Seven findings, two blocking. Every checkable claim was verified against
c8ec8f3 before being acted on; all seven held.
F1 (blocking) — the rename contract reached one path owner. Verified the
other four: Buffer::set_name documents itself as for "rename operations"
and set_buffer_path never calls it; rec.uri is cached per LSP attachment
and read at ~20 sites; dired's buffers are PATHLESS so no buffer-keyed
rebind can reach them; and the workspace-edit origin restore does not
fail gracefully — find_or_open on a renamed-away path hits
resolve_target_buffer's NotFound arm, which creates an empty path-backed
buffer, so it materializes a phantom at the obsolete path and selects it.
Rev 2 replaces the rebind with EditorCore::reconcile_rename — whole
registry, equality-or-path-component prefix, updates file_path AND name,
called by BOTH the async drain and apply_resource_op so the two cannot
drift — plus a new resource.renamed(old, new) hook so path-keyed Lua
consumers reconcile. lsp.lua recomputes rec.uri, issues didClose/didOpen,
and re-runs ensure_server because #161 keys affinity on project root, so
a cross-root move needs a different server. dired.lua follows its
handles. Verified the ordering the design needs already holds:
_async.tick calls _tick() before resuming any coroutine.
F2 (blocking) — deletion of visited paths had no policy. New §6 decides
all four cases. An unmodified visited buffer is killed; a MODIFIED one
refuses that entry, deliberately diverging from Emacs, because an
orphaned buffer is indistinguishable from a normal one and the next
C-x C-s silently resurrects the file. The check runs before the confirm
so the prompt states the skip. Adds a symmetric resource.deleted hook.
F3 (high) — the key table silently changed approved scope. The parent
lists `w` and contains no `M`. Restored `w` (Q#DR20); `M` is now an
explicit new-scope decision (Q#DR19) that REFUSES symlinks, since the
parent already ruled that the fixture's symlink-perms rejection "carries
over unchanged" and rev 1's warn-after-the-fact contradicted it.
F4 (high) — Q#DR13 contradicted the R contract. Narrowed to three
classes: set-based (D, M, C), flag-based (x), point-based (R, w).
F5 (high) — five falsifying acceptance items added, and the bite matrix
now names six mutations including "dispatch-all-then-await" and "add a
completion source to confirm".
F6 (medium) — take_settled_renames was underspecified. Took the
reviewer's preferred shape: tick returns a structured TickOutcome so
settle identity and rename metadata stay in one transaction.
F7 (2b) — defined the full C command flow with an up-front collision
scan and one confirm (declining copies the non-colliding entries), pinned
remove_dir_all's lstat safety at the primitive, and stated
dired.recursive-deletes as boolean/default false.
Not done, and said so: R is not widened to the marked set. Multi-file
rename needs a target-directory concept that does not exist, so R stays
point-based and is NAMED as a class rather than left an unstated
exception.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0126d2sikA6jZpFin3rtLCSK
Continues docs/dired-framing.md, whose §§6-7 carry the approved shape of
marks and operations. This re-verifies every claim in them against
main @ c8ec8f3 — Stage 1 changed three of the files Stage 2 leans on
most — and adds what the parent did not decide: the batch-execution
contract, the confirmation surface, the staging cut, and acceptance.
Decisions continue the Q#DR scheme from Q#DR12.
Five corrections to the parent, one load-bearing:
- The rename rebind belongs in the drain (the parent's decision, kept)
but CANNOT be implemented in `AsyncRuntime::tick`: AsyncRuntime has no
buffer registry and no core. The seam is `pmacs._async._tick`, one
layer up, which already has `lua` in scope. AsyncRuntime harvests, the
binding rebinds.
- Line references drifted (tick 991 -> 1003, the FsUnit arm 1022 ->
1046, apply_resource_op's raw lookup 3248 -> 3249).
- The frozen fixture has NO mark-and-operate layer — eight commands, two
keys, and its "marks" are wdired text-position marks. So Stage 2 has
no in-repo reference implementation, which the parent's "45 tests pin
dired/wdired behavior" reads as implying it does.
- No y_or_n exists anywhere, and there is no runtime minibuffer.lua at
all — pmacs.minibuffer is Rust-only.
- `remove_blocking` already deletes files AND empty directories, so
`remove_dir_all` is needed only for non-empty ones. This is what makes
the staging cut possible.
Also carries a verified pre-existing defect, confirmed by probe rather
than inferred: a fire-and-forget non-stream job leaks its pending entry
forever (only stream eviction and take_result remove entries, and the
Lua handle has no __gc). Named as a deferral. The same probe establishes
that a settled job IS still readable at drain time, which is what makes
the rebind design sound.
Recommends splitting Stage 2 at the "needs a new Rust primitive" line:
2a is the mark layer plus d/x/D/R/M on the five ops that already exist,
plus the rename correctness fix; 2b adds mkdir/copy/remove_dir_all and
+/C and recursive delete. The reasoning is that 2a's only Rust is the
rename rebind, whose design is subtle enough to deserve a reviewer's
whole attention.
Coherence impact per COHERENCE.md §20 is stated in §0.5, including the
honest part: Stage 2 must add a `rename_paths` field to `PendingJob`,
which is a one-off where §9 wants a general owner/purpose — though a
side map, the alternative, is worse by §9's own diagnosis of the
parse-job link. 2b grows the closed JobKind enum 12 -> 15.
Touches only this file: docs/active-work.md and docs/agent-handoff.md
are held by the open docs PR #169.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0126d2sikA6jZpFin3rtLCSK
Levi Neuwirth