Opens the GUI arc. The framing and the lane are this branch's FIRST
commit, which is both the arc's own rule for every PR in it and the
reason this branch exists today rather than after #227: the document
spent two review rounds as an untracked file in one worktree, and
uncommitted work does not travel between machines.
Revision 3 closed two blocking findings from the second round.
The closure comparison is falsifiable now. Revision 2 ordered its
grades but never said how a cell acquires one, and its "normalize to
the head grade" rule mis-graded exactly the rows it was written for:
journey steps 7 and 11 both read "works but undiscoverable" and would
both have graded `Works`, with the undiscoverability demoted to prose
that cannot block closure --- while discoverability IS the substance of
steps 4, 7 and 11. Grades now have observable criteria, a compound step
takes the minimum over declared subclaims, and the table carries three
columns (local TUI, attached TUI, GPU) compared against the local TUI.
Half B's dependency graph was inverted. Viewport facts are ABOUT a
window, and whether a semantic window is a daemon projection or a
frontend-local object is what the model stage decides --- so the facts
cannot be designed first. Revision 2 also had a framing-only stage
handing the sidebar geometry no stage shipped. The order is now model
framing, then the viewport/identity substrate, then splits plus
IMPLEMENTED side geometry, then the sidebar.
Q#GA4 through Q#GA12 are ruled and closed.
Four claims this revision inherited were wrong and are corrected with
their sources rather than quietly dropped: the daemon has always
emitted `InstanceSignal::Bell` (daemon.rs:1373), so Bell is
consumer-only; the GPU NEVER consumes daemon `view_top`, which the
backlog states in as many words; Q#DS9 scopes save AND restore, so
Stage 4b owns both; and the protocol ceiling is v23, not v22 --- #228
raised it after #221, and revisions 2 and 3 both read the range at the
audit anchor without re-reading it afterwards.
The three-column claim is narrowed to what it can support. The attached
TUI handshakes `semantic_render: false` and never consumes the
SemanticFrame family, so a shared GPU/attached gap cannot implicate the
semantic wire. The columns separate local from daemon-attached, and
attached-grid from semantic; source tracing still assigns ownership.
Q#GA6's citation is corrected to the one site that matters: local and
attached document events converge on the document handler, whose only
wheel arms are Up/Down at editor.rs:3189. The sites revision 3 cited
were terminal-content paths.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016bqGA6s9tTUFzYpbeW3tai
Levi Neuwirth
adf9611d10