crates shared a number;
* pin release runners, and assert the glibc floor from the binary
rather than trusting the pin;
* a tag pushed before its workflow reaches the default branch does
nothing, SILENTLY;
* verify from the downloaded artifact, with a negative control — the
1,576 `loro` strings mean nothing without the control build's zero.
STALENESS, found by reading the surfaces a new downloader hits first.
`pmacs --help` claimed the TUI was "currently the only frontend;
reserved for the M4 GUI rollout, where `pmacs` will default to the GUI".
That is not merely dated — it is false in a release that SHIPS the GPU
frontend as a second binary. Rewritten to say what -nw actually does
(name the default explicitly for scripts and wrappers), and --gpu now
states its two real preconditions: a `crdt` build, and pmacs-gpu either
beside the binary or on PATH. Both are things a downloader can get
wrong and neither was documented where they would look.
Also in main.rs: the TLS attach line said "activation in v0.2" and four
doc comments dated themselves "v0.1" or "M4+" while describing behaviour
that is still current. The behaviour claims were accurate; only the
version labels lied, so the labels are gone rather than the sentences
rewritten. One comment gained a correction it needed regardless —
FrontendChoice is IN-PROCESS dispatch and the GPU frontend is not a
value of it, which the old text implied it eventually would be.
README status block: v1.0.0 -> v1.1.0, protocol v20 -> v21, and it
pointed at docs/roadmap-2026-07.md for "current direction" — a file that
opens by calling itself a historical snapshot and redirecting to the
handoff. It now points at COHERENCE.md and the handoff, and mentions the
arcs that landed since it was last touched.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, clippy with and without crdt, --lib 1896,
--lib --features crdt 2081, pmacs-protocol 19, m4 149, required GPU 221,
and `pmacs --help` rendered and read.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two jobs: absorb the CI CRDT coverage lane now that #209 has merged, and
clear documentation drift that predates it and was found while reading
in on a new machine.
ABSORPTION. docs/active-work.md's lane is REWRITTEN, not removed —
rule 4 removes a lane when its ARC is done, and three named follow-ons
remain. It shrinks from 10,441 to 3,037 characters because rule 3 puts
durable architecture in the handoff and leaves only volatile state here.
The follow-ons, each with its reason:
* the macOS crdt leg, deferred pending first-run evidence that NOW
EXISTS and is favourable — the non-crdt macOS legs pass at 3,474,
thirteen fewer than ubuntu's 3,487 purely from cfg-compilation of
the Linux-gated process tests, and no crdt-specific failure appeared
anywhere;
* the --lib --features crdt flake, which did NOT reproduce in #209's
runs — but every run was --test-threads=1 and the trigger was seen
under PARALLEL load, so that is consistent with the drain_until
hypothesis rather than evidence against it. Its own PR: a
product-defect hypothesis, where all of #209 was configuration;
* the crdt_replica serde default, a third default mechanism that
disagrees with the Default impl in non-CRDT builds, untestable
without a self-describing format this crate does not depend on.
Five durable facts move to the handoff §1, each of which contradicted
something previously recorded: gpu-render runs a DIFFERENT PACKAGE than
the suites the old fix-shape wanted moved there; PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU is
absent from two of the four GPU suites; m10_10_perf is a CI-default
tripwire rather than a bench; --keep-going is what makes a clippy run an
inventory instead of a lower bound; and a feature can matter to a crate
a per-test census scores as unaffected.
DRIFT, all of it predating this lane and all found while reading in:
* COHERENCE.md §20's Priority 1 still read "runs to step 5; thin from
step 6" and called Stage 1b-3 "in flight", while §0's scorecard said
step 10 and 1b-3 had landed. §20 is a REQUIRED FRAMING INPUT per
CLAUDE.md, so a stale priority annotation there does not just sit
wrong — it misdirects the next framing doc written against it. Its
arc-cuts list carried the same two errors.
* docs/agent-handoff.md §1 described Discovery Stage 1 and Journey
1b-3 as "IMPLEMENTED, PR open" while §1a, twenty lines above,
correctly recorded both as merged. A file that contradicts itself is
worse than one that is merely behind.
* docs/side-quest-backlog.md, compiled 2026-07-14, listed #123 as an
open PR (merged 2026-07-21), #137 as "in review" (merged), and
HTML/CSS as an unshipped grammar (#146 shipped it AND its injection
consumers). It is the cross-cutting index, so a stale entry sends
someone to build something that already exists. Its north-star
section now says plainly that every original item has shipped and
that the file no longer sets direction — COHERENCE.md §20 and the
handoff §1a do, and both postdate it.
* docs/json-yaml-framing.md's status line advertised "PR #123 open and
awaiting review" for six weeks after that PR merged. Corrected in
the status line only; the revision-4 body is the as-reviewed text
and is left unedited.
No code, no workflow, no protocol change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Acceptance 8 in its strongest form. The ledger predicted the post-round-2
job totals from the census — 3,766 for Test (crdt) and 3,487 for
Test (ubuntu/luajit) — and run 30706324644 @ 71a1ebd reported exactly
those. Predicting the count before the run and matching it says more
than reconciling one afterwards: a vacuous leg would have landed near
the non-crdt job's figure.
Also records two readings that would otherwise be misread:
The macOS legs report 3,474, thirteen fewer than ubuntu's 3,487. That is
cfg-compilation, not lost coverage — the Linux-gated process tests
(setsid, the `bash -m` job-control corroboration) are not built there
rather than skipped.
And the head_sha trap bit again. Round 1's run (30705916037 @ 6519bc3)
was CANCELLED, not green: round 2's push superseded it, which is the
concurrency group working exactly as its comment in ci.yml describes. A
`gh pr checks` summary polled around that moment reported the PREVIOUS
run's results — with entirely plausible timings — and round 1 was
briefly reported as passing on that basis. This ledger already carried
the lesson from #178 ("verified by head_sha, not by the check summary").
It recurs because the wrong answer looks exactly like the right one, so
it is now recorded against this lane too.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Review finding (P2), and it is this lane's own defect class one level
down. Round 1 added a `-p pmacs-protocol --features crdt` step so that
crate compiles both ways. That step EXECUTED
`InstanceCapabilities::default` in both configurations and asserted
NOTHING about it: the crate's only use of that value is a transport
round-trip, and a round-trip is invariant to the values. An all-false
default — or one whose three fields disagreed with each other — encodes,
decodes, and passes identically in both builds.
Running code is not testing it. That is the same sentence this whole
lane is about, and round 1 committed the smaller version of it while
fixing the larger one.
Three tests now pin the defaults, and the split is the point:
* under `crdt`: multi_frontend, crdt_replica and semantic_render all
default true. Advertising false on a CRDT build would strand every
frontend in single-frontend mode.
* without `crdt`: all three default false. Advertising true would be
wire-protocol false advertising — those code paths are
conditionally compiled out.
* FrontendCapabilities::default is all-false in BOTH builds, and this
test is DELIBERATELY NOT feature-gated.
That third one pins an asymmetry nothing else did.
FrontendCapabilities derives Default and is feature-INVARIANT, while
InstanceCapabilities is feature-DEPENDENT. It is load-bearing rather
than an oversight: an instance advertises what it can do, a frontend
OPTS IN through the negotiation handshake, and a v1 frontend has no
local CRDT state regardless of how the crate it links was compiled.
Making the frontend side track the feature would have frontends
claiming support they do not have. A future edit that "makes them
consistent" now fails a test that says why not to.
All three fields are asserted separately rather than by comparing whole
structs, because they track one `cfg!` and a change flipping only some
of them is exactly the regression worth catching.
Bite-verified rather than assumed: mutating `multi_frontend` to a
literal false gives `FAILED. 18 passed; 1 failed` with the expected
assertion message; restoring returns 19/19. Both configurations now
report 19 tests, up from 17, with the correct cfg-gated test running in
each.
Left untested and recorded instead: `InstanceCapabilities::crdt_replica`
carries `#[serde(default = "default_true")]`, a THIRD default mechanism
that is unconditional and therefore disagrees with the `Default` impl in
a non-CRDT build. Exercising it needs a self-describing format and this
crate's only serde dependency is postcard, which is not one. Adding
serde_json as a dev-dependency to test a divergence this lane did not
introduce is scope creep.
