The "cheap batch" subset that is genuine template-fill: these four
return the exact `Location | Location[] | LocationLink[] | null`
shape `textDocument/definition` already parses, so no new parsing —
only a kind discriminator so they don't collide on (server, uri).
- src/locations.rs: a (server, uri, kind)-keyed store whose value
type is the reused crate::definition::DefinitionResponse. The
proven definition store + Lua API are untouched.
- lsp.rs: ResponseRoute::Locations { uri, kind }; one absorb arm; a
DRY request_locations helper + request_references /
request_declaration / request_type_definition /
request_implementation. references sends
context.includeDeclaration. Supersede keys derive from each
kind's distinct method, so the four don't cancel each other.
- Lua: _request_*_raw bindings + install_locations exposing
pmacs.references / .declaration / .type_definition /
.implementation ({ locations, clear }, mirroring pmacs.definition,
reusing definition_response_to_lua). lsp.lua Handle wrappers + a
lsp.find-references command bound to M-? (modeline summary;
references-list buffer is future UX, like the hover panel).
- Tests: locations.rs unit tests (kind labels distinct; keys don't
collide); e2e driving all four through the async bridge and
asserting each routes to its own kind slot (fake returns distinct
lines 11/21/31/41).
Scoped: documentSymbol / workspaceSymbol / documentHighlight return
different shapes (new parsing) — a separate follow-up, not crammed
in here.
Gate: fmt clean; clippy --all-targets -D warnings clean; lib
1232/0; m4_acceptance 65/0; m9_1 18/0; m8_1/m8_9/m8_10 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two more real languages on the proven async + UTF-16 + config-pull
base. Pure pattern application of the #12 Python shape.
- pmacs.lsp.config.c / .cpp → clangd `--background-index`. One
binary serves both; separate entries only so the didOpen
languageId is accurate. No `settings`: clangd's project model is
compile_commands.json / compile_flags.txt, not
workspace/configuration (documented in-line).
- pmacs.lsp.config.go → gopls (no args = stdio). settings =
{ gopls = {} } so the #13 workspace/configuration pull is answered
"use defaults" (present, not null — gopls prefers that).
- pmacs.lsp.filetypes extended: c/h → c (.h defaults to C,
remappable); cpp cc cxx hpp hh hxx ipp inl cppm → cpp; go → go.
- Two PATH-gated acceptance tests via a shared DRY helper, mirroring
m4_5_basedpyright: reach Initialized + assert the negotiated
positionEncoding is one pmacs can encode. Skip cleanly when the
binary is absent.
clangd is on the dev PATH, so its test ran for real: the full stack
(async bridge + Option B UTF-16 + registry + filetypes) is validated
end-to-end against a real strict-default C/C++ server, closing the
"validate UTF-16 against a real strict server" gap from the Option B
evaluation. gopls test skips here; runs wherever gopls is installed.
Gate: fmt clean; clippy --all-targets -D warnings clean; lib
1230/0; m4_acceptance 64/0 (clangd ran live); m9_1 18/0;
m8_1/m8_9/m8_10 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
gopls / pyright / basedpyright / clangd issue server→client
`workspace/configuration` during startup and degrade (or fall back
to defaults) without a reply. pmacs advertised `configuration:false`,
so it never got the chance.
- Advertise `workspace.configuration: true`.
- New `settings` field on the spawn spec, threaded through
lua_to_lsp_spec → ensure_server (pmacs.lsp.config[lang].settings).
- handle_request intercepts `workspace/configuration` (mirrors the
publishDiagnostics interception in handle_notification): each
item's dotted `section` resolves against the server's settings via
resolve_config_section; one array element per item; unknown
sections answer `null` (the spec's "not configured" signal,
distinct from a configured null). All other server→client requests
still surface as a `Request` event for the consumer.
- The Python default now ships
`python.analysis.typeCheckingMode = "basic"` (+ basedpyright.*
alias), so the #12 basedpyright-noise concern is now actually
fixed rather than only documented; a project pyrightconfig.json /
[tool.pyright] still wins where present.
Scoped: `scopeUri` ignored (single-root; same settings regardless
of scope) until multi-root, a separate deferred item.
Tests: exhaustive resolve_config_section unit test (dotted paths,
configured-null vs unknown-null, whole-object for absent section);
new `wsconfig` fake mode pulls config at `initialized` and echoes
pmacs's answer back; end-to-end test asserts the configured section
round-trips.
