PR #155 review round 2.
Finding 1 (must fix): Q#BP7 item 1 — "growth reaching the live tail
re-arms follow (top -> None), only when no selection is active" — was
never implemented. `at_bottom` is the instantaneous geometric readout
`scroll_offset == 0`, which a still-anchored view satisfies whenever it
happens to be tall enough to reach the tail, so the round-1 assertion
could not see the gap: the next rows the child printed pushed the
anchored view back into history.
`rearm_follow_on_growth` now clears `top` when a viewport-size
declaration makes the view cover the tail and no selection is frozen,
and every size-declaring path (`snapshot_for_view`, `record_view_size`,
`view_status_for_size`) routes through one `declare_view_size` helper so
grid and semantic declarations cannot disagree. `scroll_view` and
`begin_selection` deliberately stay out: they write `top` themselves,
and `scroll_view` already owns the scroll-driven arm.
New acc32b is the pin the review asked for: scroll into history, grow
past the tail, then release a SECOND burst of child output through a
filesystem gate and assert the view moved with it.
Finding 2: the PTY fixtures emitted LF-only output, which staircases
rightward until every row clips to blanks past the viewport width — so
the round-1 anchor assertions compared "" with "" and could not fail.
Both fixtures now emit CRLF, and each anchor comparison is guarded by
`assert!(!top_before.is_empty())`.
Finding 3: acc33's contrast case asserted nothing, and the behavior it
claimed was false as coded. With the re-arm in place it is true and now
asserted: clearing the selection at the same geometry re-arms follow and
leaves the frozen anchor.
Finding 4: `start_run` gated the panel branch on `display == "panel" or
already_in_panel(..)`, so an explicit `display = "current"` lost to the
inference — and that value is the documented user-facing opt-out from
the Stage 3 default flip. Now gated on OMISSION. acc19b gains the
explicit-"current" case.
Finding 5: `window_drag` is a `HashMap<FrontendId, WindowDragState>`, so
a peer's mode-line press can no longer steal or clear another
frontend's in-flight gesture, and concurrent drags are legal. Cleared on
detach. acc30c gains the mode-line-press case.
Minor: `pmacs.window.buffer()` resolves both arms through the acting
frontend using the shared `lookup_window` / `selected_window` validators
rather than re-implementing them beside an ambient `active_buffer_id()`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
PR #155 review round 1.
Finding 1 (must fix): `try_split_active` had no production caller —
`pmacs.window.split_horizontal` / `split_vertical`, and therefore
`C-x 2` / `C-x 3`, still went through plain `split_active`. Splitting a
focused panel made the root wrapper's final child a split rather than
`Leaf(side)`, which both `Layout::compute`'s fixed pass and
`document_subtree` key on: the panel band reverted to 1:1 weight
division and an ordinary window ended up living inside it. Both bindings
now route through the guard, and acc26 asserts through the real Lua
path — a direct core call passes with the guard unwired, which is how it
survived the first round.
Finding 2: the armed-drag early return now checks the arming frontend,
so one frontend's in-flight gesture cannot cancel or swallow another's
mouse events. New acc30c.
Finding 3: `paint_mode_line_graphemes`'s doc block was left heading
`paint_divider_segment`; moved back.
Finding 4: a recompile carries no `display`, so it took the raw switch
and duplicated a panel-placed `*compilation*` into the document window.
`start_run` now detects that the buffer already owns the panel slot.
`pmacs.window.buffer` gained an optional window argument so an adopter
can ask without selecting the panel first. New acc19b.
Stage-2 hazard pins the review asked for, both in `src/daemon.rs`:
a fresh attach while LOCAL is focused in a panel inherits LOCAL's
document buffer, and an initial-target bootstrap whose `after-load`
hook creates and selects a panel still reasserts into a document window.
Minor: dropped listview's dead `p.side`; documented `focus_window`'s
caller-validates contract; `jump_back` restores through `focus_window`
so the "every focus change" contract holds; `params` / `resize` default
to the acting frontend's selected window rather than the ambient one;
widened the flexible-division math to u64 intermediates.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- `listview.open`, `compile.run`, and `pmacs.terminal.open` all take the
same strict `display = "current" | "panel"`, validated before any
buffer, session, process, or wrapper exists. Omission keeps today's
behavior; Stage 3 flips the default.
- `listview.quit` / `compile.quit` delegate to `window.quit` only when
the buffer really is in a side window, so the presentation is deleted
or restored instead of leaving a source buffer stranded in the slot.
- LSP `visit_location`, LSP go-to-definition, and compile `visit_error`
route through `display_file`, so a visit from a panel lands in the
document target and fires its hook with that window active.
- `window.quit`'s Delete arm focuses the revalidated remembered origin.
- Capability fallback discards an accompanying `height` rather than
rejecting the call.
- `window.min-height` clamps a below-floor value on read instead of
refusing the write.
- `tests/bottom_panel_stage1_acceptance.rs`: 42 tests over the framing's
Stage 1 criteria, including the two production `Layout::compute`
callers, the recursive minima, hide/reappear, the final-focus matrix,
quit chains at the depth cap, per-frontend jump origins, the divider,
and a real-PTY pin of Bet B1.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Stage 1 substrate for the bottom-panel arc (docs/bottom-panel-framing.md).
- `WindowParams` (side / fixed_rows / dedicated + implementation-owned
quit action and remembered document origin), `Side`, `QuitAction` with
a bounded replacement history, and the `MIN_WINDOW_OUTER_ROWS` floor.
- `Layout::compute(area, fixed)` allocates fixed rows before dividing the
remainder by weight; both production callers feed the same shared map,
including the peer-presence overlay pass that derives its own rect.
- `subtree_min_rows` / `interactive_min_rows`: the recursive minima, and
`boundary_below` for the shared drag / keyboard resize boundary rule.
- `FrontendView` gains `panel_capable`, `frame_geometry`, and the derived
`panel_hidden`, each spelled explicitly at every construction site.
- `EditorCore`: `primary_document_window`, the non-side target rule,
`display_buffer` + placement policy, `quit_window`, side-window removal
on `kill_buffer`, per-frontend jump entries with origin windows, and the
shared resolve/load-without-switch seam the initial-target bootstrap now
uses too.
- `EditorState`: the panel reconciliation transaction, geometry
declaration, the side-window `dispatch_idle_for` gate, divider paint,
and divider drag.
- `pmacs.window.display / display_file / quit / panel / params /
set_params / resize / display_target`, plus `builtin/runtime/window.lua`
with `window.panel-height`, `window.min-height`, and the resize commands.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Levi Neuwirth