Also corrects a note that round 1 made stale: the ledger's "do not
subtract the two jobs' totals" figures (3,485 and 3,747) were measured
BEFORE round 1 added the protocol step, and round 2 adds two tests to
that crate. Expected totals are now 3,487 and 3,766. The root-package
census is untouched at 3,467 / 3,746 — the new tests live in a sibling
crate, which is precisely the region scripts/feature-census cannot see.
Verified: fmt, diff-check, clippy on pmacs-protocol in both feature
configurations, and workspace clippy --features crdt --keep-going.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Review finding (P2): docs/active-work.md and docs/agent-handoff.md both
still said "PR not yet open". This file's own rule is that an open PR
gets a lane recording its state — "When a PR is opened, give it a lane",
written after #171 drifted 153 commits while invisible here. Both now
carry PR #209, its six commits, and the first CI run.
That run is worth recording rather than merely citing, because it
discharges the one risk the framing could not close locally. ALL 14
CHECKS GREEN, including both new jobs (Test (crdt) 12m20s, M10 Perf
Gates (crdt) 5m40s) and the macOS/luajit leg that is the documented
flake surface. This was the first time in the project's history that
any of these tests executed in CI.
ACCEPTANCE 8 HOLDS AGAINST THE REAL RUN. Test (crdt) reported 3,717
passed / 0 failed / 30 ignored: the 3,746 all-targets census (with
basedpyright NOT skipped, as it is locally) plus one doc test, less the
30 ignored. The job demonstrably compiled and ran the crdt corpus rather
than reporting green over nothing — which was the whole point of writing
that criterion while the local sweep was already green.
A trap for the next reader is recorded with it: DO NOT SUBTRACT THE TWO
JOBS' TOTALS. Test (ubuntu/luajit) reports 3,485 and Test (crdt) 3,747,
a difference of 262 rather than 279, because the jobs run different
SETS — the non-crdt job adds pmacs-protocol's 17 tests. The dark count
is the all-targets comparison, 3,746 - 3,467. The wrong number looks
entirely plausible.
Chasing that discrepancy found a real gap, and one this lane's own tool
could never have surfaced: PMACS-PROTOCOL HAS ITS OWN `crdt` FEATURE.
It gates no tests, so a per-test census reports 17 either way and scores
the crate as unaffected — but it changes `cfg!(feature = "crdt")`
EXPRESSIONS inside InstanceCapabilities::default and
FrontendCapabilities::default, so those same 17 tests exercise different
runtime values under it. CI had only ever run the non-crdt ones. Closed
with an explicit `-p pmacs-protocol --all-targets --features crdt` step,
verified 17/17.
The blind spot is structural, not an omission, so it is documented at
the tool rather than fixed in it: scripts/feature-census censuses the
workspace DEFAULT MEMBER, because that is what a bare
`cargo test --all-targets` builds. Sibling crates are invisible to it no
matter what configs are passed. The durable lesson: A FEATURE CAN MATTER
TO A CRATE A PER-TEST CENSUS SCORES AS UNAFFECTED. Check siblings by
hand.
Verified: ci.yml parses at 10 jobs, script syntax clean, fmt,
diff-check, and the new protocol step green locally.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Framing revision 3, plus the ledger and handoff updates the lane owes.
docs/active-work.md's "NEEDS A LANE" block is replaced rather than
annotated: the lane now has a branch, a framing, an implementation and
verification, so the old text's premise ("no branch, no framing yet")
was the part that needed removing. Its stale figures go with it — the
273-dark reading at 74301d1 and the seven-item clippy list, both
superseded and both explicitly labelled do-not-quote in the new block.
The corrections this lane produced, all now recorded where the next
reader will hit them:
* m10_10_perf is a CI-DEFAULT REGRESSION TRIPWIRE, not a bench. Its
bounds are deliberately generous "to catch catastrophic regressions,
not to verify a tight perf claim", so #[ignore]ing it to give it a
perf job would have reduced coverage inside a coverage lane. The
framing had this backwards through revision 1 and says so.
* gpu-render runs `cargo test -p pmacs-gpu` — a DIFFERENT PACKAGE from
the root-package GPU suites. The long-recorded fix-shape of "move
the GPU-requiring crdt suites onto gpu-render, it already has
lavapipe" does not work as written.
* PMACS_REQUIRE_GPU is not uniform: absent from
gpu_invocation_acceptance and gpu_initial_target_acceptance
entirely, so it cannot serve as blanket proof the GPU suites ran.
* The dark-test classification found THREE dispositions, not two:
benches awaiting a job, deliberately-manual operator tests, and
known-defect markers. Collapsing the second into the first gives a
CI job to tests whose #[ignore] reason says not to.
* §1.1's own target-column claim was wrong, and scripts/feature-census
caught it. Eleven targets run with zero tests under CI's flags;
eight of those gain tests under crdt and three are helper binaries
with no tests in either. The framing had merged two true statements.
Acceptance 9 is revised rather than quietly met at a lower bar. The
planned deliberately-broken-test bite is replaced by the --covers
coverage assertion plus the CI count reconciliation, and the doc states
what that trades: stronger on the claim specific to this lane (the old
job STRUCTURALLY cannot see these tests), and no longer proving that a
failing crdt test turns the job red — which is generic cargo and Actions
behavior, not anything this lane changes.
The handoff gains a census hazard beside the existing sweep note,
because every trap in it was hit while writing the script and one of
them survived two framing revisions: libtest prints `name: test` with no
space before the colon, a zero-test target prints only its Running line,
and both configurations need an --ignored pass or pre-existing ignores
get attributed to the feature.
The ledger also records what is NOT established, which is the lane's
whole remaining risk: the sweep is green SERIALIZED ON A DEVELOPER
MACHINE, and the failures this lane expects are hosted-runner timing and
concurrency. That green removes the "tests are wrong" explanation and
leaves the expected one untested. It must not be quoted as evidence the
CI leg will be green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Nine PRs landed since the handoff's anchor (#199-#207) and it named
only four of them, so a fresh machine would not have learned that
ambient-root isolation exists, that the journey arc's 1b split
completed, or that the reap-ledger diagnostic landed. The ledger's
canonical base and recovery floor were five merges stale, and three
lanes described merged work as in flight.
Taken now because ZERO PRs are open. The ledger's own rule is never to
open a standalone refresh PR — because with several PRs open a lane
written on `main` re-conflicts at every merge — and this is the one
window where that cost is nil.
The handoff gains §1a, "Outstanding work — the whole board", which is
the point of the pass rather than a by-product: every arc against §20's
priority order with its next step, every open lane, every deferred item
attributed to the framing that parked it, and the standing hazards
someone running gates on a new machine needs — the three known flakes
by name, the basedpyright skip, the crdt sweep's build prerequisite,
and why a green a37 means nothing alone.
Two arcs completed, so per rule 4 their lanes are removed and their
facts are in the handoff: Journey Stage 1 and test ambient-root
isolation. Discovery and reap-ledger merged a stage each, so their
lanes are rewritten to the remaining plan rather than deleted — the
discovery lane now enumerates Stage 2 in dependency order and carries
the two Stage-1 facts a Stage-2 author would otherwise rediscover.
Base and floor advance together to `cfc1710`, per the file's own rule
that a floor accepting an older commit than the declared base passes on
a tree the document does not describe.
The recovery path was EXERCISED rather than asserted: from an empty
directory, clone, alias, fetch, floor check, and a lane worktree all
ran clean. The two-argument `git worktree add` still fails for a
remote-only branch, which is why every lane spells out the `-b` form.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
§7 said the classification comes first and alone, "its answer belongs in
review before any mechanical edit rides on it." The classification came
back at 342 sites across 66 of 97 files, and the whole-corpus migration
rode this PR anyway. That was a decision, not an oversight, and revision
5 records it as one so a later reader does not have to reconstruct it
from the diff.
The reasoning, in short: splitting would either leave 65 suites still
writing the developer's real data root while the seam sat unused, or ship
acceptance 12's ratchet with a ~65-file allowlist — and a ratchet
exempting most of the corpus records rather than ratchets. §7's ORDERING
is honoured (the census is the first commit); its implied SCOPING is not.
Revision 5 also records what review round 1 established about the shape
acceptance 12 needs: "a narrow, named allowlist" is not sufficient by
itself, because narrowness constrains which files are exempt and says
nothing about how far each exemption stretches. Exemptions carry counts.
`docs/active-work.md` picks up the same two facts and the PR number.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Per §25 the audited claim this stage falsifies is updated on the
landing PR. §5's scorecard row and ground truth both said the
registration metadata was best-in-class with almost no way for a user
to reach it; eleven `help.*` commands now reach it.