Gate: fmt clean; clippy --all-targets -D warnings clean; lib
1230/0; m4_acceptance 62/0; m9_1 18/0; m8_1/m8_9/m8_10 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
First real language on the now-correct async + UTF-16 substrate.
- pmacs.lsp.config.python → `basedpyright-langserver --stdio`.
basedpyright (MIT fork of pyright) re-enables inlay hints /
semantic tokens in the OSS server that upstream pyright withholds
for Pylance — matches the deferred-feature roadmap. No init_options:
strictness is project config (pyrightconfig.json / [tool.pyright]);
pmacs does not yet advertise workspace/configuration, so an
editor-side typeCheckingMode would not be honoured regardless
(documented in-line, with the upstream-pyright one-field override).
- LSP language detection separated from tree-sitter. pmacs.parse's
extension registry is grammar-gated (rejects "python" — no bundled
grammar). New user-extensible pmacs.lsp.filetypes map (py/pyi →
python); active_buffer_language() tries grammar-backed parse first
(rust/.rs etc. unchanged) then falls back to the map, so a language
with a server but no grammar still auto-attaches.
- PATH-gated acceptance test mirroring m4_5_rust_analyzer_initializes;
unique assertion: a real basedpyright must negotiate a
positionEncoding pmacs can encode — validates Option B against a
real strict server, not just the fake. Skips when absent.
Gate: fmt clean; clippy --all-targets -D warnings clean; lib
1229/0; m4_acceptance 61/0; m9_1 18/0; m8_1/m8_9/m8_10 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replaces the editor-blocking `poll_until` tick-loop in the LSP UX
with the M9.1 external-settle pattern: each `textDocument/*` request
registers a pending entry via `AsyncRuntime::register_external` and
returns the job id; the JSON-RPC response (or a server-teardown /
cancel / timeout) settles it, resuming a `Handle:await()` coroutine.
No worker thread is occupied for the round-trip.
Hybrid result delivery (operator decision): the response is absorbed
into the typed stores *and* carried through the Handle. The
completion popup and diagnostics gutter keep reading the stores
untouched; request/response command code awaits the value directly.
Core (src/lsp.rs):
- `LspManager` gains `runtime: SharedAsyncRuntime` (threaded through
`make_lsp_manager` / editor.rs, mirroring `make_mcp_manager`) plus
a `(server, request_id)` -> PendingExternal awaiter table parallel
to `pending_routes`.
- `request_*` return the async `JobId` (`= u64`, signature
unchanged; no caller consumed the old JSON-RPC id).
- `handle_response` settles every non-cancelled awaiter ok/failed
alongside store absorption; null result still wakes await with nil.
- Awaiters drain-cancelled at all three `pending_routes` purge sites
(restart generation flip / terminal exit / forget) so a coroutine
cannot park on a server that went away.
- Per-tick sweep: per-awaiter cancellation (Handle:cancel() or
supersede via a stable `lsp:{method}:{sid}:{uri}` key), with
`$/cancelRequest` + `cancelled_rids` on abandonment to drop the
cancel/response race silently. Mirrors mcp.rs.
- Per-request timeout (default 10s, `pmacs.lsp.set_request_timeout_ms`):
an alive-but-silent server fails the await instead of hanging.
Lua surface:
- `_request_*_raw` job-id bindings (mirror `pmacs.mcp._send_request_raw`).
- builtin/runtime/lsp.lua: Handle wrappers + the four commands
rewritten to spawn `pmacs.async` coroutines that `:await()`;
`poll_until` removed. Server-gone / error surface as structured
await failures in the modeline.
Tests:
- pmacs_fake_lsp: `error` / `silent` modes for deterministic
failure-path coverage.
- 5 end-to-end await-path tests (success+store, server-error->failed,
server-stop->cancelled, timeout->failed, supersede->cancelled).
Gate: fmt clean; clippy --all-targets -D warnings clean; lib
1223/0; m4_acceptance 58/0; m9_1_acceptance 18/0 (MCP unaffected).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Pulls a set of planned V0.2 prerequisites forward to ship in v1.0,
plus the clean audit-review round over that work.