The row names what is still missing rather than implying the concern is
closed: packages and workers have no discovery surface, `Command` still
has no title/category/aliases/flags, M-x rows are still bare name
strings, the predicate is still never evaluated, settings value
provenance is still absent, and there is still no help prefix key. The
original audit grade is kept inline for reference.
`docs/keybindings.md` gains the family table and records that the
commands are reachable by name and bound to nothing — the help-prefix
decision belongs to a later stage, for the reason #205 recorded.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
`docs/active-work.md`: the lane moves from FRAMING OPEN to
IMPLEMENTATION OPEN, with the implementation branch and worktree and a
recovery command that names them. The framing-only worktree is spent —
its doc is on `main` (#201).
`docs/agent-handoff.md` §3: a local full-suite run needs all FIVE
storage variables controlled, not four. `PMACS_STATE_HOME` outranks
`XDG_STATE_HOME`, so naming only the XDG four leaves a
higher-precedence state override live; and a run isolating only
`XDG_CONFIG_HOME` stops the `init.lua` reads while still writing through
the real data root — every local gate run in this repo before today had
that hole. `HOME` is deliberately excluded: it is the fallback the XDG
roots already cover once set, and it separately drives `~`-expansion,
which `find_file_acceptance` pins on purpose.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Correct the M-x prompt census: six of the eleven canonical commands
need a second prompt, including describe-command. Make the apropos
substring negative discriminate against fuzzy matching with a concrete
non-contiguous fixture and a no-substring precondition. Update the help
index mutation to the twelfth canonical command, and carry all three
corrections into the active-work ledger.
No review findings at 1cc9d96; these are the two product choices the
framing deliberately left open.
Q#D2 resolves to `help.*` canonical with two forwarders. The family is
eleven commands under one prefix, so typing `help` at M-x surfaces all
of it — which is the discoverability win this arc exists for.
`editor.describe-command` and `editor.describe-setting` stay registered
as forwarders, so nothing in muscle memory or in
`docs/keybindings.md` breaks. Two forwarders are duplication of exactly
the kind §5 complains about; they are accepted as the bounded price of
not breaking documented names, and they carry a deprecation path. What
is not accepted is the split family revision 3 shipped.
Q#D3 resolves to substring. `fuzzy_score` is subsequence-based and
descriptions are long sentences, so a short query's letters almost
always appear in order — fuzzy would match nearly every command and
destroy the precision that makes apropos worth having. Acceptance 4 now
pins the decision rather than the intent: a subsequence that is not a
substring must find nothing.
Counts and pins follow the decision: the family is eleven throughout,
the `_show_help` counting stub expects eleven (the two renamed commands
are in it precisely because they were the pre-existing direct callers),
and the preservation pin now drives the forwarders through the real M-x
path — dropping them after the rename is the failure a user with muscle
memory would hit first.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two factual corrections, both accepted and both verified in the code.
The custom completion source does not control display order. Revision 3
justified sorting the pool by claiming `Custom` candidates appear in
return order; `recompute_candidates` hands the pool straight to
`filter_and_sort`, which ranks by fuzzy score descending and breaks
ties lexically, so the source's order never reaches the user.
The sort is kept, for a reason that is actually true: `filter_and_sort`
applies `.take(CANDIDATE_LIMIT)` to the FILTERED iterator before
sorting, so when more settings match than the limit, pool order decides
which survive truncation. Registration order would make that vary with
an unrelated config edit; sorting makes it reproducible.
Read-only would not mitigate the foreign-`*help*` collision either.
Revision 3 implied it would. A buffer the user created and named
`*help*` carries no intercept of ours, so an intercept on the buffers
we create protects nothing — the renderer still matches on the name and
clears theirs. The missing guarantee is ownership identity: a private
table of buffers this module created, so found-by-name is not adoption.
`listview` carries it as `panels` and dired as its handle table; this
mechanism carries neither. Naming the wrong missing guarantee would
send a later fix at the wrong layer, which is why the correction is
worth its own paragraph rather than a word swap.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two blocking, two major. All four accepted.
The ledger lane still said revision 1 and still carried the two claims
revision 2 refuted. The cause is worth recording: revision 2's ledger
edit was an assert-then-write block whose later assertion failed, so
nothing before it was written either — while the commit message
reported the whole change as done. This is the second time in this
project that shape has silently dropped edits. The lane is rewritten
from scratch and the result verified by re-reading the file rather than
inferred from an exit code.
`names_from` does not exist. Revision 2's completion source called a
helper nobody has written, over `pmacs.config.list()`'s descriptor
tables where `CompletionSource::Custom` consumes a sequence of strings.
Opening the prompt would have raised on an undefined global. The mapper
is now specified, and sorted — `Custom` presents candidates in the
order returned, and registration order is neither stable nor useful.
`*help*` has no read-only intercept. Revision 2 claimed one while
`show_help_text` writes with plain delete/insert, and #205 had already
recorded that this mechanism has not adopted the generated-buffer write
invariant. §3.4 now names the policies that really are shared —
reuse-by-name, wholesale replacement, the `q` binding, and the
foreign-buffer hazard — and notes that the last is precisely what a
read-only intercept would have mitigated and does not.
The naming was underspecified. With no `help.describe-command` in the
table, calling the existing `editor.describe-*` commands
"aliases-by-retention" was wrong on both halves: nothing forwards to
them and there was nothing for them to alias. They are now explicit
exceptions, the resulting split surface is named as a wart, and Q#D2 is
sharpened to the two ways out — forward the two under `help.*`, or keep
the family `editor.*` throughout.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two blocking, two major. All four accepted and verified in the code
before the doc changed.
Completion does not close the free-text hole, and revision 1 said it
did. `resolve_accepted_value` returns the literal typed text whenever
no candidate is selected, so a non-matching typo still reaches
`on_accept` and the existing error path; separately, a fuzzy near-miss
can silently describe a DIFFERENT setting, which is a new failure mode
revision 1 did not name. Completion is reframed as assistance, the
acceptance pins both outcomes, and closed-set acceptance semantics are
named as Rust work rather than smuggled in as a side effect of adding
a source.
`invoke_interactive` is not the M-x path — the exact error #205
corrected one PR earlier. It rotates the interactive-command boundary
and calls the body; it opens no palette. The acceptance now states the
real path once and drives it: dispatch M-x, type the name, assert the
selected candidate BEFORE RET (accept does `session.take()`), accept,
and — for the five commands that take an argument — drive the second
prompt too. A pin that stops after the first RET has tested the
palette, not the command.
The `_show_help` seam is an output sink, not a migration seam.
`src/help.rs` has semantic renderers for command/key/buffer/mode/hook/
view and none for settings, lists or apropos, and the seam takes
already-flattened text, so a later migration still has to change each
command's subject-specific logic. The claim is narrowed to what is true
— one owner for Lua `*help*` writes — and paired with a per-subject
renderer function so the future Rust work is enumerated rather than
discovered.
Ground truth corrected: the missing-command list was eight and omitted
`list-settings` while §3.1 said nine; the site count said ten where
nine additions make eleven; `pmacs.keymap.lookup` does not return
`description` (it passes `cmd = None`); and the predicate sites cited
were `MenuItem` fields, not `Command.predicate`. The predicate
conclusion survives on the correct evidence — `src/help.rs:76` and one
assertion past `#[cfg(test)]`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
`COHERENCE.md` §20 Priority 4, which §5 grades "substrate without
surface — the sharpest instance of §1.1" and calls the best
payoff-per-effort in the document. Nine describe/list commands over
introspection that already exists, picking up the family root `M-x
help` that #205 landed and documented for exactly this.
The stage adds no Rust. `pmacs.describe.*`, `pmacs.keymap.list()`,
`pmacs.command.list()` and `pmacs.config.list()` already return
everything the commands render, and `parse_completion_source` accepts a
Lua function as a `CompletionSource::Custom` — so `describe-setting`'s
free-text prompt, which today turns a typo into a status-line error
while `describe-command` has had completion all along, closes with no
new Rust either.
The consequential decision is a single rendering seam. `src/help.rs`'s
cross-referenced renderer is orphaned and the reachable Lua
`show_help_text` renders less, so nine new commands calling it directly
would turn a two-site migration into a ten-site one. Everything routes
through `pmacs.editor._show_help`, and an acceptance pin replaces that
seam with a counting stub — funnelling asserted, not merely intended.
Records that `Command.predicate` is stored and exposed but evaluated
nowhere, and deliberately does not start evaluating it: that makes
commands stop being invocable, which needs its own decision about what
"unavailable" means at each call site. A preservation pin registers a
raising predicate and asserts the command still runs, so a later stage
has to change that pin knowingly.
Adds no keybindings at all — the help-prefix question is taken once,
for the whole family, by the stage that can weigh it against the
constraint #205 recorded.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Review round 2 on #205, one finding, accepted. #204 is this PR's base,
so three places still describing it as open were simply false.
- `COHERENCE.md` §2's step-6 row: "(PR open) ends the silence" ->
"(#204) ended the silence", and the "flips only on merge" clause is
replaced by the reason the row is still Partial at all — a server
that starts and then crashes is unsurfaced, which that landing did
not touch.
- `docs/agent-handoff.md`: the 1b-2 bullet says LANDED (#204), with the
same substituted reason.
- `docs/active-work.md`: 1b-2's per-stage block is removed rather than
relabelled, per rule 4 — it has merged and its durable facts are in
the handoff, which is the precondition for removal.
That last one exposed a structural problem the merge had created: 1b-2's
old lane body had come in *underneath* the unified journey header, so
the file carried two journey sections and the first one's text
described the second's predecessor. There is now one arc lane with
1b-3 nested under it as the only open stage.
Also corrects the reap-ledger lane header, which still read
"IMPLEMENTED, PR OPEN" after #202 merged. Same class of staleness,
noticed while editing the same file.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Review round 1 on #205, two findings, both accepted.
The greeting was written straight into the registry without calling
`notify_buffer_edit`. The window's `TextView` had been indexed while
`*scratch*` was empty, and newlines are zero-width to a painter working
from a stale line index — so the first TUI frame collapsed the whole
three-line greeting onto row 0. Every buffer-text assertion passed
because the buffer content was correct; only the rendering was wrong.
The edit is now captured, the registry borrow released, and the core
notified.
The pin that would have caught it paints a real frame and asserts the
second line occupies its own row AND that row 0 does not contain it —
both directions, because a one-direction check passes when everything
collapses upward. Bitten by dropping the notify call: row 1 comes back
empty with row 0 holding the lot, and it is the only pin that fails.
Second: the project docs still described the arc as it was two PRs ago.
`COHERENCE.md` §20 called 1b-2 in flight and the welcome buffer
unstarted; its arc list said 1b-3 remained; and the ledger's journey
lane header still read "1b-2 PR OPEN" while the 1b-3 block carried a
mangled "Framing only; no code" line left by an earlier edit. All now
describe the PR-head state per §25.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
The journey suite conflicted additively — step 4 from this lane, step 6
from #204 — and both are kept: 44 pins now cover steps 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
and 9.
Per §25 the audited claims this stage falsifies are updated on the
landing PR rather than deferred: the scorecard's row 18 and §18's
ground truth both read "Missing" / "missing entirely", and a welcome
buffer plus a reachable cheat sheet makes both false. They move to
Partial. §2's step-4 row stays Partial, because `C-h` still deletes a
word and there is no tutorial.
§18's ground truth now records WHY `C-h` stays as it is, so the
help-prefix question reaches the discovery arc as a stated trade rather
than an oversight: non-kitty terminals cannot disambiguate
Ctrl+Backspace from Ctrl+H, so rebinding it would break Ctrl+Backspace
on every legacy terminal.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two findings, both accepted.
The pinned API was crate-private while the pin was external.
`tests/journey_acceptance.rs` is a separate integration crate and
cannot call a `pub(crate)` function or match a `pub(crate)` enum, so
revision 3's acceptance 1 could not have compiled. `prepare_startup`
and `Startup` are now `pub`, which is consistent rather than expedient:
`run`, `EditorState::new`, `EditorState::open`, `install_state_dirs`
and `restore_desktop_if_armed` are already public, so the startup
sequence is public surface and this was the piece missing from it. The
alternative — keep it private and move the pin into `src/editor.rs`'s
unit tests — was rejected because §19 wants the journey row in the
journey suite.
The isolation that pin needs is now stated rather than left implicit.
`prepare_startup` deliberately calls `install_state_dirs`, which
resolves `PMACS_STATE_HOME` and XDG roots that tests cannot override
(`set_var` is unsafe and forbidden), so the pin inherits the standing
five-variable ambient-root requirement, asserts buffer content only,
and must assert that desktop restore was unarmed — a developer whose
real `init.lua` calls `desktop_mode(true)` would otherwise get a
restored scratch buffer and a silently different result.
The M-x acceptance still left its key assertion as an "or", and half of
it was impossible: `Minibuffer::accept` does `session.take()` and
resolves against the selected candidate, so after RET neither the
session nor the typed contents survive to be asserted. The framing now
specifies one observable, available before RET:
`pmacs.minibuffer.selected()` must equal exactly "help", then accept.
If the completion source selected something else the pin fails there,
naming what was actually selected, instead of passing on a help buffer
some other command produced.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two acceptance holes and one doc correction, all accepted.
The real startup wiring was still unpinned, and revision 2 knew it: it
named the gap and then accepted it as residual, which is worse than
missing it. Deleting the sole `run()` call to `finalize_local_launch`
would have left every proposed pin green while shipping no welcome —
pin 1 called the seam by hand and pin 10 only proved constructors were
blank. That is the shape of a guard with no production caller passing
every direct-call test.
The fix is extraction, not disclaimer. Everything in `run()` from
`install_panic_hook` through the end of the attach-dispatch match is
terminal-free; `Frontend::new()` is where takeover begins. That prefix
becomes `prepare_startup`, which `run()` delegates to and which the
welcome pin now drives. Deleting the finalize call inside it turns the
pin red. What stays outside a test is `Frontend::new()` and the event
loop, which is where terminal takeover genuinely lives.
Acceptance 4 was not the M-x path. `pmacs.command.invoke` is the
programmatic API; M-x is `editor.execute-command`, which opens a
minibuffer with the `commands` completion source and calls
`invoke_interactive` only on accept. The pin now dispatches the chord,
enters the name, and accepts — and names the hazard that makes that
non-trivial: a selected candidate shadows typed text, so the pin has to
assert which command ran rather than trusting that some help buffer
appeared. dired refused a completion source on its own prompt for
exactly this reason.
Also corrects the #204 references: revision 2's history said it had
landed while the framing footer and ledger still called it open.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Four findings, all accepted and verified in the tree first. The three
open questions are answered and folded into the design: three lines,
name `C-c c` and `C-c t` verified from structured entries, and the
command is `help`.
The startup seam was wrong, and every acceptance criterion rested on
it. `EditorState::new()` is not the no-argument entry point:
`EditorState::open` calls it before resolving the target, the daemon
constructs one too, user config runs inside it, and desktop restore
happens much later inside `run()`'s `RunLocal` arm. Greeting from
`new()` would greet a daemon, greet before a file argument replaced the
buffer, and precede anything config or a restored session put in
`*scratch*`. The stage now adds a launch-finalization seam called right
after `restore_desktop_if_armed`, using the `had_file` signal already
threaded to that point. Its untestable part — that `run()` calls it —
is stated rather than papered over, and bracketed by pins proving the
seam works and that no constructor greets on its own.
The step-2 pin amendment is withdrawn. Revision 1 analysed a
status-line welcome and then chose `*scratch*` but kept the amendment,
which was an internal contradiction. The status stays empty so the pin
stays true, and "no error text" has no defined predicate over an
unstructured status string — replacing an exact check with a fuzzy one
would weaken the ratchet to buy nothing.
The claim that this stage carried no §25 obligation was false. The
scorecard's row 18 and §18's ground truth both read Missing, and a
landed welcome plus reachable cheat sheet falsifies both: they move to
Partial on merge while §2's step-4 row stays Partial. A stage can be
too small to flip its journey step and still falsify a "missing
entirely" grade.
Acceptance 2 could not have been implemented as written. Scraping key
sequences out of prose is ambiguous — `M-x help` mixes a chord with a
command name, and `C-c c` is two chords whose boundary the text does
not mark. One structured entry list now both renders the text and
drives the `pmacs.keymap.lookup` checks, and `M-x help` is exercised
through the real palette path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
The last of the 1b split. Journey step 4 and `COHERENCE.md` §18: a
fresh `pmacs` greets the user with an empty buffer, an empty status
line, and no indication that `M-x` exists — the sole discovery
affordance in the product is knowing to press it.