V0.2-prereq implementations (documented promotions, not M11
surprises; operator raised the v1.0 public-API ceiling to absorb
them — see V0.2-PREREQUISITES.md "v1.0 pull-forward"):
- CC-1: `bypass_intercept` opts on buffer insert/delete/replace —
skips the Lua intercept chain only; preserves the same-buffer
re-entry guard, undo/dirty bookkeeping, view notifications, and
CRDT broadcast queueing.
- CC-2: `pmacs.buffer.on_removed(buf, cb)` + idempotent `:remove()`
handle; buffer-local keymaps pruned on removal. Fires for both
`pmacs.buffer.remove` and `.kill` (incl. interactive C-x k);
callback errors logged to *errors* without failing the removal.
- SP-4: `pmacs.buffer.from_file`.
- SP-5: `pmacs.fs.watch` (polling; `:cancel()`/`:is_cancelled()`).
- SP-7: `pmacs.async.yield_to_next_tick` (worker-free next-tick
yield); outline-aggregate repaint now uses it instead of
workers.sleep(0):await(), pinning propagation to one async tick.
- SP-1: `pmacs.editor.move_to_line` (0-based, clamps out-of-range).
- SP-6: `pmacs.outline.query` published by pmacs-outline.
- SP-3: audit rule 15 `reach-around-require-field` (Info).
- CC-3: runtime API-availability documented (docs-only).
Clean audit-review round (M10.11 framing stop-condition pass):
- Finding 1 (fixed): clippy needless_raw_string_hashes blocked
`clippy -D warnings` on both lanes; raw-string delimiter fixed.
- Finding 2 (fixed): fs_watch acceptance test was racy — the
`pending == 1` gate could not distinguish the in-flight baseline
stat from the steady-state poll sleep, so under load the mutation
raced the baseline (~1/3 fail in the default lane). Rewritten to
re-emit a distinct change each pump iteration; 6/6 on the
previously-failing invocation.
- Finding 3 (fixed): documented fs.watch's async-baseline startup
window and size+mtime-granularity detection limit.
- Finding 4 / SP-8 (logged, non-blocking, out of diff): a
pre-existing PTY-lifecycle test timing flake under severe CPU
oversubscription; src/process.rs untouched here.
CC-1's opts-extension-counts question resolved explicitly
(consistent treatment: counted; ceiling raised to fit).
Gate at normal load, both lanes: fmt clean; clippy --all-targets
-D warnings clean; non-crdt lib 1223/0; crdt lib 1377/0;
m8_1/m8_9/m8_10 green.
Not in scope here: v1.0 CHANGELOG body, version bump, the M10.11
Finding-4 (reattach undo) user-facing artifact, and the recorded
two-laptop manual acceptance — tracked as the remaining v1.0 steps.
.gitignore: M*-FRAMING.md added to the internal-only block for
consistency with the M*-AUDIT.md / M*-SHIP-GATE.md siblings.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Land the Model Context Protocol (MCP) integration as a transport binding,
not a built-in feature. Six Lua functions plus userdata methods expose
the substance of three MCP feature areas (resources, tools, prompts), a
notification dispatcher, and a non-trivial AI-assistance example package
that meets the architectural ship gate (spec/pmacs-spec.tex:1572): zero
direct calls into the Rust core, zero special-cased MCP handling outside
the public API, source under 2000 lines of Lua.
The M9.5 -> M9.6 -> M9.7 -> M9.8 layered composition validates the claim
"AI is a transport binding, not a feature" -- pmacs-mcp-ai composes with
pmacs-mcp-prompts.render and inherits notification handling transitively
through M9.7's package, demonstrating that the AI domain is a layer
above MCP, not a thread woven through the core.
Subtask shape:
M9.1 stdio transport + initialize handshake + restart policy
M9.2 resources with in-flight + settled cache and per-uri invalidation
M9.3 tools with isError-vs-JSON-RPC-error semantics + cancellation
M9.4 prompts with required-argument validation
M9.5 notification dispatcher (on_notification, off_notification)
M9.6 tools-as-commands fixture package + 12 audit findings disposed
M9.7 prompts-as-result-buffers fixture package + tree-sitter-md grammar
M9.8 AI-assistance fixture package (363+ LoC; 17/17 acceptance tests)
M9.9 formal package audit -- PASS on all three criteria
M9.10 release: TRANSITION-M9.md + MCP-for-package-authors guide
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Levi Neuwirth