Three findings shape the design:
- The existing step-2 ratchet pin collides with any welcome. It asserts
`status.is_empty()` while its own message says "reports no error" —
the same predicate only while nothing writes a non-error status at
startup. The framing corrects the assertion to its message's claim
and names that as the one existing assertion the stage changes,
rather than burying it in a diff.
- `C-h` is not free. It is bound to word-delete because non-kitty
terminals cannot disambiguate Ctrl+Backspace from Ctrl+H — both
produce byte 0x08 — so rebinding it to a help prefix would break
Ctrl+Backspace on every legacy terminal. §2's step-4 row calls it an
oversight; it is a deliberate trade with a stated rationale. The
help-prefix decision is deferred to the discovery arc with the
constraint recorded so it is inherited rather than rediscovered.
- A `*help*` buffer mechanism already exists over `src/help.rs`, so the
welcome can point at something real. Its two gaps are recorded rather
than inherited silently: it writes with delete/insert instead of
`set_generated_contents`, and it is found by name.
The welcome deliberately does NOT use `set_generated_contents`: that
lifts read-only, discards history and marks the buffer generated, all
wrong for the buffer step 5 requires the user to type into immediately.
Step 4 stays Partial — the row names a welcome, a cheat sheet and
`C-h`, and this closes the first plus a minimal second — so this is the
first 1b stage with no landed-evidence obligation on merge.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Stage 1b-1 landed as #203, so the four places it deliberately left
saying "in flight" are flipped here rather than in a standalone docs
PR: this branch already touches all three files, and a separate PR
would re-conflict on every merge.
- `COHERENCE.md` §2's step-9 row: Partial -> **Works**.
- §2's keybinding-inversion paragraph: all three examples answered. The
quote itself is deliberately unchanged — it names a bias, and three
fixes do not retire a bias.
- §20 Priority 1 and the arc list: 1b-1 landed, 1b-2 in flight, 1b-3
remaining.
- `docs/agent-handoff.md` §1: IMPLEMENTED -> LANDED.
Conflicts were additive on both sides and are resolved keeping both:
the journey suite carries step 9 and step 6 (34 pins), and §24 keeps
both drift entries — the `ProjectKind::Cargo` naming error and §1.2's
wrong frequency note.
The two journey lanes are unified into one arc lane rather than one
being deleted. Rule 4 removes a lane when its ARC is done, and the
journey arc is not: 1b-2 is in flight and 1b-3 is unframed. Stage 1a
and 1b-1 are summarized there with their facts in the handoff, which is
rule 4's precondition satisfied rather than deferred.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Implements `docs/journey-stage1b2-lsp-guidance-framing.md` (approved at
revision 4, after three review rounds). Lua, tests and docs; no Rust
change and no protocol change.
`COHERENCE.md` §1.2's canonical silence: a preconfigured server that is
not installed failed with no status message, no record and no modeline
marker, while tree-sitter highlighting kept working and masked it. Now
the status line names the command, the language and the errno; the
modeline reads `LSP:!` instead of nothing; and `M-x lsp.status` renders
a durable `*lsp*` panel.
Half of this was already built. `status_buffer_text()` and
`last_error()` have existed since M4.8, exposed to Lua and tested, with
no production caller and no buffer to render into — several doc
comments already referred to "the `*lsp*` buffer" as though it existed.
The reporting shape was likewise already adopted twice inside
`lsp.lua`; the canonical case was silent because nobody had converted
it.
Three tables with three lifetimes, because one cannot do the job:
`reported` is never cleared and includes the command, so repointing at
another missing executable reports again; `failures` is cleared by a
successful spawn so the panel goes quiet on recovery; and a
buffer-keyed projection feeds the modeline, because that provider runs
for every window on every paint and deriving an affinity key inside it
would invoke root resolvers during painting.
The memo is on the report, not the failure: the spawn is still
attempted on every file open, so installing the binary mid-session
recovers with nothing to invalidate.
Adds `tests/lsp_spawn_guidance_acceptance.rs` (16 pins) and a step-6
row to the journey ratchet.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
One blocking lifecycle gap, accepted. The registry's dispatch order was
read before specifying the fix rather than assumed.
`failed_attachments` is keyed by `tostring(buf)` and revision 3 never
said who deletes an entry, so killing a failed buffer leaked its
projection for the session — and that also made revision 3's sweep
bound ("at most the number of open buffers") false, since the table
could exceed the number of buffers that exist.
Nothing existing would have cleaned it incidentally. The LSP resource
reconciliation finds its work through `attachments_under`, which
iterates `attachments`, and a failed buffer has no attachment by
construction — that is the whole reason the projection exists. The gap
needed its own registration.
Revision 4 specifies:
- `pmacs.buffer.on_removed` registered once per projection, never per
failed attempt, since `attach_buffer` is reachable more than once for
the same buffer and per-attempt registration would stack callbacks —
the same unbounded-registrar shape with the leak moved rather than
fixed.
- The handle released on the success sweep, where the buffer is still
alive, but not from inside the removal callback: dispatch does
`callbacks.take(id)` and then iterates a local vector, so the entry is
already gone.
- Rename and delete CLEAR the projection rather than re-keying it.
The projection asserts "this buffer's server failed for affinity K",
and after a rename that is no longer known to hold — the new path may
be in a different project or none. Re-keying would assert a failure at
a location where none was observed, which is the error shape this arc
has been correcting throughout.
- The sweep bound now follows from the cleanup instead of sitting beside
it as an independent claim.
Adds acceptance 14-16 for kill, rename and delete, each asserting the
chosen behaviour rather than merely the absence of the forbidden one.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two blocking, two cleanups. All four accepted, and both blockers
verified by running Lua rather than by reading it.
Recovery was inconsistent across buffers sharing an affinity. Revision
2 cleared `failures[K]` on a successful spawn but cleared only the
succeeding buffer's projection, so: buffer A fails, buffer B succeeds
for the same key, `M-x lsp.status` reports nothing wrong, and A's
modeline still reads `LSP:!`. Revision 2's claim that the two tables
are "written and cleared at the same moment" was false for exactly the
cross-buffer case, which is the normal case for a project with more
than one file. Each projection now carries its affinity key and a
success sweeps every projection holding it. The new pin asserts on A,
not B — a version checking B passes on the broken implementation.
The markerless key had no Lua representation. `key_uri` is deliberately
nil and `t[nil] = v` raises "table index is nil" — confirmed under both
LuaJIT and Lua 5.4 — so the central markerless criterion was literally
unimplementable as written, and leaving it to implementation would have
produced two ad-hoc encodings for the two tables. The framing now
prescribes one key function used by both, with a `u`/`n` discriminator
that cannot collide with any URI and a NUL separator (Lua strings are
8-bit clean, checked).
Acceptance 10 could not have observed what it claimed: making the
command resolvable changes no state by itself, since `failures` is
cleared by a successful spawn. The pin now reattaches before pressing
`g`, and says why that step is load-bearing.
Also corrects the ledger heading, which still said revision 1.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Review round 1 on #203, two blocking findings, both accepted.
The compile-directory assertions used the suite's lexical `canon()`,
but `pmacs.project.detect` canonicalizes before walking
(`canonicalize_or_passthrough`, `src/project.rs:509-511`), so the
compile cwd is filesystem-canonical. On macOS `/var` is a symlink to
`/private/var` and the two spellings disagree — both macOS legs failed
while Ubuntu, where `/tmp` is not a symlink, stayed green.
Fixed with a `detected_root()` expectation, and pinned by a fixture
that launches through an explicit **symlink** so lexical and canonical
paths disagree on every platform. That matters more than the fix: the
original bite ran only on Linux, where nothing could make the two
differ, so no amount of local mutation testing would have caught this.
The new pin is the only one that goes red when the lexical expectation
is restored.
Second: `COHERENCE.md` §2's step-9 row was flipped to **Works** and the
handoff said Stage 1b-1 was **LANDED**, while this PR is open. §25 is
explicit that grades change only with landed evidence, never
aspirationally. Both now describe the real state — the row stays
Partial and names #203 as the open PR that closes it, §20 and the arc
list say "in flight", and the handoff says IMPLEMENTED with the PR
number.
The flip is not dropped, it is owned: the active-work lane records the
four places to change on merge, because an unowned doc flip is exactly
how this ledger's drift starts.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two blocking, three major, one minor. All six accepted and verified in
the code before the doc changed.
The affinity key was misstated. `ensure_server` sets `key_uri` only
when the root came from config or a marker walk, so a markerless file
keys on nil and loose files across unrelated directories deliberately
share one server per language. Revision 1's "(root, language)" would
have split what the runtime shares and re-reported one failure once per
directory. The memo now uses the real key and the stage changes no
reuse behaviour.
Dedupe and current-failure state were conflated into one record, and
revision 1 said nothing about recovery. One record cannot do both jobs:
keep it and `*lsp*` shows a failure the user has already fixed; clear
it and the message returns on the next file open. They are now two
records with different lifetimes, the reported identity includes the
command so repointing config at a different missing executable reports
again, and recovery is pinned in both surfaces.
The modeline provider is a pure per-buffer projection by design — it
runs for every window on every paint. Revision 1's "read the failure
table" would have made it derive an affinity key, invoking user root
resolvers and project detection inside painting. The failure is now
projected per buffer at attach time and the segment stays one map
lookup, with a preservation pin that counts resolver invocations.
"Adopt listview's idiom" is replaced by requiring `pmacs.listview.open`
and naming what it guarantees, including `on_refresh` — without which
`listview.refresh` early-returns and `g` is a bound key that silently
does nothing.
The acceptance had no journey ratchet row despite the stage making step
6 real; `tests/journey_acceptance.rs` states that steps 6-12 join as
later stages make them real, and 1b-1 added step 9 the same way. The
end-to-end row is now acceptance 1 and the M4 pins stay beneath it.
Also refreshes the ledger's canonical-base anchor and recovery floor
from `7586905` to `fbcf235`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
`COHERENCE.md` §1.2's canonical silence, and journey step 6: a
preconfigured-but-missing language server fails with no status message,
no record, and no modeline marker, while tree-sitter highlighting keeps
working and masks it.
Three findings shape the design, all verified in the tree:
- The reporting pattern is already adopted twice inside `lsp.lua`
itself — root-resolver failures and subscriber failures both report
through `pmacs.editor.set_status` with the `pmacs.error` arm riding
along. The canonical spawn failure at `:658-674` was simply never
converted, so this stage finishes an adoption rather than starting
one.
- Half the stage is already built and unwired.
`LspManager::status_buffer_text()` renders "the `*lsp*` status
buffer", `last_error(sid)` exists, and both are exposed to Lua and
tested — with no production caller, no `*lsp*` buffer and no command.
Several doc comments already refer to that buffer as though it
exists.
- COHERENCE's frequency note is wrong, and the correction decides the
hardest question. It records the failure as firing once per project
root; `LspManager::spawn` returns early *before* both
`status_tracker.ensure` and `clients.insert`, so a failed spawn
leaves no record, the affinity loop cannot see it, and the real rate
is once per file open. Hence the rule the stage adopts: memoize the
report, not the failure — the spawn is still retried, so installing
the binary mid-session recovers with nothing to invalidate.
Records one limitation rather than hiding it: `status_buffer_text`
renders from `self.clients`, which a failed spawn never enters, so the
durable surface cannot yet show the failure natively. The record stays
in Lua for this stage.
Also logs four stale `COHERENCE.md` §1.2 citations for correction when
the stage lands.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Implements `docs/journey-stage1b1-compile-defaults-framing.md`
(approved at revision 2). Lua, tests and docs; no Rust change and no
protocol change.
`C-c c` now runs `compile.run`, and the first prompt is prefilled from
the detected project kind through `pmacs.compile.defaults` — seeded
`rust = "cargo build"` and extensible from `init.lua`. `_last` still
wins, so a session that has compiled keeps its own command.
The prompt CAPTURES its directory rather than re-resolving it. Sharing
one resolver between the prompt and the run is necessary and not
sufficient: `pmacs.minibuffer.read` is asynchronous and nothing freezes
the active window while a prompt is open, so two calls to the same
resolver at two different moments are still two different answers — the
user could be offered `cargo build` for A and handed a run in B by
clicking away mid-prompt. This is Journey Stage 1a's `commit_to`
discipline on a smaller seam.
`pmacs.compile.defaults` is public and assignable, so the lookup is
guarded: a throwing `__index`, a non-string entry and a non-table
replacement all degrade to the pre-stage empty prompt and never
prevent compiling.
Only `rust` ships seeded. Rust has one answer; npm/yarn/pnpm,
make/cmake, and `go build` versus `go test` do not, and a wrong prefill
costs more than an empty one.
Adds eight step-9 rows to the journey ratchet and five module pins to
the compile suite. Corrects `COHERENCE.md`, which named a
`ProjectKind::Cargo` that does not exist — the variant is `Rust`, line
77 is its doc comment, and Lua only ever sees the tag string "rust".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Review round 1, one finding, accepted.
"A failed escalation is never retried by anything" was false.
`shutdown()`'s force-kill loop iterates the reap ledger with **no**
`!entry.killed` guard, so it does re-kill an entry the escalation arm
gave up on. The accurate claim is that no later *tick* retries it —
`tick_reap_ledger`'s escalation is guarded by `!entry.killed` and never
fires again for that group.
The overclaim collapsed two failure modes that this lane exists to keep
distinct: a failed escalation leaks the group until editor exit, where
one more attempt is made, while a failed `shutdown()` force-kill leaks
it past exit with nothing left to try. Narrowed in the framing, the
handoff, the active-work ledger and the test commentary.
The corrected claim was asserted in three documents and pinned by
nothing, so it gets a pin: a failed escalation marks the entry, the
survivor stays alive across ticks, and `shutdown()` — with no fault
planned, so its force-kill really lands — still reaps it. Bitten by
adding the missing `!entry.killed` guard to that loop: the new pin
fails and the other five stay green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Not a new design round. Every bet resolved, and one acceptance turned
out to be satisfiable vacuously.
Acceptance 2's in-drain clause said "the live descendant's named late
output absent" without saying how the descendant stays live. It does
not, by default: `poll_one` TERMs the whole group on leader exit. The
first fixture's marker was therefore absent on both paths, and the pin
would have stayed green with the collapse fixed.
Bets 1 and 2 hold — every site took a directed outcome without
restructuring, and every consequence is reachable, so the lane does not
shrink. Bet 3 resolves the shutdown coupling as real and measured. Bet
4 is falsified exactly as its own clause anticipated: `ProcessEvent` is
keyed by `ProcessId` while the ledger is keyed by pgid and is
deliberately independent of managed records, every production consumer
polls per known id, and `take_all_events` has no production consumer at
all. Q#RL3 is answered accordingly and reporting is parked as its own
lane.
Also records the four sites and the two reusable lessons in
`docs/agent-handoff.md` — that a seam for a background loop has to be
directed, and that an absence assertion is only as good as its
fixture's ability to produce the thing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Two blocking, two major. All four accepted and verified in the code
before the doc changed.
Sharing one cwd resolver between the prompt and the run does not
prevent drift. `pmacs.minibuffer.read` is asynchronous, nothing freezes
the active window while a prompt is open, and `run` re-resolved at
accept time — so the prompt could offer `cargo build` for A and execute
in B. Two calls to the same resolver at two different moments are still
two different answers. The interactive command now captures
`context()` and passes its `cwd` through to `run`. This is Journey
Stage 1a's `commit_to` discipline on a smaller seam: capture at request
time, never re-derive from whatever is ambient when the async work
lands.
No pin crossed the accept boundary. N1-N5 compared values the prompt
and the resolver had already agreed on, so a wrong directory inside
`on_accept` — exactly the defect above — passed every one of them. Two
pins now accept: N3 switches windows between prompt and RET and reads
the directory back two ways, and N4 accepts `cargo build` unedited in a
real Cargo fixture and asserts a clean exit.
N3's old falsifier was not discriminating: `project_root_of_active()`
already returns the innermost root, so re-detecting from it yields the
same kind and the pin would have stayed green. The mixed-fixture pin is
now N5 with a falsifier it actually catches, and says what it does not.
And §6.1 contradicted §3.1 — a Cargo workspace subdirectory holds no
`Cargo.toml` and correctly receives `cargo build`. The predicate is a
detected project, not a file in that one directory.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
`COHERENCE.md` §20 Priority 1 names Journey Stage 1b as the golden
journey's remainder and it had no branch, no framing, and no lane —
the only §20 priority with nothing in flight. This frames the first
third of it: journey step 9, build or test the project.
Scope is a global `C-c c` for `compile.run` plus a first prompt
prefilled from the detected project kind instead of empty. Lua, tests
and docs; no Rust change, no protocol change. LSP spawn guidance and
the welcome buffer are separate stages (§7).
Three ground-truth findings the framing rests on:
- `ProjectKind::Cargo` does not exist. COHERENCE names it twice; the
variant is `ProjectKind::Rust` and line 77 is its doc comment. Lua
matches the tag string `pmacs.project.detect` already returns, so
the stage needs no new Rust primitive.
- The compile cwd is resolved inside `run`, after the prompt closes,
so a suggestion built in the command's `fn` would obey a different
rule than the run. The stage extracts one resolution and has both
consume it.
- The last-resort cwd is `std::env::current_dir()` at call time, which
in tests is the pmacs repo root — itself a Cargo project. Negative
pins are built so that fallback is never reached.
Records one limitation rather than fixing it: after `pmacs <dir>` the
active buffer is dired's and pathless, so the cwd falls through to the
process cwd. That needs COHERENCE §8's execution-location model, not a
reach into dired's private handle table.
Adds the journey lane to the active-work ledger.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Refine the framing's in-drain test seam: a one-shot probe error cannot
survive the 50 ms quiescence interval, so the test-only override lasts
for one drain context and remains per-supervisor. Name the in-drain
SIGKILL as a non-observable local fact rather than adding an untestable
seam, and synchronize the revision-three ledger record.
The revision-2 commit shipped the framing alone. Its ledger edit was
generated by a script that aborted on a line-wrap mismatch before
writing, so `b881bd4` left the lane entry describing revision 1 — three
silent failures instead of four, no in-drain twin, no site-directed
seam, and the withdrawn "Bet 1 ships alone" staging.
Synchronized now: four sites including `final_drain_runtime` and its
distinct reader-cancellation consequence; journey step 9 rather than 8;
the `any_running()` precondition on the shutdown coupling; and the
first PR scoped as seam plus tests.
The failure mode is worth naming, because a partial write is exactly the
shape that leaves a document confidently wrong: the commit succeeded and
reported one file changed, which is easy to read as success when two
were intended.
Unparked from PR #200's §5, which retired the premise justifying the
ledger's leniency and deliberately changed no disposition.
Scouting found three silent failures where #200 named two. A probe error
of any errno drops the entry and cancels escalation; a failed escalating
SIGKILL is recorded as a success and never retried; and `shutdown()`
discards its own force-kill result identically — on the path written
specifically to stop a leak at editor exit.
Two facts shape the lane. `shutdown()`'s final loop terminates when the
ledger empties, which happens through the same silent drop, so the probe
error that hides a leak can also end the cleanup loop early — the probe
cannot be made strict in isolation. And all three paths are untestable
today: `tick_reap_ledger` and `shutdown()` call nix directly and consult
no injection seam, unlike `signal()`'s `forced_kill_errno`, so every one
of the five existing ledger tests exercises only the success path.
Diagnosis first; no disposition change is proposed. Stage A of the signal
lane had three tolerance rules rejected across three revisions, each for
concluding something about one entity from something about another, on
this same data structure.
The framing states plainly that none of the three has been observed:
#200 saw an explicit SIGTERM fail in `signal()`, not a ledger call.
Framing only. No code.
`docs/active-work.md` auto-merged without conflict — this branch's lane
entry sits above the folding lane, clear of the six blocks #199 removed.
Verified rather than assumed: all lane headers checked afterwards.
The merge surfaced a stale statement on `main`. The process-signal lane
still read "PR #200 open, four review rounds closed, held for review",
which stopped being true when #200 merged as `a2a92bb`. Its arc is
complete — Stage A #176 and Stage B #200 both landed, and the items its
§5 parked become their own lanes — so under the rule #199 established
(a lane retires when its ARC is done, not when a PR merges) it is
removed and recorded under "Closed since the last snapshot".
Doing that here rather than deferring it: this PR already edits the
file, and leaving a known-false statement on `main` to keep a PR
single-purpose is the wrong trade. The alternative was letting it stand
until the reap-ledger lane, which is scoped next and inherits from the
very §5 list being retired.
Review round 4: three blocking, one major. All accepted.
**`measured_group` was sampled after the failure.** It ran inside
`signal_failure_report`, after the `kill` and after `observe_leader`,
while the framing and the function's own doc both said before. A
concurrent group change would have made the diagnostic report
post-failure state as evidence about the attempted target. It is now
sampled in `signal` before the kill and passed into the report, so the
field describes the target that was attempted rather than the state the
failure left behind.
**The Linux corroboration did not exercise the production lookup.** Its
helper read `portable_pty::process_group_leader` — the accessor this
lane stopped using on the signal path — so `pty_foreground_group` could
have fallen back on every call with every test still green. Forcing it
to always fall back demonstrates the hole exactly: the corroboration
fails, and the injected pin PASSES, because the injected tests supply
the group themselves and structurally cannot detect a broken lookup.
The helper now calls the production lookup, and the corroboration forces
only the kill so the report is built from a real terminal read. The
residual limitation is recorded rather than left to the green: on macOS
`pty_foreground_group` has no end-to-end coverage, because the platform
cannot produce the precondition.
**The framing did not update its own acceptance contract.** Revision 5
recorded Bet 1's falsification in the revision history and in the bet,
and left the normative criterion demanding the real-shell rewrite — the
"implementation quietly diverges from the contract" shape this project
already recorded as a lesson on #191/#188. Acceptance 1 now describes
the injected pin, 1a adds the corroboration and its macOS limitation,
and 4 states the sampling order. The ledger is synchronized: revision 6,
four commits, 4,471 tests, bash armed on Linux only.
**`TargetSource`'s doc had the wrong classification.** Two of the four
variants target the leader pid, not one, and the pid-versus-group split
does not line up with PTY-versus-pipe — which is why the fallback needed
its own variant rather than reusing `LeaderPid`.
Gates: 11 gates, 4,471 tests, zero failures.
One blocking and two major findings, all accepted.
- The isolated gate still inherited `PMACS_STATE_HOME`, which wins over
`XDG_STATE_HOME` in `user_state_dir` (`src/state.rs:47-68`), so
controlling the four XDG storage variables did not isolate state on a
machine that exports it. The contract now names the exact five
variables rather than counting roots.
- Q#TI5 still called self-spawn the durable regression guard after
revision 3 had accepted that it proves behaviour, not continued
adoption. It now names both guards and their different jobs: self-spawn
is the behavioural proof, the checked source inventory is the adoption
proof.
- The active-work lane still said revision 2 and still prescribed an
isolated `XDG_CONFIG_HOME` alone; both are synchronized, and the stale
config-only gating note elsewhere in the ledger is corrected to say it
isolates the observed symptom rather than the gate.
Framing only. No code.
`docs/active-work.md`'s snapshot header was the only conflict; main's
absorption version supersedes this branch's. `docs/agent-handoff.md`
auto-merged, and both sides were verified present afterwards rather than
assumed: the absorption's `4cd4a7b` anchor and its new landed-lane
entries, and this branch's macOS occurrence with its run link.
This lane's ledger entry is updated from "revision 4 awaiting review" to
its actual state — implemented, gated, PR open — since the framing was
approved and both implementation commits have landed on the branch.
The full gate suite is re-run on the merged tree rather than inherited
from the pre-merge head. The absorption is docs-only, so a clean merge
is very likely correct — which is exactly when inheriting a green would
be most tempting and least justified.
Three blocking and two major findings, all accepted. Two were verified
by running the thing rather than reading it.
- **Journey isolation had no executable mechanism.** Cargo launches each
integration-test binary with the caller's environment, and a binary
cannot re-point its own roots before its tests run — the `set_var`
prohibition applies to itself. Revision 2's "isolated by its launched
environment" therefore assumed the external wrapper this lane exists
to delete. Now named and pinned: each journey test re-execs
`current_exe()` with `--exact`, a marker, and controlled roots; the
child runs the real body against the ambient `EditorState::open`, so
the production-entry-point ratchet is untouched while the roots are
contained. The same helper serves the hostile-environment check.
- **One self-spawning test is not a ratchet.** It proves the seam works
and cannot notice a raw `EditorState::new()` added to another binary
later. A checked source inventory, falsifiable by adding an ambient
constructor, is now acceptance 12.
- **The root list and the gates disagreed with the audit.** The scope is
now explicit — bootstrap STORAGE roots only (config, data, state,
cache). `HOME`'s non-storage semantics are excluded by decision, not
omission: `expand_tilde` resolves user-entered `~` and
`find_file_acceptance` pins it deliberately, so redirecting `HOME`
would retarget a user-facing feature. `XDG_RUNTIME_DIR` addresses
sockets, not stored data.
- **The gate instruction itself was insufficient**, and this is the
finding with immediate consequences: isolating only `XDG_CONFIG_HOME`
stops the reads and leaves the write path open. Every local gate run
in this repository today had that hole.
- **The count was one high and the ledger overstated it further.** 65
files call the constructor; 66 mention it. The 66th, `m5_6_acceptance`,
mentions it only to say it deliberately does not use it — making it
the third place in the suite documenting the `cfg(test)` gap. The
ledger's "all 96 test files load the real config" was false.
- **The recovery command did not work**, verified by running it:
`git worktree add <path> <remote-only-branch>` fails with `fatal:
invalid reference` after a bare fetch. Replaced with the explicit
tracking-branch form.
Framing only. No code.
Four blocking and two major findings, all accepted, all verified in the
code before acceptance. The lane's scope changes: it is about ambient
roots, not about init.lua.
- The read-only assumption was already false. `EditorState::new`
materializes bundled packages unconditionally and before config
loading, into `XDG_DATA_HOME` or `$HOME/.local/share`, and
`materialize_all` creates directories. Confirmed on the development
machine: `~/.local/share/pmacs/builtin-packages/` exists with v0.1.0
and v1.0.0. This upgrades the lane from "local gates lie" to "tests
write into real user data".
- The population count was wrong and its stated method did not match the
command that produced it: 18 from a grep for `Editor::new`, which does
not match the real constructor `EditorState::new`. 66 of 96 files
construct an editor directly.
- File-level classification cannot work: 5 files are both in-process and
spawned. Classification moves to construction sites.
- The seam must cover `EditorState::open`, which calls `Self::new()`
directly, while `journey_acceptance` requires that exact public entry
point to avoid a dead-production-path test. Resolved by isolating
journey through its launched environment rather than a different call.
- Isolated construction must still return `is_init_complete() == true`.
Config loading and `set_init_complete()` share one block, and
`m8_2_acceptance.rs:75` documents its dependence on integration-test
construction being init-complete — the `cfg(test)` gap is load-bearing
in that one respect.
- Revision 1 both proposed and parked a hostile-config CI leg. Resolved
in favour of a test-binary self-spawn, which travels with the test
rather than the workflow file, and which now also asserts the hostile
root is unmodified afterwards.
- The lane is recorded in `docs/active-work.md`, which revision 1 omitted
despite the volatile-work protocol requiring it.
Also documents six ambient roots where the shared daemon harness sets
two, and why setting HOME only isolates a root whose XDG variable is
unset — the harness's apparent adequacy is a property of one developer's
environment.
Framing only. No code.
Eight PRs merged on 2026-07-29/30 (#188, #190, #191, #194, #195, #196,
#197, #198) and `docs/active-work.md` had drifted to 1,854 lines, most of
it describing work already on `main`. Rule 4 permits removal once a
lane's facts reach `docs/agent-handoff.md`; this does both halves in one
commit so the precondition is satisfied rather than deferred.
Handoff §1: the head-of-`main` anchor moves from `6c9e765` to `4cd4a7b`
and its date from 2026-07-28 to 2026-07-30. New entries for the three
implementation PRs that had no record — #190's pre-filesystem delete
refusal, #191's Stage 1 adoption of the generated-buffer contract, and
#196's dired Stage 2a — plus #188 recorded as landed rather than
proposed.
Ledger: six merged lanes removed (781 lines). Two lanes are NOT removed
and are rewritten to their remaining plan instead, because their arcs are
unfinished: generated-buffer immutability (Stage 1 merged, Stage 2 not
started) and bottom-panel (Stage 2 complete, Stage 3 ahead). The
bottom-panel block said so in its own text — "this lane is not removed at
2B-3's merge" — so a removal keyed on "the PR merged" would have
discarded live planning. The header now states the rule as ARC-done
rather than PR-merged.
Two method notes are recorded in the ledger because they nearly cost
real work:
- A census by PR number is a proxy, not a measurement. Counting `#NNN`
in the handoff reported that five of these lanes had no record at all.
Counting by content found most already documented, with the real gap
being the implementation PRs while their framings were recorded. The
absorption written from the first count would have duplicated existing
entries.
- #194 and #195 keep their lessons in §3 and §5 rather than §1, which is
why a number search finds them once each. Sufficient under rule 3:
durable knowledge needs a home, not a required section.
Docs only. No code, no protocol change.
Integrate canonical main, restore PTY errno capture through the safe
filedescriptor duplication bridge, narrow the macOS occurrence to what
it actually measured, and make the job-control fixture foreground and
discriminating.
Record the portable framing lane and exact recovery commands in the
active-work ledger.
`docs/active-work.md` was the only conflicting file, in the same shape
as #191's: `main` inserted the generated-buffer Stage 1 lane immediately
above the bottom-panel header this branch had rewritten. The resolution
keeps both.
Each side's newer text wins where that side owns the fact: `main` carries
the corrected #188 status (MERGED/APPROVED, replacing "OPEN, PROPOSED —
do not implement"), and this branch carries the bottom-panel lane's 2B-3
state and the newer snapshot date, replacing main's "2B-2 MERGED; 2B-3 IS
NEXT" and its 2B-2 boundary paragraphs.
Verified: no conflict markers; every line absent from either parent is a
deliberate supersession by the other, enumerated and checked one by one
rather than counted; all three lane headers present exactly once.
`docs/active-work.md` was the only conflicting file. #196 added the dired
Stage 2a lane at the position this branch had used to relabel the #188
framing lane header; the resolution keeps both, changing neither side's
wording.
`src/editor_core.rs` auto-merged. Both lanes touch it, so a clean
textual merge is not evidence of a clean semantic one — the gate suite
is re-run in full on the merged tree rather than inherited from the
pre-merge head.
Resolution verified for line loss in both directions: the resolved file
differs from `main` only by this branch's own authored edits, and
differs from this branch only by additions taken from `main`.
Review round 2, three findings.
setsid is util-linux, not coreutils, and the standard `cargo test --lib`
gate must not hard-fail on a tool the README does not declare -- a
minimal or BusyBox container would fail without ever testing pmacs. The
hard assert becomes skip-unless-armed via PMACS_REQUIRE_SETSID, which is
the pattern the silent-skip lane already established, so the test cannot
quietly report `ok` having never run where the tool is guaranteed. CI
arms it on Linux; README declares it. Both arms verified against a PATH
with setsid genuinely removed: unarmed skips with its message, armed
FAILS with the diagnostic.
The durable causal account was wrong, and this corrects it in the
framing, the handoff and the ledger. basedpyright's console script runs
bundled node through `subprocess.run` and WAITS
(nodejs_wheel/executable.py:50, verified in the installed 1.39.6). It
does not exit at spawn. What orphans node is pmacs: `shutdown()` SIGTERMs
the recorded pid -- the Python wrapper -- which dies without forwarding
the signal, leaving node at PPid 1 holding the pipes. The refutation was
already in hand: the initialize handshake succeeds, which a wrapper that
exited at spawn could not have done, and the PPid 1 observation was taken
after shutdown had killed it.
The fix is unaffected -- the deadlock and its bite are unchanged -- but
the parked follow-up changes target: not "tolerate servers that
self-orphan" but "stop orphaning them", i.e. signal the process group
rather than a wrapper pid that swallows the signal. Framing section 5 P2
restated.
Also corrects a stale CI-ordering claim: the handoff said pyright must
stay unarmed until the timeout lane lands, but #195 is this PR's base and
gave every job a timeout-minutes. The one live reason is that CI does not
install basedpyright at all. The ci.yml comment asserting the job has no
timeout-minutes was stale for the same reason and is rewritten.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Integrated main (#195) first so the lane block is written on top of it
rather than conflicting with it — the one conflict this file always has,
paid at the merge that was happening anyway.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
The four findings were one shape — a failure that left state wrong and
told nobody — so the lane records them as one lesson rather than four
bugs: every one was a `pcall` or a discarded return value, and each
looked like defensive coding.
Also records the round-1 pin that passed with its own bug restored
(acceptance 53's attribution assertion was satisfied by the deleted
path's basename appearing elsewhere in the same message), the refreshed
gate numbers, and that `main` was re-measured after the round and had
not moved.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Lv428Fth9LRtffwJSsqH7T
Levi Neuwirth